The 49ers’ Backwards Draft

May 14, 2014 at 10:22 AM


Prior to the 2014 draft, mockers had settled into a fairly consistent consensus based on Niner team needs. Prognosticators predicted the prospectors would select wide receiver, cornerback, and pass-rusher in the early rounds, while perhaps selecting from among the safety, running back, center, and/or linebacker positions later in the draft. Likely the 49ers, with such a loaded roster, would trade up to take their targeted players.

Indeed, at the start of the day, the 49ers did pick, in order, a wide receiver, a cornerback, and a pass rusher. Some experts thought the Niners "reached" in selecting Ellington so early, but … wait just one blasted minute. The 49ers selected receiver, cornerback, and pass-rusher at the start of the draft's third day, not its first. In fact, if you flip-flopped that third day with the draft's first two, you would have come much closer to the team-needs order of picks as previously posted by the consensus.

This seeming-backwards priority the Niners gave to their draft selections initially baffled bloggers and puzzled pundits. The commentariot used words like "surprised," "shocked," and "confused." Even the normally unflappable Jaws dropped his jaws. Mike Singletary jostled his trousers. The 49ers themselves restored order somewhat when they revealed that their first-round choice, Jimmie Ward, although nominally a safety, would compete for the nickel corner spot, and that, through the Brandon Lloyd signing and Stevie Johnson trade, they had well bolstered the receiver position. Fans gained further succor when the overall draft grades arrived, and the consensus again anointed the Niners' selectors as once-and-future draft-gurus. The 49er faithful resumed their daily lives, saved from undo anxiety by Mel Kiper, Mike Mayock, and the local Matts.

However what might this gap – some would even say "chasm" – between the pre-draft consensus and the ensuing actuality tell us about the Niners organization, and about our misperceptions?

The "stacked roster" theory.

According to this theory, the 49ers should have bundled picks to move up and take future stars, since eleven rookies had no chance of making the team's final roster anyway. Compared to many teams, the Niners may indeed have a stacked roster. Indubitably, they have a superb set of starters, with some solid second-stringers, which allows for the perception of a loaded roster. In truth, the team hasn't fielded top-to-bottom depth since approximately a quarter century ago. Few other teams, in the salary-cap era, have either. The salient point being, regardless of what I or others might think, the 49ers themselves do not believe they, as of yet, have a stacked roster. As Baalke himself said at his post-draft presser, the team doesn't want just good starters and second-stringers, but, rather, "fifty-three … good football players." Baalke may have said this, partly, to cover for the inability, during this year's third day, to trade for further future picks. But the statement also fits with the team's overall philosophy.

Yes, the 49ers intend to buck the salary-cap constraints that cripple some franchises and relegate others to "windows." Notice Baalke did not say "fifty-three stars," or "fifty-three studs," or "fifty-three Richard Shermans." No. He talks about "good football players." How might a roster filled with these stalwarts help to maintain a perpetual contender? By having at hand players to replace the fallen, whether those gone from attrition, age, injury, or, that's right, free agency. Or gone from internal competition, and Harbalk does believe that such competition will surely winnow out the best fifty-three.

The "windows" theory.

In other words, the 49ers attempt to manage the salary cap by signing their elite players to reasonable contract extensions before said starters blow up big time, and by having replacements at the ready for the starters who do exit, ergo 2014's dozen draftees. The team may or may not currently be in a championship window, but the organization's honchos themselves refuse to acknowledge the stultifying confines of any such mere framed glass. Rather like the infamous clip of Jim Mora ranting about the playoffs, Harbalk responds to any windows questions with the equivalent of "Windows? Windows! What windows?"

This way of running a team may prove a quixotic quest or simply a hardheaded folly, but one must give the outfit credit for guts, ambition, and try. They aint afraid to compete. And they aint afraid to fail. Nor do they quail from going against the consensus grain on draft day -- no matter how many windmill-blades, or second-guessers, might later bop them on their noggins.

Grinders

Yes, I confess, I too had draft crushes this year, a certain receiver taken in the top twelve picks, and a certain cornerback that went in the top twenty-five. Alas, as they do every year, the 49ers dashed my dreams. At one point in the process, around early February, with the bitter taste of Seahawk celebration still stinging my tongue, I even dreamed the 49ers might use their bounty of picks to move up and secure both players. Alackaday all over again. How pretty, how sweet, how exhilarating to see a fast, streaking 49er wideout stretch out his full length, with, say, Richard Sherman and Earl Thomas in forlorn pursuit, to gather in an eighty-yard touchdown pass, his third of this season's conference championship game. Our very own red-and-gold offensive rookie-of-the-year! Yes! And, then, next game, our very own defensive rookie-of-the-year assures our Super Bowl victory with an interception in the end zone, this time for our side!

Well, so do off-seasons dare us to dream, and drafts lure us into the illusion that every player our team selects will become a future star, our team envied throughout the football world, and our fanatic fandom validated by a Super Bowl win witnessed by millions. However, the gridiron game itself, with very little input from us other than our eyeballs, compels a sometimes cold-hearted realism from the men who actually manage it. (And, yes, they're mostly still men.) Notice that when the 49ers finally did take a receiver, in the fourth round, they chose one, in part, because he blocks. I admit, mea culpa, that the willingness to block was not a high priority for any of my draft-crush receivers. But it was for the 49ers.

No, the 49ers did not select many prima donnas. No internationally known stars for them. Television commentators did not gush over their picks for hours ahead of time as with, say, Johnny Manziel. In fact, while I admire Manziel as a football player, with regard to image-burnishing, the Niners had a kind of anti-Manziel draft. Few had even heard of their first-round pick, Jimmie Ward, and, hard upon the pick's announcement, one could hear a thudding chorus of "Huh?" resound throughout the Bay Area. Even the 49ers' most well-known pick, probably Carlos Hyde, does not dazzle with dancelike moves, but rather runs hard and heavy. They also picked on that second day a center, a linebacker, a guard. You can almost hear those new recruits, and those they will soon hit, grunt.

In other words, as per their philosophy, the Niners, for the most part, selected a group of grinders. "Grind" is a favorite Harbaugh term, and one often gets the feeling that the coach would much rather win games by three points instead of three touchdowns. "Grinders" may well serve as Harbaugh's synonym for Baalke's "good football players." Whether those two do or do not often speak we do not know, but, rest assured, they remain on the same wave-length. Hard-nosed, gritty, old-school. Some may find the Harbalk way not very pretty, glamourless, even inelegant. But, as this draft demonstrates, the 49ers believe in the fundamentals of power football, and in the draft room, as well as on the field of play, they continue to grind.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


6 Comments

  • JerseySmellTours
    I just don't understand much about these 49er's? Conventional football theory holds that dominate defenses should have strong/solid special teams, excellent kickers, and play smart turn-over free football. I see most, if not all of that theorem when you watch the Seahawks play winning football(these two franchises enjoy team defense rankings 1-2)but these two teams style vary 180 degrees from that point on. Pete Carroll jumped ship from USC to the NFL he was one step ahead of NCCA sanctions and many felt that Seattle was an indication of that as they were almost universally seen as a very weak franchise whereas Sf49er's were stocked with talent on offense and defense. Sf asks a very productive QB like Mr. "K" to take crazy risks normally seen by a second-third tier team trying to cover over team wide weaknesses. It comeback to haunt them with that crazy, forced, no-reason to even consider throwing pass that Sherman took as a gift(big contract was coming his way but that got it to him that much faster)I have to wonder what does their coach know about this team that has him playing away from their strengths and tying to make this team into a Offensive juggernaut
    May 27, 2014 at 11:39 PM
    1
  • BW
    Looking back at the 48 year history of the Super Bowl, the vast majority of teams have about a 4 year window from their first to last victories before another long drought. The exceptions: Joe Montana led 49ers of 81-89, Staubach led Cowboys of 71-77, and Bradshaw led Steelers of 74-79. Among the losers, Tarkenton went four times from 69-76 and Brady won in 01 but lost in 12. Notice all but one are before the advent of free agency. While no coach or GM ever wants to admit it, these windows close VERY QUICKLY! This is now year 3 for the 49ers, and this was the year to get bold by trading up for Mike Evans, the player that Gil Brandt said is the next Calvin Johnson. Too expensive? Odds are that 6-7 of these picks won't make it anyway. They berated me online when I said stock pile extra picks for 2012 and then trade the entire draft for Andrew Luck. Looks now like Baalke's entire 2012 draft is a total bust!
    May 15, 2014 at 5:28 PM
    0
  • Matt
    Frank M: How in the world can you say the 2011 Draft was not good? We're talking about the draft that landed Aldon Smith and Colin Kaepernick. After those 2 stars the team got many very good players in that draft.
    May 15, 2014 at 6:25 AM
    1
    Response: Frank M said "some say the 2011 and 2012 drafts weren't good." He didn't say so directly himself.
  • Frank M
    This draft once again proved those who spent countless hours doing their mock drafts were dreaming. They should know better by now...Baalke and Harbaugh do things their way. It's hard to argue with the overall results...no matter some say the 2011 and 12 drafts weren't good. The team itself is just fine...Kap now has more weapons than he's ever had. The OL is strong and getting stronger. Marcus Martin's a mountain of a man who can move. RB's with varying skills are strong and deep. Hyde and Lattimore are the new guard. The future's bright, thanks to Baalke's "red-shirts". Defense is strong despite Bowman's injury...Wilhoite & Borland's battle for interim starter while Navarro heals should be epic. Jimmie Ward's impact play upgrades the secondary...Dontae Johnson's on board to provide press coverage. Reaser and Acker are good-sized, fast CB's. There will be some vets aced out of their roster spots as the team gets younger, stronger and faster. Works for me.
    May 14, 2014 at 2:08 PM
    0
  • Militiaades
    The 49ers drafted well if they were drafting as team with many needs. I doubt these picks will go down as a great draft for a team who's biggest needs were top notch cornerbacks and wide receivers. Baalke had a good draft in 2011 but I haven't seen much to write home about since then. If this turns out to be another bust I'd have someone else do the drafting next year.
    May 14, 2014 at 12:52 PM
    0
  • Big Al
    The Niners may grind on the ground, but this group of Wrs better put on their track shoes because the cannot will be shooting bullets.
    May 14, 2014 at 10:56 AM
    1

