LISTEN: The 49ers Season Is Over →
Shop for 49ers gear

One Last Time, Singletary Ruins Everything

Nov 23, 2010 at 8:39 AM


placeholder image

MIKE SINGLETARY: "It all ultimately comes back to me."

Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.

Well then. THAT'll teach us.

We should've known, of course. We went through this LAST year, remember? Alex Smith was unstoppable in that shotgun spread, yet Mike Singletary wouldn't buy it. No matter how quickly the losses mounted, this was HIS team, dammit, and it would run HIS offense. His stupid, pointless, run-first offense.

Okay, so Troy Smith was phenomenal in that aggressive, vertical-passing O. So great, in fact, he awakened a long-dead sense of excitement in fans and players alike. Even Jed emerged to note the "life" that Smith had injected, and he sensed we'd started to "turn a corner." And he credited Singletary, for "weathering the storm and keeping our team together."

Once again, Singletary's team had a reason to hope.

What made you think he'd buy it THIS time?

Sure, Mike Johnson thought that he had the green light. "The one thing I want to do is encourage [Smith's] daring," he said, speaking of Smith's explosive proclivities. "I want to encourage the stuff he has inside and allow that to come out without stifling it." But Singletary's take was slightly different: "It's just a matter of continuing to work with Troy right now and [to] try to weed out all the bad habits we can."

It didn't take a psychologist to see it. Johnson said "daring," and Singletary said "bad habits." But they were discussing the very same thing. Johnson wanted to encourage it. And though it was our last and only flickering light, Singletary wanted to stifle it.

And now, after Sunday, it's dead.

The change was apparent immediately. Our first play last week was a pass for 32 yards. This week? Frank Gore up the gut, for nothing. This week, our second drive was a three-and-out that sent Gore up the gut on second-and-12. Our third drive ended with run, run, pass, punt, and our fourth drive went and did it again. Our fifth drive went with Gore up the middle on third-and-four, and that was it for the opening half. A half where we gained only 64 yards. Twice what we gained on last week's opening play.

We passed more in the second half, but each pass was so short--so Alex-like--it was hard to notice. By the time that Troy threw his first pass deep, it was fourth-and-three in the FOURTH QUARTER, and Vernon Davis never saw it. Finally, on our next drive, Ronde Barber baited Troy into his first pick, and it was over.

The Bucs had allowed six rushers to top a hundred, but Gore could muster just 23. The Bucs had collected eight sacks all year, but they picked up six and hit Smith on six more occasions besides. Smith, who'd been a model of explosive efficiency--or efficient explosiveness--was 16 of 31 for 118 net yards and a rating of 52. (Needless to say, our abysmal offensive line, with two firsts and two seconds, was complicit in all the above.)

And after all of that pregame excitement: for the first time in 33 years--for the first time since before Walsh arrived--we were shut out at home, the gun echoing off thousands and thousands of empty seats.

No doubt, Smith wasn't good. In stark contrast to last week's boldness, now he looked simply confused, and he admitted as much, crediting the Bucs for not standing still like an X on a blackboard. But like everything else, this was Singletary's fault. He'd gotten to Johnson, who promptly dumbed the O back down. And, clearly, he'd gotten to Smith. No longer "daring," no longer showing "the stuff he has inside," Troy was just a copy of Alex, desperately scared to make a mistake.

Naturally, some players were frustrated, stunned at their coach's stubborn refusal to stick with what works. "I don't think we attacked them the way we should have," Davis said, for roughly the millionth time in the last two years. "I think we should have thrown more balls downfield." Others were simply in shock. "I can't believe it," said Delanie Walker. "With the playmakers that we have and the talent that we have, I can't believe that we didn't even get close." And again, with feeling: "I just can't believe it."

Asked to explain, Johnson was faced with a choice. The smart option, of course, was to tell the truth, to say he did what Singletary wanted. After all, Singletary's certainly on his way out; why would Johnson take a bullet for HIM? But in a move that'll haunt him, Johnson went the OTHER direction, defending the plan and blaming the players. Sure, last week he threw the ball deep from the start, but now he preached the run-first gospel: "I would've liked to have seen us run the ball better," he said. "That sets up more vertical opportunities." So the plan was great; it was up to the players to execute. "At the end of the day, you still have to run-block, you still have to catch, you still have to throw." And for some reason, the players didn't do those things. Johnson wasn't dodging responsibility, though. The players failed, but that "falls on me." (It shouldn't, of course, but that's just the way it goes.)

Bad move, Mike. You seemed like a smart, creative guy. You seemed like you might have a future with us. But now you've tied your fate to your boss, and now you can follow him straight down the drain.

Which brings us, at last, to the boss himself.

After looking like an idiot in yet another postgame presser--seriously, why not just leave the writers a note: "I won't have a clue 'til I look at the film"--he finally admitted the obvious. His players might not have executed, but they weren't prepared. (They WERE led and motivated, he said--cough, cough--but they weren't prepared.) And yes, that's HIS fault, as is this entire disaster. We're three-and-seven, and he "wouldn't even dare to say" he's doing a competent job. "Because it all ultimately comes back to me."

With that rare display of honesty, he was sending a message to Jed. A message in three parts. He was acknowledging his failure. He was accepting responsibility. And he was begging, to stay in his job.

It's only polite to send a reply. And Jed's reply should only be this: it's over, now.

Despite lauding Singletary for turning that corner (and running straight into a wall, it turned out), Jed issued a subtle but crucial warning. If his expectations weren't met--and rest assured, they were higher than three-and-seven--"you're certainly gonna see changes being made." He was loath, though, to make changes midseason. After all, as Singletary said, in the race for the least-deserved playoff spot ever, "we're still in it."

But Singletary now has forced Jed's hand. It's not just the losses, as historically awful as they've become. It's not just Singletary's admission that he's taking millions and isn't even doing his job.

It's worse than that, more basic than that. And it can't be allowed to continue, not even for another day.

EVERY TIME this team shows some life. EVERY TIME this team shows a spark. EVERY TIME this team shows some fire, Mike Singletary does the strangest, most destructive, most demoralizing thing.

He simply puts it out.

The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.
Enjoy this article? Follow us to never miss more!

Powered by Follow.it

Shop for 49ers gear

Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

placeholder image

49ers mailbag: What do the 49ers have left in the tank for the last four games? Will SF bring back Robert Saleh? Can Brock Purdy beat good teams?

By Marc Adams
Dec 11

It's always a big week when the San Francisco 49ers play the Los Angeles Rams. In 2021, the rivalry became even bigger when the 49ers had to win in the season's final week, in Los Angeles, to make it into the playoffs. On Thursday night, the 49ers must win again to keep their...


placeholder image

A Down Year at the Perfect Time

By Ben Roberts
Dec 5

The 49ers' performance this season has led to significant emotional reactions, particularly among fans and some media personalities who are suggesting that the team should part ways with Kyle Shanahan and Brock Purdy. Let's clarify: the 49ers are not moving on from Shanahan....


placeholder image

49ers vs. Rams injury updates: Ji'Ayir Brown questionable to return

By David Bonilla
19 hrs

The San Francisco 49ers entered Thursday night's NFC West showdown against the Los Angeles Rams without key players, most notably left tackle Trent Williams, who is sidelined for the fourth straight game with an ankle injury. On defense, standout rookie safety Malik Mustapha...


placeholder image

Kyle Shanahan reflects on 49ers' Week 15 loss vs. Rams, provides De'Vondre Campbell update

By Site Staff
1 hr

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan spoke with reporters during a conference call on Friday, the day after the team's 12-6 loss to the Los Angeles Rams. Here's everything he said. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. Opening...


Shop for 49ers gear

Latest

derrick sanchez

San Francisco 49ers

20.3K Subscribers
POWERED BY
SUN

22

dec
49ers at Dolphins
Sun, Dec 22 | 9:25 PM · Hard Rock Stadium, 2269 Northwest 199th Street, Miami Gardens, FL
49ers at Dolphins
✔ 📺 Watch on CBS

---
TUE

31

dec
Lions at 49ers
Tue, Dec 31 | 1:15 AM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Lions at 49ers
✔ 📺 Watch on ABC/ESPN

---
SUN

5

jan
49ers at Cardinals
Sun, Jan 5 | 6:00 PM · State Farm Stadium, One Cardinals Drive, Glendale, AZ
49ers at Cardinals
✔ San Francisco 49ers at Arizona Cardinals

---
View All
See all upcoming and past events on Stanza.
Past Events
FRI

13

dec
Rams at 49ers
Today at 1:15 AM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Rams at 49ers
✔ San Francisco 49ers - Los Angeles Rams

---
SUN

8

dec
Bears at 49ers
Sun, Dec 8 | 9:25 PM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Bears at 49ers
✔ San Francisco 49ers - Chicago Bears

---
MON

2

dec
49ers at Bills
Mon, Dec 2 | 1:20 AM · Highmark Stadium, One Bills Drive, Orchard Park, NY
49ers at Bills
✔ Buffalo Bills - San Francisco 49ers

---
SUN

24

nov
49ers at Packers
Sun, Nov 24 | 9:25 PM · Lambeau Field, 1265 Lombardi Avenue, Green Bay, WI
49ers at Packers
✔ Green Bay Packers - San Francisco 49ers

---
SUN

17

nov
Seahawks at 49ers
Sun, Nov 17 | 9:05 PM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Seahawks at 49ers
✔ San Francisco 49ers - Seattle Seahawks

---
SUN

10

nov
49ers at Buccaneers
Sun, Nov 10 | 6:00 PM · Raymond James Stadium, 4201 North Dale Mabry Highway, Tampa, FL
49ers at Buccaneers
✔ Tampa Bay Buccaneers - San Francisco 49ers

---
MON

28

oct
Cowboys at 49ers
Mon, Oct 28 | 12:20 AM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Cowboys at 49ers
✔ San Francisco 49ers - Dallas Cowboys

---
SUN

20

oct
Chiefs at 49ers
Sun, Oct 20 | 8:25 PM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Chiefs at 49ers
✔ San Francisco 49ers - Kansas City Chiefs

---
FRI

11

oct
49ers at Seahawks
Fri, Oct 11 | 12:15 AM · Lumen Field, 800 Occidental Avenue South, Seattle, WA
49ers at Seahawks
✔ Seattle Seahawks - San Francisco 49ers

---
SUN

6

oct
Cardinals at 49ers
Sun, Oct 6 | 8:05 PM · Levi's Stadium, 4900 Marie P DeBartolo Way, Santa Clara, CA
Cardinals at 49ers
✔ San Francisco 49ers - Arizona Cardinals

---

Trending News

Theme: Auto • LightDark
Share 49ersWebzone