Let's get some facts straight:
Jones cannot be IR'd or he is automatically out for the season. Jones cannot be PUP'd because he reported to camp healthy, and his injury is NFL football-related. Therefore, Jones MUST BE on the Final 53 roster for Game 1, or he is out for the year. Jones was also one of the most impressive WR in camp until his shoulder injury, diving to catch a pass. Note that his injury does not affect his wheels. so he should be productive very quickly, once he returns.
Crabtree, if he signs, CAN BE PUP'd. My understanding is that PUP players do count in the TC 80-player roster limit, but DO NOT COUNT against the regular season 53-man limit. This is a key consideration in the current CBA. PUP players can be added to the 53-player roster between Games 6-10 (or they must be IR'd for the remainder of the season). Crabtree can attend team meetings, including Sullivan's WR positional meetings and film reviews, but Crabtree cannot practice with the team during PUP time. He can get his playbook. He can probably, informally, run pass patterns with his "friend", Nate Davis, pitching him passes at a local high school (not a Niner practice or Niner facility), during his PUP time. No, Jerry Sullivan ( Niner management) probably can't "observe" such informal work directly, but he could have someone video tape these pitch-and-catch sessions, and then critique Crabtree "off-line". So why might the club possibly PUP Crabtree and go through such machinations? So that the club would not have to dedicate TWO WR spots on the Final 53 to players who CANNOT CONTRIBUTE in these early games.
Because neither can contribute initially, Jones and Crabtree are tied together, as it relates to precious WR roster spots.
I wouldn't be surprised to see things go down like this:
Final 53 for Game 1: Bruce, Morgan, Battle, Hill, Jones
PUP: Crabtree (activated Week 6, via a Final 53 roster player who has gone to IR)
PS: Zeigler (yes, he is still PS-eligible)
CUT: Spurlock (or kept if there is room for 6 WR, which I doubt)
[ Edited by jimbagg on Aug 28, 2009 at 10:55 AM ]