Originally posted by fly15:
Originally posted by al49erfan:
Originally posted by SJniner7:
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
we have the talent we need a new platcaller now we have to let smith air it out and we need some protecction up from im onna get bashed for this but smith didnt have a awful game i would give him a D as a grade but playcalling and coaching was just horrible just like the seahawks game
Not sure what game you were watching, but he was off.... plain and simple.
a) The pick was right in the CB's numbers (great pass to the CB by the way). Crabtree did slip, but Smith just put it there. A good QB would see it wasn't open.
b) Pass to Ziegler at goal line should have been lobbed, but instead was a terrible high velocity short throw.
c) I think 50% of his screen passes were off
d) Can you blame tipped balls on Crabtree, Gore, and Morgan? There is one common denominator amongst all of these players. Bad passes from Smith...
I do not care that our backup situation sucks. If Smith resumes his role, he will likely save face against crappy teams. Then we will be stuck with him in 2011. It is obvious he needs to take the money and run all the way home to his hot wife...
That int was not smiths fault. It looked like a timing route and if carbtree had not slipped he would have been there. Alex smith actually threw to an area where crabtree should have been something that he almost never does... i dont give that one on Alex...
I do agree that he played poorly, but so did the o-line, defense, and then the coaching staff did not have the team prepaired...
c'mmon dude, watch the game again, Alex is the problem, he needs to go to the bench
I did watch the game dude.... Alex smith struggled I agree. What happens next? Put in David Carr? Like it or not Smith gives us the best chance to win. Carr is horrible, as was said a couple years ago the fans think the best player is the back up QB.
Did you want to bench alex last week? When he has time the team has played well almost had no time and when he did he took what the defense gave him... Is Alex the answer? No he isnt after 6 years it is easy to see. But by putting in david carr it does nothing, unless the line can block and the coaching staff puts the team in position to succeed.
[ Edited by al49erfan on Sep 26, 2010 at 2:51 PM ]