Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

What Carlos Hyde Would Bring to the Playoff Table if Re-signed

Sequoia Sims
Jan 4, 2018 at 5:12 PM

Recently on Niners Live, we dropped: Why the 49ers should Re-sign Carlos Hyde; but Will They? And now we take it a step further: What Carlos Hyde would bring to the playoff table if re-signed in 2018.

Wait, what? Playoffs?! Don't talk about playoffs! Are you kidding me? Playoffs?! I'm just hoping we can win a game, another game! (In the words of Jim Mora Sr., and no pun intended, of course). Yes, this article is about to come from a different perspective, indeed, and if you have been tuning into Niners Live you know how we move and do it... The Forty-Niners are expected to make the playoffs in 2018, so says NFL Network analyst and former scout Daniel Jeremiah (via

Oh, he's not the only one talking playoffs

Joe Staley: "I mean, 6-10 at the end of the season, but I don't think there's a team in the NFL that would want to see us right now in the playoffs."

Hold that thought and let's recap Hyde's 2017 season

Carlos Hyde in 2017 had his best all-around year as a pro, playing and starting all 16 games while accounting for 940 yards rushing on 240 attempts at 3.9 yards per rush and eight rushing touchdowns – all career highs outside of his per rush average. Hyde didn't stop there in the career-high category. He became a dual threat with 59 catches and 350 yards out the backfield.

Hyde had 1,290 yards from scrimmage while running behind a subpar to average at best interior line base on the eyeball test and Pro Football Focus run grades. Also, this unit below was flagged with eight holding penalties that contributed to nullifying big gains by Hyde.

Pro Football Focus Grades: Left guard Laken Tomlinson (run grade 76.2), center Daniel Kilgore (run grade 52.7) and right guard Brandon Fusco (run grade 74.4). Hyde finished 13th in rushing (behind Frank Gore who Niners Live said should be re-signed). Now imagine if this area of the offensive line was upgraded.

Could Hyde be a 1,500 to 1,800 yards from scrimmage running back? With having Jimmy Garoppolo as his quarterback for a full season? Yes, he could. Objectively speaking, of course.

But wait, there's more. Hyde scored the most touchdowns on the team, with eight (see above). Tight end Garrett Celek, aka "Celek Time," came in second on the team with four.

Hyde had 44 rushing first downs, which was first on the team (rushing wise) and 17 pass catching first downs giving him a combined total of 61 first downs converted (tops on the team). The runner-up was Marquise Goodwin with 49 first downs total (three coming from rushing, via

What Carlos Hyde would bring to the playoff table if re-signed

Based on the expectations as aforementioned, and the Hype train of the Forty-Niners making the playoffs as Peter Schrager, Senior National Writer for, has called out and led the charge. What do you pack heading into the playoffs come December and January? Or even in February if you were going to the Super Bowl ala Hyde's prediction. Your defense and running game, that's what.

What kind of running back and style of a runner is needed for sure in the playoffs?

  • A runner that's big, powerful, and physical at the point of attack.
  • A back that can break tackles, help control the time of possession, and help rest your defense.
  • A back that can help slow down the opponent's pass rush by wearing them down based on his bruising running style.
  • A back that can get the tough/short yards in the playoffs.
  • A back that can be a threat in the passing game and be a leader on the field while inspiring his teammates with his natural and necessary toughness and bullying ways.

In fact, let's go back to the New York Giants game in which Hyde averaged 4.9 yards per rush after contact, with 84 of his 98 rushing yards coming after contact.

Hyde's performance against the Giants, which was the Forty-Niners first win of the season, earned him nomination honors for the FedEx Air & Ground Player of the Week (via the team's website).

I'll leave on this closing note

Does the production match the description of the player? Who had six runs of 20+ yards? Carlos Hyde. How many did Matt Breida have? Just two. Who stood up for his quarterback and teammate, C. J. Beathard, and got ejected from the Arizona Cardinals game? Carlos Hyde. Are your eyes wide open?

Would John Lynch like to bring Hyde back given the right parameters and if it works out for both sides? Yes, he would (per Matt Maiocco). Ok, let me end here. I think this article just might need CPR because I just killed it...

Sequoia Sims: Founder of Niners Live, Content Creator and Senior Author. The home of the faithful fan and analyst from an objective/analytical lens, and different perspective, of course.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • No Comments

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Playoff Picture: 49ers' dominant win vs. Jaguars improved playoff chances

By David Bonilla
Nov 22

The once-dismissed San Francisco 49ers have now won three of their last four with two consecutive routs of opponents. A week ago, it was the dismantling of a division rival, the Los Angeles Rams. Yesterday, the Niners dominated a struggling opponent, the Jacksonville Jaguars, to climb to .500. Next for San Francisco will be a matchup against another .500 team, the Minnesota Vikings, winners of two straight. A win against the Vikings could be enough to finally push the Niners into the playoff picture. Below is a breakdown of the current playoff picture in the NFC, with the first four teams being the division leaders. The most significant change from last week is the Arizona Cardinals leaping past Green Bay for the top spot thanks to the Vikings knocking off the

'We understand we've got to bring it': John Lynch explains why the 49ers aren't taking the Jaguars lightly

By David Bonilla
Nov 19

The San Francisco 49ers experienced the high of beating a tough division rival on Monday night, routing the Los Angeles Rams 31-10 at Levi's Stadium. The upset victory was the 49ers' first at home in over a year. The Rams were 7-2 entering that game. The 49ers' next opponent owns the opposite record. The Jacksonville Jaguars are 2-7. San Francisco is in no position to take them lightly, though. "We kind of backed ourselves into a corner, and it's not like we're a team that's 8-2," 49ers general manager John Lynch explained on KNBR's Murph & Mac show. "We're 4-5, so we've backed ourselves in a corner where we just don't have that margin for error. And so, I think [we have] the level of urgency. I also believe, coming off a game where we finally put it

Playoff Picture: Where the 49ers stand entering Week 12 showdown with the Vikings

By David Bonilla
Nov 27

The San Francisco 49ers are entering a pivotal clash with the Minnesota Vikings this weekend. A lot is on the line for both teams, who each enter Week 12 with playoff aspirations. On Thanksgiving, the New Orleans Saints fell out of the seventh and final playoff spot after a 31-6 loss to the Buffalo Bills. The 49ers, at 5-5, took their place. That means, if the season ended today, the Vikings and 49ers would own the final two playoff spots. A loss for either team might hurt their efforts to continue playing past Week 18. "Sunday's home game against the Vikings could be a crucial pivot point that dramatically shifts the 49ers' playoff odds, which sat at 33 percent

49ers entrenched in playoff picture but are focused on winning

By Rohan Chakravarthi
Nov 28

The 49ers arguably had their biggest win of the season on Sunday, except for maybe their Week 10 win against the Rams, as they extended their winning streak to three games with an impressive outing against the Minnesota Vikings at Levi's Stadium Behind a rushing attack that exceeded 200 yards, led by rookie Elijah Mitchell, the 49ers were able to control the pace of the game following a shaky start, as they had a 15-minute time of possession advantage over the Vikings, helping them win this much-needed game. Coming into Sunday's matchup, both the 49ers and the Vikings were 5-5 and battling each other for playoff seeding, with San Francisco taking sole possession of the sixth seed in the NFC playoff rankings after the win coupled with Panthers, Eagles, and Saints


More by Sequoia Sims

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone