Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports

Ed Szczepanski-USA TODAY Sports

State of the 49ers: Free Agency Edition

Stewart M. Cockrell
Mar 18, 2015 at 1:10 PM

Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
Wow…What a crazy couple weeks.

I had originally written this article as a "back off the ledge fellow fans" type of piece but it seemed I couldn't write fast enough to keep up with the unfolding drama. I feel like I need to at least say something about the recent developments.

I once read a quote that stated, "Your strengths maximized become your liabilities". For the past four years, the 49ers' strength has been it defensive unit. The core that existed was one that it was easy to plug role players into and it all kind of fit. From coaching to personnel, it didn't seem that player turnover really hurt us. During this time period, our offense was our biggest liability as it never really turned into the juggernaut that we all expected. Now however, as I look at the team today given free agency departures and recent signings, I think we can all safely say that our defense has the potential to be our biggest liability.

I won't bash Patrick Willis or Chris Borland for walking away from the game. While I will miss watching them play on a weekly basis, I understand the reasons. Willis has been battling chronic foot problems for years, and simply just didn't feel that he could come back and play at a level he was used to. Borland on the other hand is making a decision based on his quality of life. Do I wish someone else would have burned a 3rd round draft pick on him? In hindsight yes because it hurts more that we only got one year out of the pick and that it does set us back from that standpoint. In the immediate aftermath of Willis' retirement, I thought Borland could put together a Zach Thomas type of career filling in for Willis. It puts even more pressure on Navarro Bowman to come back to form.

Speaking of pressure, our personnel department is going to have to hit a home run this year in the draft. While our team has youth at positions to develop, our depth has taken a huge hit. While leading up to the past two weeks I thought we would draft a WR in the first round, after recent signings and developments I think we will be looking at defensive back or a linebacker in the first. The team will no doubt say they don't draft for specific needs and will take the best player available, but I don't think our team has the luxury this season to do that.

Some of my random thoughts on our signings and free agency departures:

Out: Justin Smith? In: Darnell Docket/Tank Carradine

While Justin Smith hasn't made it official yet, there is a real possibility that he is going to walk away from the game too. When I saw the Docket signing I immediately thought he was Smith's replacement. Then I thought about how great it would be to pair Smith and Dockett together. It is for this reason alone that I think you are seeing reports where Justin Smith has said he hasn't made a decision yet and also reports that he might start the season on the PUP to rest him for a playoff run. However, for the sake of the argument, let's assume Smith does walk away and Dockett fills his position. If there is ever a position that the 49ers are rich in, it is defensive line. Comparing the 2013 seasons of Smith and Dockett, you see a lot of similar stats. Dockett recorded 46 tackles and 4.5 sacks while Smith had 49 tackles and 6.5 sacks. I think the organization and fans would be very pleased if Smith retires and Dockett can return from his ACL injury to put up those kinds of numbers. I think the bigger issue will be to replace Ray McDonald's production next to Smith, but the team is hoping that Tank Carridine will be able to fill that void.

Out: Frank Gore In: Carlos Hyde

There was no doubt in my mind that last season was Frank Gore's last in SF. If the team was 25 million under the cap, yes he would have stayed. This team however is not and simply can't invest 5 million a year in a 32 year old running back, no matter how productive he has been over the past four seasons. The biggest thing this team will lose in Frank Gore leaving is his leadership. I have few doubts that Dr. Carlos and Mr. Hyde (along with Hunter) can fill the production that Gore gave us. In fact Hyde might be able to give us something Gore couldn't over the past few years, the ability to finish long runs with TD's. I know fans are excited about the Reggie Bush signing, but I don't see really how he fits into the equation yet. You can't bring him in to use in the screen game exclusively because the other team will see through that. At best he is going to be a boutique type player that will probably get limited touches. Likely the team will look to use him like LeMichael James during the 2012 season in the read option.

Out: Michael Crabtree In: Torrey Smith

Torrey Smith to the 49ers is a done deal and Crabtree is still a free agent. Crabtree was a fine player for the 49ers and a big reason why the 49ers made a run to the Super Bowl two seasons ago. However, he is injury prone and you never know how healthy his feet are going to be. Am I broken hearted he is leaving? Not really. The proof that he has made it this far in free agency means that other teams don't value him like he valued himself.

The addition of Torrey Smith is tantalizing from a deep ball threat standpoint. A young, talented, and fast receiver in the prime of his career is something any fan can get behind. His 16.8 YPC career average along with 40 career touchdowns dwarf Crabtree's 12.9 average and 26 touchdowns despite playing 1.5 seasons less than Crabtree. Bottom line is, Smith is an upgrade over Crabtree even if the team over pays a bit for him. Kaepernick has the arm strength to throw the deep ball, and the jury is still out in my opinion if the lack of success is on Kaepernick or the current set of receivers on the team. The biggest question mark I have is how he will stack up in our physical division. My gut instinct says pretty good, considering the division he is coming from. This signing makes the addition of a first round WR less of a priority unless one of the all world guys just happens to fall to us at 15.

Out: Mike Iupati In: Marcus Martin/Brandon Thomas/Daniel Kilgore/Joe Looney/Erik Pears

Yeah, you read that list right. That is how many people the 49ers have that can fill (not replace) Mike Iupati's position at left guard. I'm a big fan of Iupati because he is a rare player that just was designed to be a road grader in the run game. However his weakness was always in the passing game and I think while the 49ers will miss him in the run game, they might be better off with a potential improvement in pass protection. I could actually even see Boone moving over to left guard and the battle being at right guard. Bottom line is, the 49ers are stacked with interior linemen that are more than serviceable. As I noted last season during training camp, the 49ers would likely not pay big money for guards and the team has pretty much followed suit with my thoughts. It stings that Iupati will be playing for the Cardinals, but no more than how they feel about Dockett playing for the 49ers. I still look for the team to take another interior lineman in the draft this year to develop. If I was a betting man, I think you are going to see a starting offensive line of Staley, Marcus Martin, Kilgore, Boone, and Davis.

Out: Chris Culliver & Perish Cox In: Jimmy Ward, Dontae Johnson, Chris Cook, Shareece Wright, Kenneth Acker, Cameron Fuller, Leon McFadden, Keith Reaser, Marcus Cromartie

Culliver and Cox are gone and it appears the team didn't really make an effort to resign them. I do think that we have some good young players at the CB position. My biggest concern is Brock staying healthy as he was a non-factor last year. Johnson played a lot as a rookie and played fairly well. Reaser is a 4.3 40 guy that could develop into a nice nickel player even though Ward is our projected nickel back however Ward will eventually move to his natural position of safety at some point you would think. Acker is a big tall corner that still ran a sub five second 40. This is another position while untested; the 49ers have a lot of players to groom, even though there are a few players that Baalke "red-shirted" last season. I still see the team adding another defensive back or two in the draft, even as high as the first or second round. The effectiveness of our secondary will depend largely (as it always has) on our pass rush ability.

It always hurts to loose core players; especially players that have been to the pro bowl and helped you go deep in the playoffs. But then again, teams lose these players all the time. As a fan we have to hope that the front office knows what they are doing (I'm still on the fence) and trust that the additions will mesh into the culture that our team has. One thing is for sure; I think the 2015 season is beginning to shape up for a wild ride.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • 50 year FORMER faithful
    OUT:WINS IN:LOSSES 100% about failed ownership. This is about honestly appraising a now lengthy track record of multiple bad football decisions. Jed defers to Baalke on personnel and is obviously is not studying each and every player to the degree winning owners do. Boy blunder gonna start a soccer team with all that spare time. No dedication, no heart, no passion. He is dependent and not an NFL expert Boy blunder should be 100% about the team and nothing else. Otherwise sell the team and go run a mall, restaurant, or some other business where your failure does not result in emotional pain for countless fans and financial waste for the gullible ticket holders. The San Francisco 49ers were once a great brand. They now are a joke of a franchise with dim prospects. Until the York family sells the 49ers, the 49er s will remain a joke, a mediocre team run by disloyal incompetent liars and greedy ignoble cowards incapable of putting winning before their egos. When the answer to "How do we get better?", after 3 NFC title games and a SB, is to fire the best coach in 20 years because he rubs you wrong? Then you have sheer ego driven incompetence. The 49ers are DONE, Thx JED
    Mar 20, 2015 at 7:52 AM
  • cj
    He's 100% right!
    Mar 19, 2015 at 8:41 PM
  • Frank M
    Stewart, Well-balanced article...nice to see amid all the doomsdayers out there. You hit on a point lost on many analysts and fans...that Baalke's done a terrific job of stockpiling talent the last few years. Had he not done that, I'd have to agree there would be no way the team could recover. He's also signed some key FA's...to get our WR corps considerably faster. I see Bush used in a variety of ways...but he won't and shouldn't be used as a between-the-tackles RB. His biggest strength, as shown when he was with the Saints, is to be a receiver. He can come out of the backfield, line up in the slot, whatever...the point is you get this guy the ball in open space. He still has enough speed to make an impact. He only signed a 1-yr contract, so that tells me Baalke will indeed draft another RB. Dockett was a fortuitous signing...not only because he could be the bridge from Justin Smith, but also be the vet to take Aldon under his wing. A blog from him alluded to that, which is good news. Haven't heard anything from Sterling Moore's visit...I hope Baalke signs him. He'd add to a talented, but largely untested CB corps. Baalke should rock this draft at #15.
    Mar 19, 2015 at 9:39 AM
  • Marquis
    You crazy. You think Reggie Bush is going to be the next Lamichael James? James can't carry Bush's jock strap man. Bush has been successful and put up baller numbers for every team he's played for. You think he's gonna play 2nd fiddle to some guy named Hyde? Cmon out of the homer trailer. Meet Reggie Bush, your #1 runningback and your #2 receiving threat, if Vernon Davis continues to struggle/be injured.
    Mar 19, 2015 at 8:47 AM
    Response: My actual words were, the team will use him "like" they used James. No comparison on the players. Bush is a much stronger player the James clearly. I just don't know how he fits into the game plan yet.
  • Mike
    Why cry and complain there's nothing, as fans, that you can do about it? Enjoy the journey and take it for what it is, a sport, a pastime. On the other hand, If the defense struggles, Kap will have even more pressure on him, having to play catch-up in most games. Unless he figured something out this off-season, expect a record high in sacks and turnovers.
    Mar 19, 2015 at 7:34 AM
  • Pace42
    Thank you for a the sky is not falling article. I have my worries but we have people on D just like last year to make us top just hoping EM is good and can pull it off. Offense hey let Kap and Hyde do their thing not this don't you dare run or we will shoot you crap. Iupati sucked at pass protection and wasn't even rated high at run blocking per PFF either so who cares. Tank and Lynch looked beast last year especially Lynch. Add Dial/Dorsey/Williams/Dorsett. Plus Smith isn't stalling for a reason. He very likely will come back. Line and outside backers are sick. Now inside yes PW52 is my boy and it hurts. He's my favorite 9er D side since Ronnie Lott. My favorite 9er ever. Why does everyone think Bowman won't come back at say 90%? He and Whilote would be better then Borland and W last year. Depth takes a hit ok. CB position loaded with talent and let the best man play. Safety well damn we are ok. Let it play out. I worry about coaching more then players.
    Mar 19, 2015 at 1:55 AM
  • Fan
    I agree with Kieper's prediction. The team is in a free fall. The Go team rah rah fans will think all is well.....but it's not.
    Mar 18, 2015 at 9:02 PM
  • joeper
    Mel Kieper Jr. is predicting the 49ers will have 4-12 season in 2015
    Mar 18, 2015 at 8:34 PM
  • Fan
    How about the real west coast offense coming back. Oh, that's right...Kap isn't capable of running those plays. 6-10 to 3-13 this year.
    Mar 18, 2015 at 8:32 PM
  • sacninerfan
    Finally! Thank you for not yelling "the sky is falling" like so many others on this site have recently. I agree with your article here, and think we should wait till the season starts before we judge. I really like Kevin White and if the Niners entertained the thought last year to move up for OBJ, they can surely move up this year for KW(a lot less of a jump). Really not sure which way they will go in the draft though, thoughts?
    Mar 18, 2015 at 5:17 PM
  • don
    You failed to review out Wiilis/Borland, in Skov, Moody, Wilhoite and Chase..
    Mar 18, 2015 at 1:44 PM
    Response: True. Mostly because I honestly think there will be a rookie starting next to Bowman next year. Although I saw a rumor that Brooks might be sliding inside and Lynch will start in his place. I'm not sure if that rumor scares or intrigues me considering Brooks seems to be morphing into a nose tackle with his eating habits. I do think that Wilhoite played quite well and will be the starter heading into training camp.
  • Monte
    I don't think Forester and his zone blocking scheme is being talked about enough. How does it play into read option which is Kaps forte and I believe Hyde ran in college. The power running game that was featured I believe is gone..something new! Some real new woulf be scoring touchdowns in the red zone...someting Harbaugh and Roman couldn't get done! New offense new philosophy ...better results. When the newness of Kap wore off. Harbaugh couldn't adjust!!!!!
    Mar 18, 2015 at 1:38 PM
    Response: You bring up a good point that I hadn't thought of. I think our offense is going to look a lot different. I am really wondering how our route trees will differ under Cryst. It was always disappointed in the linear approach Roman had to the passing game.

More San Francisco 49ers News

Will the 49ers sign Brandon Aiyuk? Schefter weighs in

By David Bonilla
Jul 4

The San Francisco 49ers hold significant leverage in their negotiations with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. Aiyuk is under contract for the upcoming season, and the team can use the franchise tag to retain him in 2025 and 2026. Despite this, both parties would benefit from...

Why CBS Sports named Brandon Aiyuk the 49ers' most underappreciated player

By David Bonilla
Jul 4

Brandon Aiyuk has dominated San Francisco 49ers-related storylines this offseason as the star player seeks a contract extension that will make him one of the NFL's highest-paid receivers. Given his consecutive 1,000-yard seasons, it's surprising to see Aiyuk listed among...

Former NFL exec ranks 49ers' Brock Purdy among NFL's best young players

By David Bonilla
Jul 4

ESPN isn't alone in its high regard for San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy. Former NFL executive Jeff Diamond also ranks Purdy among the best NFL players under the age of 25 on his list for The 33rd Team. Purdy comes in at No. 6, behind only Justin Jefferson, Micah...

De'Vondre Campbell ready to impress 49ers, fill in for Dre Greenlaw

By David Bonilla
Jul 5

De'Vondre Campbell wasn't the San Francisco 49ers' first choice this offseason when it came to adding linebacker help. Dre Greenlaw is still recovering from the torn Achilles he suffered in February's Super Bowl and will likely miss at least a few weeks at the start of the...


More by Stewart M. Cockrell

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone