More Freedom for Manusky Improves the 49ers Defense

Dec 10, 2008 at 11:57 AM


Sure, Shaun Hill is getting lots of well deserved praise for the 49ers recent winning streak. But there is another improvement that seems to be going unnoticed. The 49ers defense is playing extremely well under Manusky and Singletary.

Lets first start off with a basic premise: Greg Manusky is calling the shots on defense. Coach Singletary stated his role when it comes to the defense is to help with the game planning. Singletary has input in the game plan for sure, as do various other coaches. On game day, Manusky calls the shots and it's clear that Singletary gives Manusky more freedom than Nolan did. Manusky went from implementing Nolan's defense to crafting his own and the results show.

The first, and perhaps most important, thing Manusky did was finally settle on an identity for the defense and made it a base 3-4. The results are obvious if you watch the games, but more obvious when you delve into the stats.

The 3-4 allowed both Manny Lawson and Parys Haralson more playing time. They have both responded with improved play. Haralson has 12 solo tackles and 7 assists in 5 games. More importantly he has 3 1/2 sacks over the same period. Lawson, inactive for 2 weeks early in the season, has 6 tackles and 9 assists over the last five games in addition to 2 sacks. In other words, the edge rushers are making more of an impact in Manusky's 3-4 instead of relying on situational defensive ends.

Even Patrick Willis is seeing higher tackle numbers, as was expected in a 3-4 scheme with 48 solo tackles coming in the last 5 weeks. That's an average of 9.6 tackles a game. Willis only averaged 7.25 solo tackles throughout the preceding 8 games.

The 49ers are allowing fewer rush yards per game over the last six weeks, an average of 34 yards per game fewer. This contributes to a time of possession swing of about a minute and 17 seconds per game. The defense is allowing fewer touchdowns through the air (1.8 under Manusky/Singletary versus 3.1 under Nolan).

Finally, the 5th point of Singletary's mantra - finish. The 49ers are allowing fewer than 6 points in the fourth quarter under Manusky's improved defense. Under Nolan they were allowing a little over 9 points in the fourth quarter. Considering they lost games to Seattle by three points (week 2), and New England (week 5) by 9 points, stronger finishes could potentially have had an impact in these games.

What accounts for these changes? Not knowing the game plans certainly hampers us in this exercise, but we can make some good guesses. The consistency behind the 3-4 scheme is allowing players to settle into their roles. Manusky also seems to be fitting his defense to the players, as opposed to fitting his players into his defense. I've said it in this space before, but schematic agility and flexibility is a must for great football coaches.

Also, Manusky said he is melding things he learned under Phillips with things he learned from Nolan. Singletary's ego seems to be one that is tolerant of another coordinator's ideas. He is allowing Manusky to run with a new defense, instead of trying to cram something down the coordinator's throat. All in all, it seems that more freedom for Manusky is certainly paying dividends for the 49ers defense.
The views within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


3 Comments

  • fanster
    In your last response, you stated that Franklin and SOAP were UNDERSIZED....????? I thought both those guys were around 320lbs??? Franklin might be a touch undersize at NT, but I thought Soap was a little on the BIG side for a DE, even a DE playing in the 3-4. You are right on about our improved D. It is nice to see the D start to have an identity. Good eye on pointing out the 1 gap scheme. You are right on the money with this article. Nice work
    Dec 12, 2008 at 2:36 PM
    0
    Response: Franklin lost weight this year to make himself more athletic. Soap ismore traditionally sized in terms of weight, but for the two gap scheme he was trying to play he was still a little under sized. But you're right, Soap is closer to the right size.
  • Hill to Hill
    Hey Oscar, they actually won in week two against Seattle (33-30). I would also like to add that there were a few games (Patriots and Eagles) where 4th quarter TO's by JTO had a LARGE part to do with their losses. And I was starting to wonder what happened to Lawson? But after seeing him the past few weeks, I understand it was all due to an ineffective scheme pre-Singletary era.
    Dec 10, 2008 at 2:54 PM
    0
    Response: I agree, the turnovers certainly didn't help the 49ers in the early going. One thing that we may need to account for as well is that Lawson may just now be getting back to his pre-injury form.
  • Mike in MD
    It's finally good to see Manusky is getting his head out of his a**. For a while there I wanted him out of here on a platter for being hypnotized by the Nolan kool-aid & not able to snap out of it. The last couple of games he's starting to get it. I like that he's doing what he's more comfortable at which is running a 3-4. This last game though (I don't have my copy yet) he said they ran more 4-3 w/t DL penetrating & 1-gapping...HALLELUIAH FINALLY!! But the combination of Singletary's effect (holding everyone accountable, inspiration/motivation, raising the intensity, personnel adjustments, giving DC his freedom, etc) & Manusky finally starting to come into his own is getting some great results. His next step is to get more of that AGGRESSION in his arsenal...more pre-snap MOVEMENT/CONFUSION like when he first arrived here & us attacking more & dictating instead of waiting too much read & reacting. HE NEEDS TO WATCH MORE FILM OF LEBEAU, JJOHNSON, & BALTIMORE'S DEFENSES & SERIOUSLY START TAKING NOTES. But he's coming along & I'm definitely for keeping the continuity & retaining him next season. Watch the above film Greg! And keep up the good work.
    Dec 10, 2008 at 1:24 PM
    0
    Response: I think Manusky is leaning towards more of a one-gap scheme, which may benefit the defense in the end. Franklin and Soap look can use their quickness in that area to excel. They are undersized after all.

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



'Just more competition': 49ers' Fred Warner excited to face Rams' Matthew Stafford

By David Bonilla
Jul 25, 2021

Kyle Shanahan would have liked to look into the possibility of adding Matthew Stafford this offseason. He was shocked by how quickly the deal between the Detroit Lions and the Las Angeles Rams went down. As a result, Shanahan never got a chance to get his team into the mix. "I was trying to get involved in it," Shanahan shared earlier this month, sharing that he thought he had more time to do so. But it was too late. The trade was on its way to being completed. Now, Stafford is in the NFC West, and the San Francisco 49ers will have to face the veteran quarterback twice a season. News of the trade was shocking to many, especially those within



Kyle Shanahan and John Lynch talk 49ers training camp, QB situation, Nick Bosa, more

By Site Staff
Jul 27, 2021

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch spoke to the media on Tuesday as the team opens its 2021 training camp. Here is everything they had to say. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. Opening comments: General Manager John Lynch: "We want to welcome [vice president of football communications] Corry Rush. I think you guys have all met Corry and I also want to thank [senior manager of football communications] Mike Chasanoff for doing an unbelievable job along with [coordinator of football communications] Tessa [Giammona] and [manager of football communications] Pete [Volmut] as we were filling that role. I'm excited to get on with camp. A couple of



Jimmy Garoppolo talks 49ers training camp, Trey Lance, Brandon Aiyuk, Mohamed Sanu, more

By Site Staff
Jul 28, 2021

The San Francisco 49ers kicked off their first practice of training camp today. Quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo spoke with reporters after the players came off the field. Here is everything he had to say. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. How did the first day go? "I mean, there's always, you know, those first-day jitters, excitement having fans out there, I'm a huge fan of that. It was good to get back to some normalcy, I guess." TE George Kittle said yesterday that he saw a different fire in you in OTAs and WR Deebo Samuel just said you've seemed a little bit more locked in and more energy in the huddle. Can you speak to that a little bit? "I don't



Kyle Shanahan talks 49ers training camp, Trey Lance, Nick Bosa, Mohamed Sanu, more

By Site Staff
Jul 28, 2021

The San Francisco 49ers kicked off their first practice of training camp today. Head coach Kyle Shanahan spoke with reporters after the players came off the field. Here is everything he had to say. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. Opening comments: "The guys just doing individual only right now, waiting to be safe before we allow in team stuff is [WR Jalen] Hurd, [DL Nick] Bosa, [DL Dee] Ford and [DL Javon] Kinlaw. Go ahead." The guys you mentioned going on COVID, does that have a positive impact in the weeks ahead? As far as counting toward the vaccinated players you have on your team? "What do you mean by positive


Featured

More by Oscar Aparicio

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone