Jerome Miron/Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports

Jerome Miron/Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports


Would the 49ers trade for Trent Williams or Jalen Ramsey? Don’t get your hopes up

Sep 17, 2019 at 4:28 PM0


San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan was asked on Monday about the team's philosophy on improving the roster. The question was specific to the left tackle position and dealing with the loss of veteran Joe Staley (leg) for six to eight weeks and if the team would be aggressive in pursuing a temporary replacement.

Here is how Shanahan responded:

"Yeah, always. We would love to if there were options. You look at anything that's possible. I don't think there's a ton of great options out there that are possible."

While some took this to mean that the 49ers might aggressively pursue a replacement starting left tackle and ensure that quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo stays upright and injury-free, I interpreted it differently. I saw it as the 49ers being open to pursuing options, assuming the cost isn't too high and the move made long-term sense.

The key to Shanahan's statement sits in the last sentence. There aren't options that make sense for the 49ers. Hoping that the San Francisco brain trust pursues someone like Trent Williams from the Washington Redskins is probably wishful and misguided thinking.

Giving up valuable draft capital for Williams might make sense if the 49ers thought Staley was done for the year, especially given the team's 2-0 start to the season. This year's squad, after all, might be capable of making a playoff push. Why not solidify the position before then.

The 49ers' situation is different, though. Staley is expected back and mortgaging the future for a temporary replacement doesn't make a whole lot of sense, especially since money — and possibly other factors — are involved in the stare-down between Williams and Washington.

Things might have been different had Staley still been on the final year of his contract. He isn't after signing an extension in June that keeps the tackle under contract through the 2021 season.

Of course, if the asking price isn't a first-round pick, you never know. Then again, what happens when Staley returns?

Shanahan sounded confident moving forward with rookie tackle Justin Skule as Staley's replacement during his extended absence. The coach noted that the team's decision-makers are always evaluating the roster and Skule, a sixth-round pick, made the cut because he was good enough to do so.

"When you go to your final roster of 53, at every single position, whoever's on it, you're looking at all options out there to see (if there is anyone better)," Shanahan said on Monday. "[…] We kept Skule because we thought he was the best available. That doesn't change now. I think Skule's going to get a lot better throughout his career, but we kept him on this team because he can help us win now."

The 49ers are more likely to make a move like re-signing Sam Young, who initially joined the team after Shon Coleman's season-ending injury. Young visited Santa Clara today.

If Shanahan feels that way about the all-important left tackle position, an anchor along the offensive line, he likely feels the same way about cornerback. All-Pro cornerback Jalen Ramsey requested a trade from the Jacksonville Jaguars this week following an in-game argument with coach Doug Marrone and, like clockwork, fans started tweeting at 49ers general manager John Lynch to make a move.

Two teams have reportedly offered the Jaguars a first-round pick for Ramsey with one of the teams, an NFC squad, offering a 2020 first-rounder and a fifth-rounder in 2021. It's difficult to fathom the 49ers being that team. That would be a lot to give up when your roster already includes Richard Sherman and Ahkello Witherspoon. There is no doubt that Ramsey would upgrade the position, and maybe if the cost were lower, San Francisco might be willing to give it more consideration.

Witherspoon has rebounded well from his up and down 2018 campaign and been impressive during the 49ers' first two victories. Sherman is healthier than he has been in years, and that has been reflected on the field.

Again, do you mortgage the future when it seems like you are seemingly set, at least for now, at the position? My answer might have been different a few weeks ago, before Witherspoon's resurgence.

This year's trade deadline is October 29, so a lot could happen before then. For now, it sounds like the 49ers are comfortable moving forward with what they have and aren't willing to make an impulsive move that could cost the team down the road. After all, if San Francisco's success continues, Shanahan and Lynch will have proven that their patient and methodical approach to this roster rebuild was correct.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


0 Comments

  • No Comments

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Kyle Shanahan expects Jimmy Garoppolo to be 100 percent for 49ers-Colts, hopes Trent Williams can practice Friday

By David Bonilla
Oct 21

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan joined KNBR this afternoon and provided two key injury updates. One was on his starting quarterback, Jimmy Garoppolo, who is returning from a calf injury suffered on October 3. The injury forced him to miss Week 5, but the coach sounds more and more confident that Garoppolo will be ready for Sunday's home game against the Indianapolis Colts. "He's getting better each day," Shanahan said on the Tolbert, Krueger & Brooks show. "I mean, there shouldn't be any problem with him by Sunday at all. Any time you're coming off the calf injury like that, it takes a little time to get that soreness out, so you'll see it on some throws here and there. But each day it gets much better, and I think he'll be feeling 100 percent by



Trent Williams: No need to panic; 49ers have the 'talent we need in-house' to end losing streak

By David Bonilla
Oct 18

The San Francisco 49ers have lost three consecutive games and look to turn their season around on Sunday night against the Indianapolis Colts. At 2-3, the team finds itself looking up at the division-leading Arizona Cardinals (6-0) and Los Angeles Rams (5-1). The Niners have lost to the Cardinals and Seattle Seahawks and have yet to play the Rams. Williams says there is no panic in the building. The team knows the locker room is talented enough to rebound on its own. "We're not waiting for somebody to walk through the door," Williams told reporters after today's practice. "We've got all the talent we need in-house. ... We've just got to put it all together on Sunday." San Francisco still has four division matchups remaining. There remains a chance



Jimmy Garoppolo practices again; Trent Williams, Trey Lance among absent 49ers

By David Bonilla
Oct 21

Jimmy Garoppolo was out on the practice field for the third time this week (the San Francisco 49ers held a bonus practice on Monday). We won't know exactly how much the starting quarterback worked during today's session until the team issues its practice participation report later this afternoon. Reporters aren't allowed to watch the entire practice, which means missing out on team drills. The Niners listed Garoppolo as limited on Wednesday. On Wednesday, head coach Kyle Shanahan said he is "pretty optimistic" Garoppolo would be available for Sunday's home game against the Indianapolis Colts. However, he was less sure about the status of his rookie quarterback and



49ers-Colts Injury Report: Trent Williams day-to-day with ankle injury; Jimmy Garoppolo limited; Trey Lance doesn't practice

By David Bonilla
Oct 21

The San Francisco 49ers are preparing for their Week 7 contest against the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, California. Quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo, coming off a calf injury, continues to practice with his teammates this week. He is expected to start against the Colts. RELATED: Shanahan expects Garoppolo to be 100 percent for 49ers-Colts, hopes Williams can practice Friday The 49ers' rookie quarterback, Trey Lance, hasn't practiced this week and was not on the field today. While his status for Sunday is uncertain, it is unlikely he is suited up for the


Featured

More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone