Derick E. Hingle-USA TODAY Sports

Derick E. Hingle-USA TODAY Sports

Saints fans: We know how you feel

Nov 13, 2014 at 1:28 PM8

It's been four days since the San Francisco 49ers' 27-24 overtime victory against the New Orleans Saints. It was a must-win for the two 4-4 clubs. After all, the difference between 5-4 and 4-5 is historically huge when it comes to a team's playoff chances. Since 2002, 49% of teams that have started the season 5-4 have made the playoffs. That percentage drops to 13% for a team that starts off 4-5. That difference means more to the 49ers than the Saints. After all, even with Sunday's loss, the Saints are somehow still in command of the NFC South. However, the 49ers are in a different situation. Now sitting at 5-4, they are still in third place in the NFC West, three games behind the leading Arizona Cardinals, a game behind the Seattle Seahawks, and still fighting for they playoff lives.

Despite still leading their division, Saints fans are still bitter over the overtime loss to the 49ers and a controversial ending to the fourth quarter. All I can say to those still frustrated on how the that quarter ended is, "49ers fans know how you feel."

On Sunday, there were five seconds left in regulation with the game tied up 24-24 at the Mercedes-Benz Superdome in New Orleans. Saints quarterback Drew Brees had just spiked the ball after getting his team to the 49ers' 47 yard line. He lined up in the shotgun, dropped back, moved up into the pocket and let go of a Hail Mary pass that made it all the way to tight end Jimmy Graham, who leaped in the end zone and hauled in the touchdown. The crowd at the Superdome erupted in cheers as they witnessed an exciting finish to an already great game.

Their Saints had won the game on yet another amazing play by the team's two best players in Brees and Graham. 49ers head coach Jim Harbaugh even threw his play calling sheets into the air in frustration as he watched his 49ers lose their third straight game. It would be the team's first three-game losing streak since he took over as head coach. The 49ers' postseason hopes, which were already on life support, looked very bleak at best.

Hold on a second. What was that on the field? It was a yellow flag. Graham, along with Saints fans at the game, stared in disbelief. Was this really going to get called back? Indeed it was. The call was offensive pass interference on Graham, nullifying the spectacular play. Graham had been flagged for pushing off on 49ers defensive back Perrish Cox, who sold it very well.

Graham argues the call

The fourth quarter would end in a tie and the 49ers would go on to win the game in overtime. Was it the correct call? Yes. Should it have been called on a Hail Mary play where, typically, almost anything goes? Maybe not, but it was still the correct call.

How will this one play and one penalty impact the remainder of the season for both teams? We'll have to wait and see.

Rewind almost exactly one year.

The setting was the same. We were at the Mercedes-Benz Superdome in New Orleans. The opponents were the same and the situation was -- different, yet still strangely similar.

The 49ers led 20-17 with 3:18 remaining in the game as Brees dropped back from the 49ers' 35 yard line. Linebacker Ahmad Brooks hits Brees, the ball pops out of his hands and into the waiting arms of a very alert Patrick Willis. 49ers fans watching on television jumped up and cheered as the 49ers would take over near midfield while holding onto a three point lead with 3:12 left on the clock. Patrick Willis held up the ball getting ready to celebrate.

Hold on a second. What was that on the field behind him? It was a yellow flag. Brooks had been flagged for a personal foul -- contact to the neck of the quarterback. It was a 15-yard penalty and an automatic first down for the Saints.

Harbaugh and 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick, yelling from the sidelines, argued that it was a hit on the shoulder. The Saints would go on to tie the game on the extended drive, and eventually win 23-20 in the closing seconds of regulation.

During the days following the game, debate ran rampant among the media on whether Brooks should have been flagged. When he was fined $15,750 for the hit, even more public opinion surfaced. Former Baltimore Ravens great Ray Lewis called it "the most embarrassing call in the National Football League since the Tuck Rule and Tom Brady."

Brooks would eventually win an appeal of the fine.

It is entirely possible the Saints would have won the game anyways. However, it would have been an uphill battle for them as they watched valuable time come off the clock.

How did this one play and one penalty impact the remainder of the season for both teams?

The Saints would have still made the playoffs as a wild-card, having beaten the Arizona Cardinals during the regular season and owning the tie-breaker between the two teams.

The 49ers situation would have been very different. They would have finished the season 13-3 and home field advantage throughout the NFC playoffs. The 49ers split their series with Seattle but had a slightly better division record. Instead of playing two tough road games (at Green Bay and at Carolina) before meeting up with the Seahawks at CenturyLink Field in the NFC Championship game, they would have hosted a Divisional playoff game before possibly hosting the NFC Championship game themselves. It would have been the Seahawks that would have had to go on the road during the postseason.

Perhaps linebacker NaVorro Bowman never gets injured in the NFC Championship, which would have impacted the 49ers' 2014 season as well. Maybe it would have been Colin Kaepernick and Jim Harbaugh hoisting the Vince Lombardi Trophy after beating the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl XLVIII, the 49ers' second appearance in the league championship game in as many years.

That's a lot of what-ifs. Perhaps the 49ers lose in the Divisional round and the Seahawks still go on to win it all. The point is, the 49ers' path to a championship would have been much easier had their matchup with the Saints ended differently. It was a big loss for the 49ers and devastating towards their playoff positioning.

This past Sunday, Ahmad Brooks did get a little redemption against the Saints. With 5:25 left in overtime, he hit Brees from behind, knocking the ball loose and allowing linebacker Chris Borland to pounce on it. The 49ers would kick the game-winning field goal on the next play.

With this victory, Harbaugh won his 20th career road game, becoming the second fastest head coach in franchise history to do so.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Barney Fife
    I don't even know what the point of this article is----it was clearly a penalty and the refs got it right.....end of story. If they had missed it, then it would be a story. I couldn't believe that cheater Graham was actually crying about it. It was clear for all to see he blatantly pushed off. It the defensive back breathes on a receiver he gets called for interference. Why shouldn't the offensive player get called for an obvious penalty?
    Apr 8, 2015 at 4:53 PM
  • Rick Reulecke
    The fact of the matter is that whether he pushed off or not, the referee's are just as much a part of the game as the Quarterback, running back or tight end. Whether the call goes for us or against us, there is NOTHING that any amount of bitching in this context will cure. A receiver drops a game winning pass or a referee throws a flag - there is literally no difference, both are a part of the GAME. Shoulda woulda coulda does not send your team to the playoffs, winning does
    Nov 22, 2014 at 4:00 AM
  • RishikeshA
    Thanks David, it's about time a call went our way. The fact that it was there for everyone to see helped. Every camera angle showed the push. That being said the last play of the game is usually left alone by the refs. Remember Crabs being mugged in the SB and the entire Raven punt team with bear hugs on 49er players during the safety.
    Nov 14, 2014 at 9:46 AM
  • Monsterniner
    I couldn´t care less if they´re mad. Last year we lost with an embarrassing call that at the end the NFL reversed when Brooks won his appeal. The refs stole that game from us. Now we won with a clear OPI because OPI´s and DPI´s are the same according to the NFL rules. We won and now it´s their turn to whine. The difference is that we were right last year.
    Nov 13, 2014 at 6:33 PM
  • Jerry
    Oh let's see if anyone recalls A.Boldin gets a pass interference penalty earlier in game which would have given NINERS a first down and driving for a potential score instead first down and twenty so the point Jimmy quit crying you pushed off.
    Nov 13, 2014 at 3:25 PM
  • JohnJPDX
    I think it only looks like he flopped in slo mo. At real speed it clearly looks like opi IMO
    Nov 13, 2014 at 3:15 PM
  • TJ
    Now only if we could have got these calls in the SB against the Ravens.
    Nov 13, 2014 at 3:07 PM
  • Craig
    "What was that on the field? It was a yellow flag." One correction, it was two yellow flags thrown at exactly the same time. The call was right. I hate the idea that some situations call for different rules. If so put it in the rule book. i.e. A receiver who extends his arms to push a defensive back and create space has committed pass interference, unless the ball is thrown over 30 yards and the game clock shows less than 10 seconds and a resulting score would allow said team to take a lead or tie the game.
    Nov 13, 2014 at 1:48 PM
    Response: I think the rule should go in the book exactly as you wrote it. It seems fitting for the NFL.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

49ers' George Kittle wishes NFL fans were more like college football fans

By David Bonilla
Jun 23

San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle joined the Bussin' with the Boys podcast this week, joined by Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen. Both are in Tennessee for Kittle's Tight End University. Allen is among several quarterbacks on hand to throw footballs to the large contingent of tight ends. During the lengthy conversation on the Barstool Sports podcast, the topic of fanbases came up. Allen has played in front of Bills Mafia his entire career, while Kittle has been among The Faithful. The two groups create very different atmospheres heading into game days, leading Kittle to reflect on his college playing days at

49ers Mailbag: Reactions to fans' hot-takes

By Marc Adams
Jun 21

The good news? We're about five weeks away from 49ers training camp. The bad news? We're about five weeks away from 49ers training camp. We are now in the slowest, most boring time of the year for football fans. But we have you covered. We asked San Francisco 49ers fans for their hot takes or predictions regarding the team. Several responded. And now we're going to expose them (sorry—I meant "respond to" them). Let's get to it! Michael Arbios: Hot take is shouldn't have passed on Brady twice and keep Garoppolo, as Lance isn't ready to be the starter as proven by his poor play in the two games he started last season. I'm not sure how 'hot' this take is, due to its age, but I agree that the 49ers should have traded Jimmy Garoppolo


More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone