Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports

Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports

Will past mistakes make Trent Baalke think twice before drafting a wide receiver in the first round?

Al Sacco
Apr 22, 2015 at 10:20 AM12

In his first five seasons as the San Francisco 49ers' general manager, Trent Baalke made six selections in the first round of the NFL draft. Those picks were: Anthony Davis (2010), Mike Iupati (2010), Aldon Smith (2011), AJ Jenkins (2012), Eric Reid (2013), and Jimmie Ward (2014).

Five of those players made an immediate impact and were or are long-term fixtures on the roster (although the juries still out on Ward, he was the team's nickel corner when healthy last season). The sixth player, however, was a bust of colossal proportions that set the team back at the receiver position

That bust, obviously, was Jenkins, who didn't catch a pass in his only season with the 49ers. As bad of a pick as it was, Jenkins is just another name in a long line of wide receiver flops for San Francisco.

Since drafting Terrell Owens in 1996, the Niners have selected a total of 18 receivers. Only six of those players have gained 1,000 yards in their entire 49er careers. Only one, Michael Crabtree, managed to gain 1,000 yards in a season. So out of 18 draft picks who played 50 individual seasons with the team, only once did any of them again 1,000 yards.

While Baalke wasn't there for all of these mistakes, he hasn't managed to select anyone of note at the position either. Since 2010, Baalke has taken five receivers in the draft. They are Kyle Williams (6th round, 2010), Ronald Johnson (6th round, 2011), Jenkins (1st round, 2012), Quinton Patton (4th round, 2013) and Bruce Ellington (4th round, 2014).

Out of those five, only Williams has more than six career receptions (to balance that out though, he single-handedly fumbled away the 2011 NFC Championship game). Johnson didn't make the team, and Patton has been a disappointment. It's unfair to judge Ellington at this point, however, as he just completed his rookie campaign.

Because of their inability to select a receiver, the position is almost a year-to-year revolving door in which new veterans are brought in every season in an effort to see what sticks. Randy Moss, Mario Manningham, Stevie Johnson, and Brandon Lloyd are all familiar names that didn't live up to past production in recent years, despite the 49ers hoping to catch lightening in a bottle with them.

The one exception to this is Anquan Boldin, who has been the best player at the position the team has had since Owens. In two years in San Francisco, Boldin's averaged 84 catches for 1,120 yards and scored 12 total touchdowns.

Baalke is hoping to get similar production from Boldin's former Baltimore Raven's teammate Torrey Smith, who the team signed to a 5-year, $40 million deal this offseason. It's the largest free agent contract the 49ers have ever given to an offensive player, but when you can't draft a position you don't really have any other choices.

While Smith will be in the fold for the foreseeable future, Boldin could be in his final season with the Niners due to age and contract issues. Because of that, it's extremely likely Baalke will be looking to take a receiver early in the draft.


You know that kid who is playing Little League somewhere in America right now who is praying the ball doesn't get hit to him because he has no idea if he can catch it? That's kind of how I imagine Baalke is feeling about picking a receiver right now.

There are three of them in this draft who look relatively safe: Alabama's Amari Cooper, West Virginia's Kevin White and Louisville's DeVante Parker. There were some rumors previously that the 49ers had interest in exploring what it would take to move up and get Cooper, and that makes sense on many levels.

Cooper is seen as the safest pick at wide out, and the one most scouts consider to be a sure thing. Baalke is probably looking at it the same way...easy catch, can of corn.

The issue with that, however, is Cooper will be long gone when the 49ers pick at 15, and they may have to trade up as high as six to get him. That will be too steep a price considering the amount of holes the team currently has. White, who could go as high as four, is also probably a pipe dream.

Parker may be more of a realistic option, although there's a chance he can go anywhere from pick number 10 on. If he's off the board, Baalke may have a serious dilemma on his hands.

The rest of the receivers who the team could consider taking have some serious boom or bust potential and an argument can be made for taking them in the second round just as much as the first.

Names like Oklahoma's Doriai Green-Beckham and UCF's Breshad Perriman offer plenty of upside, but they could also be major disappointments.

Can Baalke afford to take another chance on a receiver?

I don't think he can, and that's why I believe if Cooper, White or Parker aren't an option, Baalke will draft another position in the first round and wait to address a pass catcher. It's an easy sell because the class is so deep at the position, and someone like Ohio State's Devin Smith or Michigan's Devin Funchess could provide early returns in the later rounds.

How this situation plays out on draft day will be interesting to say the least. Are you ready, Trent? The ball's coming your way.

Al Sacco has covered the 49ers for various sites over the years. He's been a guest on multiple podcasts and has had his work used by ESPN NFL Insiders and USA TODAY. Follow Al on Twitter @AlSacco49
The views within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Marty
    Major reason receivers have struggled the last eight seasons have been HCs Nolan, Singletary & Harbaughs systems. The 49ers offense his been in the 1950's passing offense. These coaches know nothing about NFL passing game. They are not interested. All they ever focus on was the running game. Just maybe Ellington & Patton will improve with the new coaches.
    Apr 26, 2015 at 2:35 AM
  • zach ameen
    Baalke is a failure because he draft for the need; he doesn't pick the best player available. That is why he jumps his guns too early and move up in a draft unnecessarily. His and his offensive scout staff skills in drafting good WRs and other offensive players are "0"
    Apr 25, 2015 at 3:48 PM
  • JayKay
    I don't think Baalke will chance another 1st round WR bust, unfortunately. Arik Armstead is talked a lot with all the measurables but didn't perform like he should of Oregon. I smell a trade down in the first to gain additional pick. But I do agree with another poster he could go for Gurley at 15.
    Apr 23, 2015 at 3:50 PM
  • MrBen
    I'm for taking the chance on DGB in first round,... if we trade back to do it. Patton has really good game speed, and has been working with kaep, so he might be a surprise this year. But if we draft a WR early, you might see him or Simpson not make the team. Time will tell, and the clock never stops ticking.
    Apr 22, 2015 at 10:07 PM
  • RishikeshA
    Thanks Al, the past four years Baalke has had Harbaugh at the point and he could stay in the background. No longer, every move will be scrutinized. When the team was in the running for Super Bowls and a top-flight receiver could have brought 6 and maybe 7 in the trophy case, Baalke did nothing. With his job on the line I don't see him taking a chance for any of the top 3 at the receiver position. He will go with what he feels comfortable with O-line or D-line.
    Apr 22, 2015 at 7:30 PM
  • Tim
    I don't mean to be insulting, but ..... "Stephone Anthony ILB, Monster tackler, Patrick Willis talent Round 4" BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAH!!! Come on man. That is ridiculous.
    Apr 22, 2015 at 3:29 PM
  • wilsonm73
    I hear a lot of people pumping up Ellington and Patton. They will get their opportunity this year and we'll see. And stop it with the injury thing, if they're hurt they're not reliable. I don't buy that the coaches gave preference to the veteran players despite skill level. The coaches aren't stupid and they know winning is their pay check. If Ellington and Patton were so good they should have convincingly beat out those older guys or been drafted higher. They are both likable guys but don't count on them changing the 49ers WR position much. Its something entirely different. Baalke has a formula somewhere that says he can win with old cheap veterans and mid to late round WR's picks. I'd be really surprised if he went WR in round 1 especially with the addition of Simpson and Smith.
    Apr 22, 2015 at 2:44 PM
  • Eric Thornton
    Great read. The WR position has been a revolving door dating back to Braylon Edwards. With the rule changes making for an easier transition for rookie receivers I believe Devin Smith in the 2nd gives us a punchers chance at a capable passing offense.
    Apr 22, 2015 at 2:19 PM
  • brian
    I don't know why, but I have a weird feeling that baalke takes Todd Gurley at 15. Could I be wrong? I hope I'm wrong but there you go.
    Apr 22, 2015 at 12:09 PM
  • Chris
    Did you not read what I said?? Lol he was injured half the year his rookie season made a awesome catch against the cards his rookie year!! Then they picked up aging vets during his second year!! I'm sorry but cmon give him a chance! Him and Ellington are the future!!
    Apr 22, 2015 at 12:03 PM
    Response: I understand where you're coming from, I just don't agree. Barring injury, I think he ends up being the 5th receiver this season (Boldin, Smith, rookie, Ellington, Patton) and won't be on the team in 2016.
  • Chris
    How can you say Patton is a disappointment?? He's been injured half of his rookie year and last year the receiver corps was pretty heavy!!
    Apr 22, 2015 at 11:39 AM
    Response: What has he done? He has 6 catches in two years.
  • Don
    I wouldn't draft a WR with my #15 pick.. Here is what I would do if I were Trent Baalke... Round 1. Arik Armstead DT, Best athlete at the position, fills need Round 2. Phillip Dorsett WR, After burner speed, DeSean Jackson clone Round 3. Stephone Anthony ILB, Monster tackler, Patrick Willis talent Round 4. Mike Davis RB, Natural runner, great instinct Round 4. Josh Shaw CB, Big, fast, high football IQ- a steal Round 5. Mitch Morse OG, Solid solid player-blocks and protects, competitive Round 6. Ty Montgomery WR, A gem this late, can receive, return kicks, Sp teams
    Apr 22, 2015 at 11:03 AM

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Trent Williams on board with 49ers adding QB Trey Lance, doesn't think there will be a QB controversy

By Kirk Larrabee
Jul 27, 2021

49ers offensive tackle Trent Williams has been around the NFL for over a decade, which means he fully understands just how harsh of a business the league can be. For that reason, Williams has no problem with the 49ers' decision to add rookie quarterback Trey Lance even though they already have a proven veteran in Jimmy Garoppolo, and he doesn't seem to think there will be any controversy as a result. Garoppolo led the 49ers to the Super Bowl in 2019 and carries a 22-8 overall record since joining the team in 2017. But he's also missed the bulk of two seasons due to injuries, has a contract with a hefty amount of non-guaranteed money over the next two seasons, and doesn't have the

49ers' Kyle Shanahan impressed by Trey Lance's reaction to mistakes, Jimmy Garoppolo as a mentor

By David Bonilla
Jul 30, 2021

Trey Lance is a rookie. He is bound to make mistakes in his first NFL training camp. The San Francisco 49ers quarterback reportedly made what is described as some questionable throws during practice on Friday. They probably won't be his last. Head coach Kyle Shanahan didn't sound too concerned about the practice miscues. There is no rush to prepare Lance to get onto the football field for a game. The 49ers have a veteran starter in Jimmy Garoppolo. Lance can make those types of mistakes because he has time to learn from them as his NFL education pushes forward. Plus, Lance has ended up being his own biggest critic and is self-motivated to perfect his play. "You don't have to get on him too much," Shanahan told reporters after Friday's practice. "When

Round Table: When will Trey Lance get his first start for the 49ers?

By Site Staff
Jul 23, 2021

Jimmy Garoppolo is expected to be the starting quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers when the team opens the regular season on September 12 against the Detroit Lions. How long he remains the starter is the question. San Francisco traded up to draft Garoppolo's eventual successor, Trey Lance, at No. 3 overall. He will bring a much different dynamic to head coach Kyle Shanahan's offense. The inexperienced quarterback just needs time to learn and master the playbook and scheme. We asked our 49ers Webzone contributors to predict when Lance will get his first start. Below are the responses in the order in which they were received. Chaz Inouye The 49ers should get off to a strong start with what looks to be an easy schedule to begin the season with

Watch 49ers rookie Trey Lance fire up the crowd before practice

By David Bonilla
Jul 29, 2021

San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan regretted not having a rookie player fire up the crowd during the first training camp practice this week. The team has tasked a rookie with doing so in previous years. Obviously, not last year, as no fans were in the stands for practices. "We usually do a rookie hype machine, and I feel like I didn't see it out there today," Shanahan told reporters yesterday. "So I was kind of disappointed with that. I'll get that corrected later today, but it was definitely different (seeing fans again). And I'm so pumped to see it in the stadium." Shanahan did get it corrected. Rookie quarterback Trey Lance, the 49ers' first-round pick, was the one out there getting fans fired up before today's practice — the


More by Al Sacco

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone