Originally posted by TX9R:
Originally posted by FILTHpigskin:
Originally posted by TX9R:
Originally posted by msallaz51:
Originally posted by GlenCoffeesNuts:
Young made things happen with his incredible tools such as his quick feet and strong arm. Joe made it happen with magic. My vote is for Joe.
Joe could make reads faster, react quicker and was more accurate. The most impressive thing Joe did was to lead a team of nobodies in '81' to the superbowl. He was later blessed with for talent to win his other 3.
The biggest thing is playing under pressure. Steve was horrible when the game was on the line and the stakes were highest, Joe was at his best. If you look at Steve's biggest wins, the 2 against Dallas in 94 and the SB, at no point was there any doubt, the Niners controlled from the outset so he was loose and played well. now once he won the SB that changed a little, but before he was always tight and threw crucial INTs at the worst time.
All of this.
Some people, I guess, forget how much Young choked... especially when he first became a starter for the 49ers. Not that he wasn't great, eventually.
Joe Montana was just on a whole other level.
Most people who were there during that transition period would agree. Now over a decade later Young is remembered much more fondly but I can remember thinking in 94, if we don;t beat Dallas this year, they're going to run Steve out of town.
This. But remember, the fans were ready to run Montana out of town in '87 and '88 too ... It was QB carousel in '88 until Montana got healthy and led the team through the playoffs. Of course, he pretty much silenced all critics by winning in '88 and '89. Young's teams couldn't beat Favre's teams or Aikman's teams (save for the one year we bought Deion Sanders in '94 and the "Owens, Owens, Owens!" wild card game in '98) Too many missed opportunities for Young, IMO.
I vote Montana, if only because he threw the prettiest ball I've ever seen - accurate as hell and with touch. With so much emphasis on Cover 2 play now, I think Joe would eat that stuff up, throwing to windows in perfect timing. Besides, Montana won 2 SBs without Rice. He could make legends out of very talented players like Davis and Crabtree ... players with far more athletic ability than anyone Montana played with (excluding the GOAT).