Troy Smith to Start. 49ers Coaches are clueless.

Dec 22, 2010 at 4:52 PM


Jason LaCanfora, the same guy who reported that Alex Smith was going to start week 12, is reporting that TROY Smith will be the starting quarterback in the do-or-die game against the St. Louis Rams.

According to Matt Barrows, Singletary said he's told the quarterbacks which one is going to start but is not releasing that information. I almost looked past this weak attempt at gamesmanship except for one critical fact: Sing has yet to tell Mike Johnson who is going to start.

[quote=Mike Johnson]No, we have not finalized [the starting quarterback] yet so we're still trying to figure that out. We're practicing both guys, and that decision will be made later.
If Mike Johnson were the janitor, it wouldn't be a big deal. But Mike Johnson is the offensive coordinator. You know the guy who is tasked with maximizing his quarterback's talents and developing an offensive game plan.

So to recap: Head Coach Mike Singletary has told the players who is going to start, but the player's coordinator is out of the loop. Mike Johnson needs to develop a winning game plan that maximizes his team's strengths, but he is unsure which quarterback will be playing.

Mike Singletary has basically ensured that Mike Johnson is flying blind for the arguably most important December game since 2002. Maybe having a clueless offensive coordinator at this stage is all part of the master plan. I mean, who wants to draft 21 in the 2011 draft anyway.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


9 Comments

  • David Pallas
    Join me in urging management that Mike Singletary must go! Facebook: Fire Mike Singletary
    Dec 26, 2010 at 1:38 PM
    0
  • TIM
    Oscar: You do know that Mike Johnson DID know who was starting but was simply under orders to not tell the media ? Instead of saying he didn't know when he was asked over and over again,he should have said for the media to stop asking him and go ask the HC.
    Dec 25, 2010 at 2:36 PM
    0
    Response: The responses were way too different for me to believe that.
  • CanadianFaithful
    This situation wreaks!! There is so little communication in this 9er organisation and we can all see it. There is little doubt that the HC & OC are on different pages in the playbook on every call. My take on the situation....a clear cut power struggle is present and both are stubborn. The players are the ones that are losing here. There is no way they can win with the leaders of the team pushing to show the other is wrong. The whole coaching staff has to go and a new culture of teamwork and winning needs to be fostered going forward for this team to be successful. All the cancer needs to be killed and start fresh with positive winning people. The problem is that this is the way the Yorks have fostered the culture. Will it change with new coaching? Maybe Sing is the stand-up guy in the whole situation? Who knows? I am not in the building all day. Just talking from past experiences.
    Dec 24, 2010 at 9:40 AM
    0
  • 49erfaninPA
    When the decision to switch back to Alex was made, we were told that this was done because Alex knew more of the playbook and Troy could not run all the plays. Using the entire playbook gave Mike Johnson more flexibility in play calling. Now, with the switch back to Troy, are we supposed to believe that he now knows all of the playbook? Or does MJ not know all the plays himself? Just a very strange situation. A team with two QBs is a team with none.
    Dec 23, 2010 at 6:57 PM
    0
    Response: I think Sing is enamored with Troy's leadership and Mike Johnson wants to have the flu offense at his disposal.
  • The Camper
    As I understand it the game plan is put together monday and players start learning it on tuesday. Anybody else see a problem here? Mike Johnson needs to shape a game plan towards the talents of the starter, are you telling me that there is no difference between the two QB's in Mike Sigletary's mind? WOW just WOW! The fact that his staff does not know shocks me, I can't image that it is true. Johnson must know. I can't believe Singletary is that stupid! If this is true it explains a lot about this season!
    Dec 23, 2010 at 6:24 PM
    0
    Response: If Johnson and Sing had the same story, then maybe. But their stories differ too much. I really do believe the OC is in the dark.
  • Hearstfan
    This is ridiculous. I'm not a huge Alex fan, and yes we can't expect much improvement from him. But changing back and forth is absolutely the best way to ensure NEITHER guy gets comfortable. RIDICULOUS. I'm so fed up with this miserable excuse for coaching and ownership, I feel like "just lose the darn game already" and put us fans out of our misery!
    Dec 23, 2010 at 5:24 PM
    0
  • rjberryx
    Quite naive of you to think Sing and Mike Johnson didn't talk about who was going to start. You just weren't in on the conversation - imagine that. To your point about gamesmanship; the game was to keep RAMS from planning which was working okay until someone leaked the starting QB on Wednesday. Nice goin' whoever that was. Coaches are not clueless but are really struggling and being second guessed with every poster who thinks he is a sports writer. Sing will go but this season has not been all his fault - although he is responsible.
    Dec 23, 2010 at 2:21 PM
    0
    Response: If Mike Johnson, the chief offensive architect cannot match his story to that of the head coach then there ares some serious problems. Sing said a decision was made, and conferred to the starters, a full day before Johnson said they were undecided. Sing is the head coach and he would be the first to admit that responsibility for this teams performance begins and ends with him.
  • Dallas Niner fan.
    If you have to evaluate both QB's to death with no clear cut winner it just proves that the Niners do not have a decent QB. Plus you have a head coach that cannot make a decision. Being wishy washey is not the sign of a good leader. Its as simple as that.
    Dec 23, 2010 at 6:15 AM
    0
    Response: Agreed. For someone who values leadership, Sing sure doesn't seem like a leader right now.
  • The_Real_Randy
    Could be worse. When Sing neglected to say which QB was starting my fear was that we'd have Carr under center.
    Dec 22, 2010 at 8:06 PM
    0
    Response: I guess we're lucky that the magic 8-ball landed on one of the Smiths.

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Troy Aikman on 49ers: If I could hire any coach, Kyle Shanahan would be that guy

By David Bonilla
Nov 21

Hall of Fame quarterback Troy Aikman, who was in the broadcast booth for Monday night's game in Mexico City between the San Francisco 49ers and Arizona Cardinals, said he is "a huge buyer" of the former as a legitimate threat in the NFC. The team is filled with star power and playmakers, evident by its dominant 38-10 primetime win. However, that's not necessarily the main reason the analyst has believed in the Niners for several years. "A big reason for that is because of [head coach] Kyle Shanahan," Aikman said on ESPN's SportsCenter after the game. "If I was in a position to hire a head coach, and I could hire anybody I wanted, Kyle Shanahan would be that guy. The way he's able to utilize his personnel ... I think, as we mentioned in our game, John Lynch, their general



Steve Young believes Kyle Shanahan's conservative play-calling is due to 49ers QB Jimmy Garoppolo

By David Bonilla
Nov 17

Is Kyle Shanahan's play-calling too conservative? Many watching Sunday night's game against the Los Angeles Chargers might say it is. The San Francisco 49ers offense scores an average of 22 points per game, ranking 18th in the NFL. Coincidentally, that's exactly how many points they scored in the win over the Chargers. Most would think the 49ers should score more on offense rather than stalling and settling for field goals. There is too much talent on the roster with playmakers like Deebo Samuel, Brandon Aiyuk, George Kittle, Kyle Juszczyk, Jauan Jennings, and recently-added running back Christian McCaffrey. On Monday, Shanahan was asked if he felt his offense wasn't clicking and if anything could be done to increase production in the second half of the season.



49ers-Cardinals Injury Report: No Arik Armstead, Samson Ebukam at practice in Colorado

By David Bonilla
Nov 17

The San Francisco 49ers are preparing for their Week 11 contest against the Arizona Cardinals on Monday night at Estadio Azteca in Mexico City. This week, the team is practicing at the United States Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, about an hour south of Denver, to get acclimated to the altitude. Head coach Kyle Shanahan has already ruled out defensive tackle Javon Kinlaw for Monday's game. Kinlaw remains on injured reserve due to a setback in his surgically reconstructed knee. He did not make the trip with the team. Also missing from Thursday's practice, the first of the week, was defensive lineman Arik Armstead. He is dealing with foot and



49ers Notebook: Shanahan on Cardinals' QB uncertainty, Williams tipping plays, Colorado weather; Lynch on Ndamukong Suh interest

By David Bonilla
Nov 17

The San Francisco 49ers are holding their three practices this week at the United States Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, about an hour south of Denver, to get acclimated to the altitude. On Sunday, the team will travel to Mexico City for Monday night's game against the Arizona Cardinals at Estadio Azteca. Which quarterback will the 49ers defense face when they take the field? No one is really sure. Both Cardinals quarterbacks are day-to-day with injuries. Kyler Murray is dealing with a hamstring injury that kept him out this past weekend against the Los Angeles Rams, while McCoy is working through a knee injury suffered in that game. Both


Featured

More by Oscar Aparicio

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone