Originally posted by NCommand:
Sorry, just getting back to this. I'll take 98%. Haha!
Personally, I would not have kept Whitner THIS year...I come from the Bill Walsh school where you let guys go a year or two before their twilight (but always have the "next man up" training in the background). Whitner was a salient issue last year - he gave up the points; he was the "break" in the bend-but-don't-break defense. And while we highlighted that it wasnt his fault completely, he owns much of it. For instance, if you continually get beat in the EZ (inside the RZ) on simple seam routes, you MAY want to practice that or talk to Fangio about assignments (he is a leader); like, maybe move a taller and more physical Goldson over the TE or taller/stronger slot WR (Jones/Boldin). I'm not seeing an old dog learning new tricks here either (still 2 ro 3 steps late on coverage in the middle of the field/EZ). I probably would have seriously considered, like Baalke, a veteran like Reed where you'd have better coverage skills and still have that veteran leadership. I would NOT have gone 2 rookies back there. I could see for over 2 years now that coverage with Whitner is a major issue (with or without Reid next to him).
So that answer alone answers your original question...he'd be gone after this year (large salary too). I'm no sure what Baalke has in store here but usually he has a guy training in the wings as well but right now, I don't think that guy is on the team. It may end up being a FA pickup or a high draft pick to get younger/cheaper.
I never was a fan of that particular Walsh philosophy. Jerry Rice would've played 4-5 Pro bowl caliber seasons for ANOTHER TEAM had we continued that. Much as I loved Walsh, he wasn't as flawless as the nostalgics have made him out to be - but that's another debate.
As for Whitner/Safties, well being a strong safety obviously means you're on the strong(TE) side - which is kind of the reason that 2% need for a SS still exists. You need someone bigger than a corner and faster than a LB to cover the Grahams & Gates & Gronks (oh my!). I think the wipe out of the SS will be complete when these teams abandon the TE in favor of the 3wides and go full Aaron Rodgers.
I've always felt Whitner was a huge liability in coverage and I cringe anytime it seems like he might end up in a one on one coverage situation. However, his locker room and team presence is immeasurable. His in-game IQ - forcing the GB WR to land out of bounds and forcing another WR to land IN-bounds (I think that was the same game) are just a few examples. Not to mention what he has meant to young Eric Reid. Right now we have to settle for him getting beat by Graham and just hope he knocks the s**t out of him to cause an incompletion or fumble.
Still, I'm torn about next season. I'm not sure I like the thought of pairing a 2nd year safety (Reid) next to a possible rookie.