Photo by Kelley L Cox of USA Today Sports

Photo by Kelley L Cox of USA Today Sports


How the 49ers starting roster was built: Free agency versus the NFL Draft

Mar 6, 2014 at 2:22 PM2


The official San Francisco 49ers site published an interesting article yesterday. It showed how the current 49ers roster was built and broke it down by draft picks versus free agent signings. The number of draftees versus free agency signees on the team was nearly even. In fact, free agents only outnumbered draft picks by one. Below is the final breakdown of the team's 2013 roster.

30 free agents
29 draftees
3 trades
2 waiver claims

This shows that, when it comes to building the 49ers roster, free agency is just as important as draft selections. Or is it? The article takes the entire roster into account. However, that may not be the case on the offensive side of the ball when you only look at the best players on the roster, represented by the team's starters. The team's starting offense shows a very different picture.

2013 Starting Offense

QB - Colin Kaepernick - 2011 NFL Draft
RB - Frank Gore - 2005 NFL Draft
FB - Bruce Miller - 2011 NFL Draft
WR - Michael Crabtree - 2011 NFL Draft
WR - Anquan Boldin - 2013 Trade
TE - Vernon Davis - 2006 NFL Draft
LT - Joe Staley - 2007 NFL Draft
LG - Mike Iupati - 2010 NFL Draft
C - Jonathan Goodwin - 2011 Free Agency
RG - Alex Boone - 2009 Undrafted Free Agent
RT - Anthony Davis - 2010 NFL Draft

Eight of the eleven starters on offense were acquired via the NFL Draft. Those players are shown in bold. Only two players were acquired via free agency. Boldin is the lone player acquired via a trade. The 49ers have built this starting offense via the draft and we can assume that trend will continue as the new league year and free agency begins on Tuesday. In recent years, the 49ers have not been big spenders in free agency. Instead, they let the initial days of chaos pass and allow the players demanding the highest prices fall of the board and then try to find bargains that can fill spots on the roster or add depth. The team's future is acquired via the NFL Draft.

2013 Starting Defense

DT - Ray McDonald - 2007 NFL Draft
DT - Justin Smith - 2008 Free Agency
NT - Glenn Dorsey - 2013 Free Agency
OLB - Aldon Smith - 2011 NFL Draft
MLB - NaVorro Bowman - 2010 NFL Draft
MLB - Patrick Willis - 2007 NFL Draft
OLB - Ahmad Brooks - 2008 Waivers
CB - Carlos Rogers - 2011 Free Agency
CB - Tarell Brown - 2007 NFL Draft
SS - Donte Whitner - 2011 Free Agency
FS - Eric Reid - 2013 NFL Draft

Among the starting defense, the breakdown is a little more even. Only six of the eleven starters were acquired via the NFL Draft. Free agent acquisitions have shown enough on defense to become starters and contribute. Ahmad Brooks, acquired off of waivers from the Cincinnati Bengals in 2008, signed a six-year $44.5 million contract extension in 2012. The team has done everything they can to make sure Justin Smith, acquired in 2008 via free agency, retires in red and gold. Smith signed a two-year extension back in June of 2013.

Even the team's punter, Andy Lee, who is one of the best in the league, was a selection from the 2004 NFL Draft.

This may not have been the intention when the 49ers signed free agents or drafted players, but this was the result, which shows that they know what they are doing in both departments. Obviously the team wants to create competition and allow the best player to start. The draft selections, at least on offense, have faired much better than the free agents. Sure there have been players like AJ Jenkins, a top draft pick that did not pan out, but there have also been players like Bruce Miller, low round selections that have contributed.

The 49ers are also more willing to let drafted players walk when their price tag shadows their value to the team. That was the case last year with Dashon Goldson. His perceived value was much higher than his actual value to the team so they let him sign with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and drafted his replacement. That replacement was Eric Reid, who made the Pro Bowl in his rookie season. The same will likely happen with Tarell Brown, who has been a solid contributor but is considered to be one of the top corners to hit free agency this year. As a rule, the 49ers generally will not get into a bidding war with other teams.

In 2011, the team signed Carlos Rogers in free agency, but only after the top players at cornerback were signed to bigger contracts by other teams.

As free agency quickly approaches, don't expect the 49ers to be big spenders on big name players, especially on offense. They may plug in some role players here and there, but they rarely land the top tier free agents. Expect them to sit back and let the dust of the first day or two settle before they start getting a little more aggressive. The team is less likely to get into future salary cap trouble if they avoid overspending on overvalued players. That strategy has worked for the team, who has appeared in the past three NFC Championship games and a Super Bowl.