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



John Lynch: 49ers learning from draft hits and misses; Aaron Banks, Ambry Thomas will contribute

By David Bonilla
Oct 17

A lot is riding on the selection of Trey Lance. The future of the San Francisco 49ers — and likely head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch — depends on the rookie quarterback developing into an impact player. The NFL Draft has seemingly been a crapshoot for the Niners. For every Nick Bosa, there is a Solomon Thomas or Reuben Foster. There have been George Kittles and Fred Warners. However, selections like Dante Pettis severely impact evaluations of recent draft classes. The jury is still out on last year's first-rounders, Javon Kinlaw and Brandon Aiyuk. The latter's lack of involvement this season has been baffling. The 49ers have hit



Golden Nugget Award: This week's winner should excite the 49ers fanbase

By Sasha D. Robinson
Oct 13

Week 5's Golden Nugget Award winner goes to defensive tack D.J. Jones. The other nominees for this week's award are quarterback Trey Lance for his first NFL start, defensive end Nick Bosa, linebacker Fred Warner for his dominance on defense, and punter Mitch Wishnowsky for his 48.5 punt average in the loss against the Arizona Cardinals, dropping the San Francisco 49ers to 2-3. The former Ole Miss Rebel did not have a dominant performance in the game but his sack on Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray in the first quarter had Twitter erupted. OhMyGoodness DJ



No Huddle Podcast: What's up with the 49ers? Talking Trey Lance's 1st start, Kyle Shanahan, and more

By Site Staff
Oct 13

Al Sacco and guest co-host Jason Aponte of the "Sprint Right Option Podcast" wonder what is happening with the San Francisco 49ers and the strangeness of the 2021 season. Plus: Trey Lance's start: Was the game plan suspect? The Brandon Aiyuk situation What teams would take Kyle Shanahan over their coach? Expectations after the bye You can listen to the latest "No Huddle Podcast" episode above, from our



49ers protect QB Nate Sudfeld, two others from the practice squad

By David Bonilla
Oct 13

The San Francisco 49ers protected three practice squad players this week. The team is currently in its bye week and will face the Indianapolis Colts at Levi's Stadium on Sunday, October 24. The three players protected are tight end Tanner Hudson, offensive lineman Colton McKivitz, and quarterback Nate Sudfeld, per The Athletic. 49ers this week protected practice squadders:* TE Tanner Hudson* OL Colton McKivitz* QB Nate SudfeldYou may have read somewhere that QBs Jimmy Garoppolo (calf) and Trey Lance (knee) are dealing with injuries.— Matt Barrows (@mattbarrows)


Featured

More by D.C. Owens

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone