Originally posted by GNielsen:
I'm not telling you or anyone anything. I'm giving my opinion. All I'm saying is that a Niner fan wants what's best for the Niners. A Chiefs fan wants what's best for the Chiefs. A Seahawk fan wants what's best for the Seahawks. Am I wrong about that?
My only point is that if you'd rather see the Chiefs go 16-0 than 8-8, then by virtue of that, you'd rather the Chiefs win than the Niners get a better pick. Do you see anything wrong with that logic? If you do, I'd like to see the reasoning.
And, if you are a fan of more than one team, then the question is which team are you MORE of a fan for? If you're MORE of a Chiefs fan than a Niners fan, that's fine in my opinion. This is, after all, a Chiefs thread, so it's not surprising to find Chiefs fans here. But MY OPINION IS that if you'd rather see the Chiefs win a lot of games than the NIners get the best possible draft pick, don't at the same time pretend the NIners are more important to you than the Chiefs. I'd call that hypocrisy. And again, that's just my opinion.
I see something wrong with this logic, or at least with the connected logic you've applied which is that preferring more chief wins to a slight increase in 49er draft pick
value means one is more a fan of the Chiefs than the 49ers.
As a parallel, if you could choose between finding $5 yourself, or having a person who is in a bad financial situation find $1000, which do you choose? By your logic, someone who chooses the latter is more concerned with some stranger than with themselves, and so any real person would take the $5.
There are degrees at play between a team winning games, energizing a fanbase, critical validation and career success for a player who should be much admired in these parts...and a team getting to pick a few spots higher in a draft. They are not equal outcomes.
If someone wants to cheer for the Chiefs in a head-to-head with SF, with the same outcome on the line (e.g. a super bowl, or both teams needing to win to make the playoffs), then you can legitimately claim they are more Chief Fan than Niner Fan. In this situation, you cannot.