Contract negotiations with upcoming free agents can begin on Saturday, March 8. Free agency, the first day that players can sign those contracts, begins on Tuesday, March 11.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


2 Comments

  • Matt
    Every year during the off season the casual fans want the 49ers to go out and sign all the big dollar free agents without taking into account the salary cap or the current roster. If more of them would read this article we would have a lot less whining! :-) Interestingly, the only free agent on the starting roster that came to the team on a big dollar contract was Justin Smith. The rest of the free agent starters were all acquired on smaller and/or shorter term deals. I think that shows that the way to build a team is to try to get your best players through the draft, then fill in the rest of the roster with 2nd tier free agents who offer great value. Only rarely should you spend big for a high dollar free agent when the situation warrants it.
    Mar 7, 2014 at 6:31 AM
    0
    Response: I agree completely. There are always those fans that get so upset that the 49ers are not even in talks with the top tier free agents. It's because the 49ers are cap smart and no longer are willing to overspend on anyone.
  • VA49er
    I would submit that it is really 9 and 7 players drafted. Call it what you will but Brooks and Boone were guys we scouted in the draft process and that we took as rookies. We just correctly evaluated that neither needed to be drafted. BL we brought both those guys into the league. In principal if you are talking about building through Free Agency you are talking about signing what you think is a proven commodity/fit.
    Mar 7, 2014 at 1:27 AM
    0
    Response: I somewhat agree on Boone and I knew as I was writing this that someone would bring that up. I wanted to add a note that mentioned that, but instead just listed him as an undrafted free agent. Technically, he was a free agent. But I totally get your point. As for Brooks, he was drafted in the supplemental draft by the Bengals in July of 2006 and then acquired by the 49ers off waivers on August 31, 2008.

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



Kyle Shanahan on if Jimmy Garoppolo will remain the 49ers' starting QB: 'I would guess so'

By Kirk Larrabee
22 hrs

It doesn't sound like there will be any rush to make a change at quarterback for the 49ers after their rain-soaked 30-18 loss to the Indianapolis Colts Sunday night, although 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan didn't sound overly definitive about the future of the position either. Jimmy Garoppolo was given the starting nod at quarterback for the 49ers against the Colts, two weeks after he missed a start due to a calf injury. Garoppolo's performance against the Colts wasn't exactly confidence-inspiring, as he finished with 181 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions on 16-of-27 passing along with one lost fumble. But with rookie Trey Lance continuing to nurse the knee injury he sustained when he stepped in for Garoppolo in a loss to the Arizona Cardinals in Week 5,



Roster moves: 49ers waive CB Davontae Harris and RB Jacques Patrick

By David Bonilla
Oct 12

The San Francisco 49ers announced that the team has waived two players, cornerback Davontae Harris and running back Jacques Patrick. Harris was activated from the team's injured reserve list on Monday. The 49ers signed Patrick off the Cincinnati Bengals practice squad on September 21. The team announced no other moves. However, today, Tom Pelissero of NFL Network reported that the Los Angeles Chargers signed offensive lineman Senio Kelemete off the 49ers practice squad. It's possible that the 49ers try to sign at least one of the waived players to the practice squad, assuming they clear



Roster moves: 49ers announce Mychal Kendricks signing, sign two to practice squad

By Site Staff
Oct 18

The San Francisco 49ers have officially announced the following roster moves ahead of the team's Week 7 matchup against the Indianapolis Colts. LB Mychal Kendricks signed to a one-year deal OL Jon Halapio signed to the practice squad RB Jacques Patrick signed to the practice squad S Jared Mayden released from the practice squad Practice window for RB JaMycal Hasty opened Ian Rapoport of NFL Network first reported news of Kendricks' signing. Hasty was seen at this morning's practice, making it clear that the 49ers had opened his



49ers' Jimmie Ward calls Buckner trade 'bittersweet,' questions how division rival keeps pulling off big roster moves

By David Bonilla
Oct 18

Sunday night will be a reunion for many San Francisco 49ers players. All-Pro defensive tackle DeForest Buckner will return to Levi's Stadium for the first time since being traded to the Indianapolis Colts in 2020. "He was the heart and soul when he was here, man," safety Jimmie Ward said of Buckner after today's practice. "I wasn't happy about [the trade], but I understand the business side. I'm pretty sure you all knew something was going to happen, just like I did. I just didn't know what was going to happen. "When that happened, like I said, it was bittersweet. We ended up getting [Javon] Kinlaw, and we ended up getting Brandon Aiyuk. But we lost a leader, especially a leader on the defense. Really, a leader on this team, in this building. But he's


Featured

More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone