The Niner Faithful’s love affair with Nolan may be over

Dec 11, 2007 at 2:44 PM8

A buddy of mine, who happens to be a Dallas Cowboys fan, is in the Bay Area for work this week. He is a good guy who does not talk a whole lot of smack and respects the 49ers from their glory days while remembering the epic matchups between the two storied franchises. I received the following in an email from him yesterday.

I was driving from Oakland to Santa Clara and listened to a lot of Niners sports radio. I'm not sure if Mike Nolan is the right guy. I was listening to his press conference and a reporter asked him, "With all of the great expectations coming into the season, what has been the problem of meeting those expectations? Coaching? Lack of talent? Poor execution by the player?"

Mike Nolan said that it is not appropriate time to answer this. What?! If you know the answer, you should address it and make people accountable if you are the head coach. If you don't know what the problem is, that's scary.

My buddy admits that he does not know the team and its issues as well as I do. Well, guess what are pretty right on. Even an outsider briefly looking in, who has very little knowledge of everything going on with this franchise, can see that Nolan's responses are very puzzling. Nolan has finally mentioned that he has a better grasp on what is wrong with this team and what remedies are needed to fix things.

"I think I have a much better visual of a lot of things," Nolan said. "But there are certain things that I don't have a visual on."

However, instead of elaborating on what these "things" are, Nolan went on to say, "There will be a time and place to go into that...but there's more clarity in my mind about several things than there were two months ago, no question."

For the majority of the season, it seemed as though Nolan had no clue what the problem was. The problem with Nolan seems to be his stubbornness and he has only recently begun to admit when he is wrong. That is something that does not seem to happen often. Someone has to be wrong considering the amount of talent on this team. The team should be winning more matchups than they are. Unfortunately, the offense seems totally unprepared on Sundays. I am sure that it is very reassuring to fans that the team looks very prepared during practice. Note the sarcasm there. After all, that is what we hear almost every week from the coaches and players.

The majority of the issues seem to be coaching, but Nolan refuses to throw any of his staff under the bus. Could this all mean that, in his eyes, the problem does indeed lie within his staff? Because there are three games remaining, meaning three more losses, he may not be willing to throw a guy like offensive coordinator Jim Hostler under the bus. The team already proved that Hostler is not ready to do this on his own when they brought in Ted Tollner as a much needed consultant to assist in planning out the offensive schemes from week to week. In fact, over the course of the season, Nolan has had nothing but good things to say about Hostler. Apparently, he feels that Hostler is doing a good job. So good a job that Tollner was needed to come in and share in his glory.

While he will not say a word about his staff, perhaps Nolan does not have a problem throwing his players under the bus. In a statement to MediaNews, Alex Smith stated that Nolan made it clear to teammates that the quarterback was using his injuries as an excuse for his performance on the field. Smith feels that the comments have severely hurt his reputation among teammates. He referred to Nolan's repeated comments regarding the injury as "the spin" and felt that Nolan was questioning his toughness. Who is telling the truth here? It is probably Smith. While he has been so good at avoiding public outbursts over the course of his career, this latest issue may have pushed him over the edge forcing him to say something in his own defense.

"He came out and said some things to the team," said Smith. "It was like he was telling his side of it and I didn't want to get into it. ... That was my biggest concern when he did that: I felt it was trying to undermine me with my teammates."

Now, one has to wonder how much trust there is between Nolan and his quarterback of the future.

A fan noted that it is amazing how quickly one guy can turn from savior to target. Even toward the beginning of the season, fans were in love with Nolan and had no doubt that he would right this struggling franchise. On paper, the 49ers looked much improved under his watch and they seemed to be a contender in the NFC West. Twelve weeks later, Nolan is being targeted as the source of this team's woes. He certainly is not helping his case by avoiding the tough questions when they are asked.

All of this makes you wonder how much of last year's solid production was because of Norv Turner and not Mike Nolan. Should Nolan remain in San Francisco, which could still happen, he needs a solid offensive coordinator to throw around ideas with. He is not a good enough coach to call the shots on his own. With Turner, the offense over-performed despite having much less talent. Turner's untimely departure left the 49ers in a very bad predicament, one that resulted in the promotion of a guy that had little to no experience calling offensive plays.

A case can be made that the defense is good, but they are on the field too often due to the ineffectiveness of the offense. At this point in the season, the defense has played more time than any other NFL team. No defense should be cursed with such a bad offense. They are tired and unable to keep up with teams that are much more rested. Because of the offensive's lack of production, this may be the worst 49ers team ever. If it isn't, it certainly has to be one of the most boring teams to watch. I certainly can't remember a 49ers team that was this uninteresting.

Returning to Nolan's stubbornness, why did it take an injury to Trent Dilfer to give fans an opportunity to get a good look at quarterback Shaun Hill? Nolan stated that Hill would likely have played in the second half even if Dilfer had not gotten hurt. That may have been the case considering he was seen warming up on the sideline prior to the injury. Coaches and fans have had a chance to watch Dilfer for five games prior to Sunday's loss to the Minnesota Vikings. During those five games, he performed like an NFL quarterback during one matchup, the team's win against the Arizona Cardinals in November. With Dilfer performing at such a low level and with the season pretty much over, why not give another guy a shot? If you are looking for your best chance to win football games, sometimes it is better to go with the unknown x-factor rather than someone you know to be playing at a horrible level. Even if it does not pan out, what have you lost? You were likely going to lose the game with Dilfer anyways.

If Shaun Hill is not your guy, elevate former UCLA quarterback Drew Olson and give him a shot. While his career with the Bruins was anything but extraordinary, you never know where you will find a spark on offense.

Dilfer is a "Nolan guy" though. Guys like him, wide receiver Darrell Jackson and linebacker Derek Smith will always have a place on this team if you embrace Nolan's philosophy and vision. These are guys that practice well but always seem to consistently make mistakes on Sundays. You can always count on Dilfer to throw some interceptions, Jackson to drop some passes and Smith to be in the right place at the right time, but fail to make the tackle. These are all guys that probably would not see much playing time on many NFL teams, yet they are 49ers starters.

On the flip side, potential guys like receivers Ashley Lelie and Jason Hill sit on the sidelines for the majority of the season. Ok, Hill has been hurt, but he was probable for Sunday's game. Even if these guys do not perform well, would anyone really notice in this offense? If they fail, then just change the lineup next week. With three games left in a pretty pathetic season, this is not the time to be stubborn and refuse to mix things up a bit when there is a chance it could help.

You have to feel bad for guys like Nate Clements and Patrick Willis. While it is tough to feel too bad for any guy that is making more money in one year than most people will see in a lifetime, Clements probably believed all of the Nolan hype and figured he was coming to a playoff team. After all, he was one of the few missing pieces to the puzzle, right? As for Willis, he probably heard what the fans, media, and even the staff was saying about the 2007 season. Things were golden in San Francisco and there was a lot to look forward to. Willis has performed at an exceptional level on a team that underachieves as a whole. In fact, Willis deserves to win the Defensive Rookie of the Year award. As Nolan said on Monday, he may not only be the best defensive rookie, he probably would compete in that category against veterans. I must admit, Nolan has brought in some good talent. He simply has not been able to do anything with it. Unfortunately for Willis, while his stats are fantastic, he plays on a very unwatchable team and you have to start to wonder if this will impact his chances to win Defensive Rookie of the Year.

I envy guys like Matt Maiocco and Matthew Barrows. They get to be very objective in their duties covering the 49ers while fans like us have to live with the frustration of watching the current staff take this team from potentially good to undoubtedly clueless. While our expectations might have been higher than they should have been, no one could have foreseen this mess.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Dallas Fan
    One person you did not mention who I relly feel sorry for is BY. He must be totally embrassed and frustrated to see how low the Niners have gone. He has given evrything to this team and he is a very classy act. It is a shame.
    Dec 12, 2007 at 2:47 PM
    Response: Agreed. The result of this season probably had a lot to do with his decision to likely retire. BY has played for a long time and the costs probably outweigh the benefits at this point. It is not as though everything will be turned around in one year. BY is loyal to this team, but at some point you have to know when to give up hope that a championship is near.
  • 49erSacFan
    Five things we need to do to help turn this mess around: 1. It's time for the Yorks to see the team to Larry Ellison 2. Bring back John McVay to help find a GM 3. Replace Nolan with an experienced NFL Coach 4. Keep Alex Smith and draft a potential replacement for him this year. 5. Fan's except that we've gone from Salary Cap Hell to a 10 year re-building project, and live with it.
    Dec 12, 2007 at 9:37 AM
  • arthur
    I'm totally with you on the "TRY SOMETHING" logic. How can you "stay the course" when you're as bad as this? This is my number one reason why Nolan should be fired. The insane stupidity of this thinking just CAN'T be rewarded with one more year. Last year Kwame killed us with his penalties. Did he EVER get benched? (Even though we had Adam Snyder waiting in the wings!) This year it's VD with 7 false starts. How many repeated mistakes earns a player some pine time in Nolan's plan? If Nolan comes back next year, it will just be somebody else doing the same old stuff without consequences. I thought they had "accountability" meetings. Doesn't look like anyone is actually held too accountable!
    Dec 12, 2007 at 7:54 AM
  • dwd
    Thanks for the analysis. Of course, it is difficult to draw conclusions only from watching the games, but even an amateur like myself has to wonder how Nolan could have stayed with Dilfer for so long. When your quarterback is throwing more interceptions for touchdowns against you than he is throwing for touchdowns for you, it is time to make a change. It may well have been that Hill would have played the second half, but is there any doubt that, barring injury, Dilfer would have started this week? Then we find out that the team is looking at Briggs for linebacker as their free agent acquisition. On defense, we need down linemen that can rush the quarterback, particularly at the nose tackle position. If I played fantasy football, I would start whatever quarter back was playing against the 49ers each and every week. While we usually do well against the run, we make their quarter back look line an all-star each and every week it seems. DD
    Dec 12, 2007 at 5:46 AM
  • Vince
    Dec 12, 2007 at 3:20 AM
  • Ed
    Excellent take David. Last years offense success can be attributed to Norv Turner. Although Norv has not done much as a head coach, he is one of the best OC's in the game. I see too many wrong coaching decisions being made by Mike Nolan. I think he does not have the ability or maturity to be a head coach in the NFL. He is good looking, speaks well, and wears suits. That doesnt count for jack as a coach.
    Dec 11, 2007 at 8:22 PM
  • Sydney
    Awesome article David. I agree completely. This was a well-thought out article that told the whole story.
    Dec 11, 2007 at 5:21 PM
    Response: Well, it was inspired by an email exchange and written very quickly. Just some thoughts that I wanted to throw out. Thanks Sydney.
  • niner
    I'm never wrong The ony time i thought i was wrong, i was wrong. Besides that I never lose. As long as i get my check every week i win. I certainly like the progress were making........
    Dec 11, 2007 at 5:04 PM
    Response: Thanks for the input. Stay the course.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers-Giants: Trent Williams calls punch of A'Shawn Robinson a 'love tap'; Official explains why Williams wasn't ejected

By Kirk Larrabee
Sep 21

Those who watched Thursday night's game between the San Francisco 49ers and New York Giants may want to know why no ejections took place after 49ers left tackle Trent Williams punched the face mask of Giants defensive lineman A'Shawn Robinson as the first half came to a close. NFL Senior Vice President of Officiating Walt Anderson gave an explanation behind that decision after the game, while Williams played his punch off as a "love tap." The incident took place towards the end of the first half of the 49ers' 30-12 win over the Giants, following a play where the 49ers downed the ball. Robinson can be seen giving Williams a poke in the chin, after which Williams swung and hit Robinson in the face

NFL fines Trent Williams $11,473 for "love tap" during 49ers-Giants

By David Bonilla
Sep 29

San Francisco 49ers tackle Trent Williams informed Cam Inman of Bay Area News Group that the NFL fined him $11,000 for punching New York Giants defensive lineman A'Shawn Robinson in the Week 3 matchup between the two teams. Update: Both Williams and Robinson were each fined $11,473, per Tom Pelissero of NFL Media. The NFL fined #49ers OT Trent Williams and #Giants DL A'Shawn Robinson $11,473 each for

3 quick takeaways from 49ers' 30-12 win over the Giants

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Sep 21

The San Francisco 49ers defeated the New York Giants on Thursday Night Football 30-12, improving to 3-0 with a victory in the home opener at Levi's Stadium. Following a slower-than-expected start due to some quarterback miscues and longer drives, the 49ers settled in, taking a 17-6 lead going into halftime, which improved to 30-12 by the end of the game. Here are three quick takeaways from the 49ers' 30-12 win over the New York Giants. 2nd half adjustments For the second consecutive half, it seemed like the 49ers made the proper second-half adjustments defensively, operating with heavier blitzes and more press-man coverage, which resulted in shorter passes from quarterback Daniel Jones, leading to four punts and an interception in the

Nick Bosa: "My body's fully adapted to football now" after 49ers' TNF win over Giants

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Sep 27

The San Francisco 49ers defeated the New York Giants in a Thursday Night Football matchup during Week 3, notching a 30-12 victory in their home opener to improve to 3-0. San Francisco was dominant in all three areas of the field, consistently leading by two scores due to another strong offensive performance, matched by a defense that held the Giants to just 12 points overall. Despite the short week, the 49ers earned major contributions from defensive end Nick Bosa, who recorded a sack and six pressures in only 39 snaps due to the Giants' lack of offensive plays. Bosa's health has been an underrated factor through three weeks, as the defensive end was acclimated heavily in Week 2, playing 63 defensive snaps, which was a significant uptick from Week


More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone