The EDGE Dyaeshon Hall thread

Originally posted by SisterFister:
I hate to be a debbie downer, but the the Panthers fans feel the same way about Hall as we did about Joe Williams. Hall got hurt last year but came into this season healthy. Fans expected him to step up and apparently he did not show up at all in practice and in preseason games. He lost a roster spot to an undrafted free agent.

With all that being said, what would you say to the fans of the team that signed Williams to their practice squad?

Good luck with that is what I would say. That should be your expectation with Hall. Maybe a miracle happens. Maybe he improves his motor and upper body strength, two things the Panthers were really looking for him to address.

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by SisterFister:
I hate to be a debbie downer, but the the Panthers fans feel the same way about Hall as we did about Joe Williams. Hall got hurt last year but came into this season healthy. Fans expected him to step up and apparently he did not show up at all in practice and in preseason games. He lost a roster spot to an undrafted free agent.

With all that being said, what would you say to the fans of the team that signed Williams to their practice squad?

Good luck with that is what I would say. That should be your expectation with Hall. Maybe a miracle happens. Maybe he improves his motor and upper body strength, two things the Panthers were really looking for him to address.

This is exactly why I said two year project, except I'm even lower now on Williams than I ever would've been on Hall. RB is pretty much plug and play and I have virtually no faith in any player that player RB in college and goes to the practice squad. With Hall, we shall see. Two seasons and hopefully we have something. Of course, this takes place provided that he actually is showing some type of growth, effort, etc in that time frame.

Originally posted by Giedi:
Boy, he sounds like another Attaochu clone, lots of injuries, and not much production. HOpe the change of scenery does him some good, but odds are that he'll be gone (and probably so will Pita) next year when (or if) the 49ers actually focus on the edge rusher position in the draft next year.

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
we did it!!!

thank you for making a move Saleh

Originally posted by ChazBoner:

Originally posted by Giedi:
Boy, he sounds like another Attaochu clone, lots of injuries, and not much production. HOpe the change of scenery does him some good, but odds are that he'll be gone (and probably so will Pita) next year when (or if) the 49ers actually focus on the edge rusher position in the draft next year.

the pick needs to be #99 from Florida State. He is, the one. I know because I watched about 10 minutes of last weekend's game.

Originally posted by LarryLestersBuns:

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
we did it!!!

thank you for making a move Saleh

Saleh?

Originally posted by SisterFister:
I hate to be a debbie downer, but the the Panthers fans feel the same way about Hall as we did about Joe Williams. Hall got hurt last year but came into this season healthy. Fans expected him to step up and apparently he did not show up at all in practice and in preseason games. He lost a roster spot to an undrafted free agent.

With all that being said, what would you say to the fans of the team that signed Williams to their practice squad?

Good luck with that is what I would say. That should be your expectation with Hall. Maybe a miracle happens. Maybe he improves his motor and upper body strength, two things the Panthers were really looking for him to address.

Originally posted by Ensatsu:

Originally posted by SisterFister:
I hate to be a debbie downer, but the the Panthers fans feel the same way about Hall as we did about Joe Williams. Hall got hurt last year but came into this season healthy. Fans expected him to step up and apparently he did not show up at all in practice and in preseason games. He lost a roster spot to an undrafted free agent.

With all that being said, what would you say to the fans of the team that signed Williams to their practice squad?

Good luck with that is what I would say. That should be your expectation with Hall. Maybe a miracle happens. Maybe he improves his motor and upper body strength, two things the Panthers were really looking for him to address.

yes, I am reading that he has an inconsistent motor.

I feel a lot better about that than I do for Joe Williams though. He just seemed to have mental issues holding him back. You can't teach heart.

Originally posted by LVJay:
This dude might be inconsistent, but that should mean he is sometimes pretty good..... Marsh is consistent at being mediocre

Originally posted by LVJay:

This dude might be inconsistent, but that should mean he is sometimes pretty good..... Marsh is consistent at being mediocre

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by LVJay:
This dude might be inconsistent, but that should mean he is sometimes pretty good..... Marsh is consistent at being mediocre

Yeah, Marsh is poo poo - I think I'd rather take my chances with Hall.

Originally posted by simplyfloyd:
Haha yeah. He said he would get to the quarterback. Did he even come within 5 feet of cousins yes Steffany? Shaking his hand at the end doesn't count

Originally posted by father49er:

SuperbBowl!