Originally posted by WINiner:
Originally posted by English:
Originally posted by valrod33:
Originally posted by WINiner:
We had better offer 17, or this franchise FAILS. Ben is an unquestioned star in this league. The Steelers are dumb for trying to trade him and the Niners are fools if they don't bend over for the Steelers to acquire him.
Seriously i doubt they trade him, i think they are just using this to scare Ben.
And if they do, I am not convinced 17 will do it. Or anywhere near it.
McNabb traded for a 2nd, Holmes traded for a 5th. I would think 17 would do it, although now that I think about it I'm pretty sure you can't trade picks that were not originally yours.. If not go ahead and offer 13 instead. If it takes more, then offer 13 and our 3rd, or 13 and next years 2.
Being open to trading a franchise QB is not the way to go about things if you are trying to curb certain behavior. I mean look how quickly things blew up in Denver with Cutler at the mention of trading him. Ben has the upper hand here. I don't imagine he really cares if he stays in Pitt. I mean there are MANY places I would rather live personally. I mean it's not like Pitt is a yearly contender like say the Pats or Colts are, although I suppose they are the next best thing.
I hate roethlisberger but you are gonna make me defend him.
Mcnabb is not a Super Bowl winning QB, Ben won 2
Mcnabb is a choke artist, Ben has come up big in big games
and for Holmes, you cant compare a WR to QB at all
So to even think that the price for roethlisberger would be cheap just because those guys went for cheap is just crazy
and did you really just say that Pitt is not a contender every year?
i dont think you really know what you are talking about