Most Over-rated Player from 2010

Originally posted by 9er_84:

Originally posted by jones49:

Originally posted by bigmike55:
Alex Smith

That would be 2005 - present

+1
Dont know why people keep giving him chances...

Neither do I. You would think 6 losing seasons with this kid at QB would be enough.

gotta be goldson... We all expected him to build on 2009, but instead it was quite the oppposite. He whiffed tackles, made bad reads, and created very few turnovers. Considering it was his contract year, it was a terrible year for Goldson

Can't really choose one of these guys because my expectations were not that high for any of them.

Nate Clements--down the year before.
Adam Snyder--fill in--plays any OLine pos except C.
Dashon Goldson--had not shown consistency and was a crap shoot.
Demetric Evans--did not expect him to unseat any of our DLine.
Parys Haralson--has not impressed, inconsistent.
Will James--picked up for depth.
Chilo Rachel--showed promise rookie year, regressed 2nd year.
David Carr--why?

If I had to choose one it would be Clements because he has been very good in the past.

Patrick Willis. He should be on the list.

He did not have a good season.

I expected better from Crabtree. Too many drops.

Originally posted by lamontb:
Who rated Will James?

My answer is Joe Staley. Just an all out disappointment to me. Instead of being on a pro bowl level he was below average. this thread seems like deja vu.

wow i'd rate a lot more than staley. he was doing fine then got injured.

Originally posted by ishkabibel:
I expected better from Crabtree. Too many drops.

i agree, but i figure yr 3 will be his breakout yr

Originally posted by wailers15:

Originally posted by ishkabibel:
I expected better from Crabtree. Too many drops.

i agree, but i figure yr 3 will be his breakout yr

Agree...and hope!