Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports


How Much is Too Much for the 49ers to Acquire Deshaun Watson From the Texans?

Levin T. Black
Jan 17, 2021 at 1:02 PM0


Houston Texans quarterback Deshaun Watson isn't happy. This has been known for a while at this point with reports of Watson not returning calls and being upset over the team's hiring process for both the general manager and the head coach. Watson was told he would get to have input but it's been reported that Watson either never got the chance or the input he gave was completely ignored by the Texans.

The possibility that Watson could force his way out went from possible to a near lock on Sunday. ESPN's Adam Schefter dropped a bomb that will likely dominate sports talk all off-season. It came via a tweet.


Let the sweepstakes for quite possibly the best quarterback to ever hit the trade market begin!

Saying the San Francisco 49ers will be interested is an understatement. The question isn't whether the 49ers will make an offer but how big of an offer. Watson won't come cheap. It's likely that he brings back the biggest haul ever for a player not named Herschel Walker.

How much should the 49ers be wiling to spend and who is the main competition? We'll start with the competition.

New York Jets


No one knows if the Jets will actually enter the sweepstakes. They do have Sam Darnold and new head coach Robert Saleh and offensive coordinator Mike LaFleur reportedly liked what they saw when they scouted Darnold.

The reason the Jets are kicking things off here is twofold. First, Watson was apparently a fan of Saleh.


The Texans not interviewing Saleh when nearly every team with an opening did is particularly eyebrow raising because Saleh got his NFL start with the Texans. He was on the Texans coaching staff from 2005 to 2010.

If Watson is a fan of Saleh then it is likely he'd waive his no trade clause to go to the Jets. If he does, the Jets have the best assets to offer and no, it doesn't involve Darnold. The Jets own the No. 2, No. 23 and No. 34 overall picks in this year's draft. In addition to this year, they also own two first-round picks in 2022 draft.

If the Jets choose to pursue, the only way they lose is by setting their limit too low. No one can match the draft capital they can offer up.

Miami Dolphins


Do the Texans believe Tua Tagovailoa is a franchise quarterback? Tua didn't have the best rookie season but there was some promise shown and a rebound in throwing velocity could be in order next season after some time off to recover from his hip injury.

If the Texans like Tua, the Dolphins have something no other team can offer. That would be a recent top draft pick the Texans believe in, who also has a minimum of three years left on a cheap rookie deal. For the cash-strapped Texans, the potential value of Tua can't be understated. That's not all the Dolphins have, though.

They also have a lot of draft capital thanks to owning, wait for it, the Texans' first-round pick. That pick would be the No. 3 overall selection in this year's draft. The Dolphins also own the No. 18 overall pick, making them the only team with two top 20 picks. Would they trade Tua, the No. 3 overall pick plus other picks like No. 18 overall or their 2022 first-round pick and a few mid-round selections? If so, the 49ers aren't likely to be able to match.

San Francisco 49ers


So what do the 49ers have to offer? They don't have multiple first-round picks in this year's draft. They don't have a promising young quarterback. They do have a roster that is just a quarterback away from being a 10-plus win team every single year and if things break right, a potential dynasty. That means the 49ers could afford to give up more future picks than other teams.

The 49ers can trade the No. 12 overall pick, their 2022 first-round pick, and 2023 first-round. With Nick Bosa, George Kittle, Brandon Aiyuk, Deebo Samuel, Fred Warner, and Arik Armstead already on the team, the 49ers have elite talents needed to go with Watson.

First-round picks are valuable but the 49ers' ability to win titles after acquiring Watson will be about finding the complementary pieces. Depth essentially. Depth comes from mid-to-late rounds.

The problem for the 49ers is three first-round picks probably aren't enough by themselves. The 49ers may have to part with one of the players listed above in addition to the picks. Are three first-round picks and Samuel too much? What about Bosa and the picks?

In this writer's opinion, I'd pull the trigger on the three first-round picks and any one of the above players, but only one. That's my limit.

Yes, I just said I would trade three first-round picks and Bosa for Watson. Simple fact is as great as Bosa is, he's not a quarterback and he's missed almost the entire season two of the past three years (last season of college included).

The Watson's value and the greatness the offense would achieve being led by Watson, Kittle, Aiyuk, and Deebo with Kyle Shanahan calling plays would be historic. It would be comparable to, and maybe even surpass, the current Kansas City Chiefs team, yet younger both in coaching and players.

The Chiefs are destroying the league. The 49ers' defense would still be better than the Chiefs' without Bosa while the offense would be just as good. That's the level of team the 49ers would have instantly by acquiring Watson, even at the cost of three first-round picks and an All-Pro caliber edge rusher on a rookie deal.

Feel free to @ me on Twitter. I welcome the discussion. Where is your limit?
  • Levin T. Black
  • Written by:
    A graduate of Ball State University in 2009, Levin was an award winning sports journalist until he transitioned into a different career. He's written for Webzone since 2018.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



13 emotionally-influenced 49ers observations (that I'm probably making too quickly)

By Marc Adams
Sep 12

The San Francisco 49ers beat the Detroit Lions 41-33 on Sunday, and at times, were dominant. That's the good news. The bad news? Rather than blowing out the Lions, like it looked like they were going to, they let the team from the Motor City back into the game, almost losing the lead. The worst news? More injuries, including a season ending injury to their best cornerback, Jason Verrett, as well injuries that knocked Raheem Mostert and Dre Greenlaw out of the game. The 49ers need Greenlaw and



49ers' Kyle Shanahan on Deommodore Lenoir: 'Nothing's too big for him'

By Marc Adams
Sep 18

San Francisco 49ers rookie cornerback Deommodore Lenoir has been thrown into the fire early in his NFL career. Veteran defensive back Emmanuel Moseley missed the 49ers first game due to an injury. Lenoir filled in as the starting corner opposite Jason Verrett, and played 90 snaps in the team's opening day win over Detroit. He was very solid. And now with Verrett out for the season with a torn ACL, the rookie defensive back will be counted on even more. And his coaches are confident he is up to the task. Head coach Kyle Shanahan, who spoke about Lenoir to the media a couple of times this week, said, "I've loved his mentality," he told Matt Maiocco, of NBC Sports Bay Area. "He doesn't say a lot, he's a



49ers-Eagles: Goal line stand turns the tide after shaky 49ers start

By Kirk Larrabee
12 hrs

If there was one significant turning point in the San Francisco 49ers' 17-11 win over the Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday, it was most likely the unexpected goal line stand members of the defense produced after a 91-yard pass put their backs against the wall in the second quarter. Down 3-0 to the Eagles with just over seven minutes remaining in the half, the 49ers had a long field behind them after a punt from Mitch Wishnowsky pinned the Eagles at their own three-yard line. But on the first play after the punt, Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts went deep for wide receiver Quez Watkins, who went for 91 yards before being brought down by safety Jaquiski Tartt and cornerback Deommodore Lenoir at the 49ers' six-yard line. A pass interference call on cornerback Josh Norman two plays



ESPN simulation has 49ers, Trey Lance finishing strong, Seahawks starting 0-9

By David Bonilla
Sep 6

The start of the 2021 NFL season is just days away, and everyone is making last-minute efforts to predict the outcome. That includes ESPN, which ran its annual Football Power Index (FPI) simulation of the entire 285-game schedule 20,000 times to project what will happen. ESPN used the simulations to predict the win total for each team and give a good idea of who might win Super Bowl 56 at SoFi Stadium in February. What happens in the NFC West, according to the simulation? The San Francisco 49ers start strong with a 4-1 record, tied for the best among the NFC. The Rams also start 4-1 while the Arizona


Featured

More by Levin T. Black

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone