Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
One last time: McCloughan isn't/wasn't the only voice in the personnel department. Not much (if anything) will change going into the draft. Calm the hell down.
Indicative of bigger problems though imo.
There are 305 users in the forums
Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
One last time: McCloughan isn't/wasn't the only voice in the personnel department. Not much (if anything) will change going into the draft. Calm the hell down.
Originally posted by GEEK:Originally posted by NickSh49:
I have never, and will never, trust PRO FOOTBALL WEEKLY.
RealFootball365 may be a better source for information compared to PFW...
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
One last time: McCloughan isn't/wasn't the only voice in the personnel department. Not much (if anything) will change going into the draft. Calm the hell down.
He was the GM and had final say in draft picks. So he was the voice in the personnel department.
Originally posted by ObePwnD:Originally posted by SanDiego49er:Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
One last time: McCloughan isn't/wasn't the only voice in the personnel department. Not much (if anything) will change going into the draft. Calm the hell down.
He was the GM and had final say in draft picks. So he was the voice in the personnel department.
Draft wise, what did he do do in the last 2-years? I know you're gonna say Crabtree but my 13-yr old son could have made that pick at the 10 spot. Maybe the fact that he was canned so close to the draft had everything to do with his approach toward the draft. It seems to me that Sing and McCloughan were bumping heads, and differences of philosophy pertaining to drafting was the main reason. IMO
Originally posted by ObePwnD:Originally posted by SanDiego49er:Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
One last time: McCloughan isn't/wasn't the only voice in the personnel department. Not much (if anything) will change going into the draft. Calm the hell down.
He was the GM and had final say in draft picks. So he was the voice in the personnel department.
Draft wise, what did he do do in the last 2-years? I know you're gonna say Crabtree but my 13-yr old son could have made that pick at the 10 spot. Maybe the fact that he was canned so close to the draft had everything to do with his approach toward the draft. It seems to me that Sing and McCloughan were bumping heads, and differences of philosophy pertaining to drafting was the main reason. IMO
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:Originally posted by GEEK:Originally posted by NickSh49:
I have never, and will never, trust PRO FOOTBALL WEEKLY.
RealFootball365 may be a better source for information compared to PFW...
Please. PFW's been around for 40+ years. Who knows how much of their story is accurate, but they're not a bunch of charlatans just trying to make a name for themselves.
Originally posted by MBee:Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:Originally posted by GEEK:Originally posted by NickSh49:
I have never, and will never, trust PRO FOOTBALL WEEKLY.
RealFootball365 may be a better source for information compared to PFW...
Please. PFW's been around for 40+ years. Who knows how much of their story is accurate, but they're not a bunch of charlatans just trying to make a name for themselves.
They certainly seem to have no problem using large portions of another writer's work and yet not credit that writer or the publication for which he works.
Originally posted by MBee:Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:Originally posted by GEEK:Originally posted by NickSh49:
I have never, and will never, trust PRO FOOTBALL WEEKLY.
RealFootball365 may be a better source for information compared to PFW...
Please. PFW's been around for 40+ years. Who knows how much of their story is accurate, but they're not a bunch of charlatans just trying to make a name for themselves.
They certainly seem to have no problem using large portions of another writer's work and yet not credit that writer or the publication for which he works.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:Originally posted by ObePwnD:Originally posted by SanDiego49er:Originally posted by bigtony2tone:
One last time: McCloughan isn't/wasn't the only voice in the personnel department. Not much (if anything) will change going into the draft. Calm the hell down.
He was the GM and had final say in draft picks. So he was the voice in the personnel department.
Draft wise, what did he do do in the last 2-years? I know you're gonna say Crabtree but my 13-yr old son could have made that pick at the 10 spot. Maybe the fact that he was canned so close to the draft had everything to do with his approach toward the draft. It seems to me that Sing and McCloughan were bumping heads, and differences of philosophy pertaining to drafting was the main reason. IMO
He's the one who set us up with 2 first rounders this year. 2010 has to be to his credit as well.
Originally posted by Memphis9er:Originally posted by MBee:Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:Originally posted by GEEK:Originally posted by NickSh49:
I have never, and will never, trust PRO FOOTBALL WEEKLY.
RealFootball365 may be a better source for information compared to PFW...
Please. PFW's been around for 40+ years. Who knows how much of their story is accurate, but they're not a bunch of charlatans just trying to make a name for themselves.
They certainly seem to have no problem using large portions of another writer's work and yet not credit that writer or the publication for which he works.
This is why they are sometimes accurate, but that is no excuse for plagiarism. I do not think Scott has been as bad as some of the armchair GM's on this site claim.
Originally posted by WINiner:Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
It's just the Yorks being stupid and self destructing the team like they always do. Only the Yorks could come up with a plan to get rid of the GM 5 weeks before the draft with no replacement on hand. They could have done it at the very beginning of the offseason and may have been able to land the likes of Holmgren or Shannahan in the role if they were willing to pay for it. But they aren't willing to pay for it and everything the Yorks do is reactionary and spur of the moment with no forward planning. It's how the roll. Destroy the team and figure out the consequences later. It's how they have rolled for a decade.
You don't get it. They are not looking to bring someone from outside the organization in to replace Scott. THAT'S why it doesn't matter that he was canned 5 weeks before the draft. The Niners are going to make Baalk, Gamble, or Marathe GM and the team will continue forward with little change in the short term.
This in my opinion is not at all reactionary or spur of the moment, but a culmination of discretions that led to the change. I don't think for a moment that the management had any interest at all in GM candidates outside the team earlier this off-season. I think if anything, the team waited too long.
Originally posted by susweel:
Best article so far about the situation.