Originally posted by fly15:Originally posted by Ceadderman:Originally posted by Kalen49ers:Originally posted by Ceadderman:Originally posted by jacklegniner:
Crabtree should get a ton of looks per game. he has made mistakes but he is a dynamic player. smith was throwing pics long before crabtree got there. dhb comparison is a joke. comparing crabtree to nicks is crazy as well. nicks has eli manning throwing to him. we have soon to be cut alex smith.
Yeah Smith was throwing Picks before Tree got to this team. But the Picks he threw were mostly tip ups.
Four Passes to Tree wound up in the hands of the other guys BECAUSE of Tree. Not in spite of Tree. You fall to the turf once in a game fine sh!t happens. Tree didn't adjust for the surface and it cost Smith. Not once but twice. Then Tree also had the ball hit him in the Pads cause he took his eyes away before he looked it in. And instead of cutting his route off on the break he went to the sideline and Smith threw on the timed route only no Receiver was there and it looks like Smith is the incompetent Player.
I agree that we should throw to him more but in this case you cannot blame Smith a guy who's 9er career hinges on a good Season for not throwing Tree's direction. If I'm the QB Tree would not have been on the field for a few games until we worked out the chemistry issue that followed us from the Preseason into the Regular Season. Especially after that abysmal Home Performance.
You want to see Trust issues happen, it happens after games like the 1st three.
~Ceadder
Can't blame all those on Crabtree, Smith is throwing absolute bullets when Crabtree is 4 yards away from him. No receiver is gonna catch those.
If that was Hill or Morgan you would (rightfully) be on they ass for it. It's Crabtree and "nobody" can reasonably catch that. You're nuts. Favre throws bullets that close to his Receivers and they DO catch that.
But now that it's Smith throwing that Pass, nobody can catch it.
Tree never saw a Pass from Shaun Hill so he doesn't have velocity to blame. He's caught bullets from Alex before this should not be an issue. He took his eyes off the ball and it caromed off his right shoulder pad into the arms of the Defense. That is on Tree.
~Ceadder
sir, he did catch a pass from noddle
I don't recall this. Please show me. Not that I don't believe you but I don't recall him catching one Pass from Noodle in that 1st game.
~Ceadder