Originally posted by redrathman:Originally posted by rawdel:Originally posted by boriken_9er:Originally posted by D-NOTTE:
I prayed he learned something from Nolan/Hostler/Raye, btu I guess he is sealing his fate to Alex also. Not to bash but if nothing else his play does not push the offense to be better so in my opinion not a leader...
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/players/playerpage/552642/alex-smith
None of those coaches failed because of AS, they fail because they all sucked.
Smith sucks. It's been six years and he still hasn't proved ANYTHING. Yeah, I understand he was dealt a bad hand, but the organization has to know when to throw in the cards. I don't think BW can resurrect his career at this point.
Has been six solid years of healthy starting though?
Alex Smith has seen one full season without injury or interference in his six seasons with the 49ers. Smith has attempted 1323 passes in his career. It took Steve Young eight years to attempt as many passes before the 49ers gave him an opportunity to start full-time.
I understand your frustration, but using the six year argument makes you look foolish.
Steve Young was sitting behind Joe Montana. Not Tim Rattay, not JTO, not Hill. BTW, Smith lost out to 2/3 guys in QB competition during training camp. If anything, making these types of comments make YOU look foolish.