Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports

Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports

Hall of Fame Case for Frank Gore

Stewart M. Cockrell
Dec 23, 2016 at 8:57 AM

Since there is not really much good to say about the 2016 49ers outside of the promising play of Deforest Buckner and the prospect of Trent Baalke finally doing enough (or lack thereof) to get fired. I'd like to spend a moment to make the case for a former 49er favorite and current Indianapolis Colt Frank Gore for the Hall of Fame.

Frank Gore, entered the league in 2005 as a backup with not much promise as an oft-injured third-round pick out of Miami. In his first season, he backed up Kevin Barlow and amassed 608 yards rushing in 14 games. His coming out year was 2006 though, where he rushed for 1,695 yards and 8 touchdowns. This began a streak of four straight seasons where Gore played at least 14 games and rushed for over 1,000 yards. His 2010 season was cut short with a hip injury but he still put up 853 yards in 11 games. Frank Gore then strung together another four straight years of at least 1,100 yards rushing while not missing a single game. Age and salary cap caused Gore to move onto the Indianapolis Colts for the 2015 and 2016 seasons and has a realistic shot to finish the 2016 season with over 1,000 yards. In doing so, Gore would have eclipsed that mark nine times in his 12-year career.

Gore, who is 33 years old while playing for the 7-7 Colts this season and has passed some big names on the all-time rushing list in the process during the 2016 season. In fact, Gore currently sits 8th on the all-time rushing leaders list in NFL history with 12,931 yards. Gore also sits only 328 yards behind the great Eric Dickerson for 7th all time. While it would take something ridiculous happening for him to get that many yards in the last two games of the season, even if Gore were to hang up his cleats after the season he would be in the rare company in NFL history of running backs.

Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

Consider this; every runner ahead of Gore currently is in the Hall of Fame outside of LaDainian Tomlinson. There are few that argue that Tomlinson will not get his call in 2017 when the yellow jackets are announced prior to Super Bowl 51. Crazier still is that if the season ended today, Gore sits only 754 yards behind Tomlinson for 5th all-time in rushing yards. The only other active running back in Gore's neighborhood is Adrian Peterson who sits at 16th and is 1,184 yards behind Gore. Few will doubt that Peterson will likely catch and pass Gore due to being younger, even if that happens Gore would finish his career solidly in the top ten rushers of all time.

Gore to this point has scored a respectable 74 (24th all-time) touchdowns in his career compared to a whopping 164 for the all-time leader Emmitt Smith and 145 for the aforementioned Tomlinson. However, Gore has accumulated more rushing touchdowns than current Hall of Famers Thurman Thomas (65) and O.J. Simpson (61). On top of being a sturdy runner, Gore has been valuable as a receiver as well piling up an additional 3,401 receiving yards and 16 touchdowns. These yards when combined with his rushing totals gives Gore a current All-Purpose yard total of 16,347 yards which is top 20 of all time and only 185 All-Purpose yards behind Thurman Thomas.

Let's assume Gore plays the 2017 season either for the Colts or for a team looking for a veteran third-down back. While in a limited role it would be hard to imagine Gore matching his 72.6 yards per game career average, we can imagine he averages 50 yards rushing and 25 yards receiving a game for the 2017 season. That would put Gore as the 5th leading rusher of all time and 17th all-time in all-purpose yards. By scoring 6 more touchdowns on top of his current 90 would put him at top 25 in touchdowns all time as well.

The knock on Gore will likely be that he never was an MVP and is far down on the list of all-time rushing touchdowns. There is little doubt that Frank Gore was one (if not the) of the best players on the San Francisco 49ers for his entire career with the team. He currently holds all significant rushing records with the team by a large margin and likely will not be challenged in that aspect for a long time if ever. Likely it will come down to how the Hall of Fame values longevity over awards. Based on statistics alone, Gore seems to have the resume to receive a call from Canton and there is little doubt that he will someday have his name enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
The views within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.

1 Comment

  • Tom
    I always liked Frank and was happy to have him as a 49er for so long. But, his numbers and longevity aside, I have never viewed his as a back that significantly altered the position in any way, or was a back who could really be considered as dominant , which seems to me to be the criteria by which that position should be judged. I have no issue with him being voted in if that happens but I would also have no issue with him not making it.
    Dec 24, 2016 at 2:40 PM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

John Lynch among 15 modern-era finalists for Hall of Fame Class of 2021

By David Bonilla
Jan 5, 2021

The Pro Football Hall of Fame announced its list of 15 modern-era finalists, narrowed down from the 25 semifinalists announced in November, for the Class of 2021. There is one name on the list with ties to the San Francisco 49ers — current Niners general manager and former hard-hitting safety, John Lynch. This is Lynch's eighth consecutive year as a finalist. The former safety was a nine-time Pro Bowl selection throughout his 15-year NFL career with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Denver Broncos. During that time, he registered 1,051 combined tackles, 26 interceptions, 13 sacks, and 16 forced fumbles, according to ESPN. The 49ers named Lynch as their general manager in

Read the Full Article

Adam Rank can't believe ex-49ers LB Patrick Willis isn't a Hall of Fame finalist

By David Bonilla
Jan 6, 2021

For the second consecutive year, former San Francisco 49ers linebacker Patrick Willis failed to make the cutdown from 25 modern-era semifinalists for the Pro Football Hall of Fame to 15 finalists. Many were shocked when Willis' name wasn't among the list of finalists last year. Imagine how they feel after it happened again. NFL Media analyst Adam Rank was among those "absolutely stunned" in 2020 when Willis' name was left off last year's list of finalists. "I thought he was one of the few automatic selections," Rank wrote last year. "But apparently some Hall of Fame voters tend to favor longevity over guys who were dominant over a shorter period of

Read the Full Article

49ers GM John Lynch compares Javon Kinlaw's potential to a Hall of Fame defender

By David Bonilla
Jan 10, 2021

The San Francisco 49ers are excited about defensive lineman Javon Kinlaw's potential. While the rookie defender recorded just 1.5 sacks during his first NFL season, he showed flashes of being a powerful playmaker who could develop into an elite talent along the interior of the defensive line. "I think Kinlaw is going to be a dominant force in this league," John Lynch told Tim Kawakami of The Athletic on The TK Show podcast. "I should say, 'is going to become,' because he's not there yet. He's shown flashes." Lynch knows a thing or two about impressive defensive-line play. He played behind a Hall of Famer in Warren Sapp. In fact, watching his former teammate cause

Read the Full Article


More Featured Stories

More by Stewart M. Cockrell

All Articles by Stewart M. Cockrell

More Articles

All Articles
Share 49erswebzone