Personnel and Personalities

Apr 8, 2013 at 11:28 AM


With the voluminous information available via the internet, many fans today know almost as much about a potential 49er's measurables as do some NFL personnel departments. The scads of mock-draft info available during roster-replenishment season, not just from beat writers and national experts, but from the appended comments by fans, testify to the generally high level of expertise. Many articles that speculate on future, or recapitulate past, personnel moves, whether by draft, trade, or free-agency, come replete with a rundown of a player's height, weight, strength, speed, Wonderlic scores and other stats. And, of course, salary-cap cost.

However, while NFL personnel departments have perfected the science of measurement, they must still grapple with the very imperfect art of personality assessment. How will a certain player fit, not only on the field, but off it? How coachable will he be? How quickly might he mature? How susceptible to off-field distractions? How well will he handle potential fame and big money? How diligent will he be with his preparation, how careful with his health? How well will he adapt to big-game pressure, media scrutiny, longer work hours? How will he react to temporary setbacks? Failure? Success? Intense competition?

In other words, teams must necessarily judge a prospect not only on the merits of his measurements, but also on the contents of his character. In this regard, personnel departments have considerable advantage over the rest of us, who, in our dogged quest for home-team news morsels, must settle instead for scraps. However, team reps can talk to a player's coaches, his family members and friends, his teachers, teammates, opponents, fellow students, and, alas, agents. Still, most of this information comes second hand. So, in order to get the gut-reactions begotten by face-to-face encounters, teams schedule in-person meetings with prospective draftees.

Different teams rank the importance of the character issues -- no surprise -- differently. The late Al Davis, for instance, sometimes eschewed character issues altogether in favor of measurables. In fact, he occasionally seemed to view irascibility, particularly in a veteran player, as a positive. Bill Walsh sought out smart players. Team-builders often tend toward those characteristics in others which mirror their own traits. Mike Singletary wanted physical players, preferably with an "f."

Obviously, every team craves stupendous athletes who simultaneously function as supportive teammates, exemplary role models, and responsible citizens. In a perfect world. However, in this one, the team brass may sometimes need to make tough decisions when evaluating what a particular player may bring, not only on the field, but off it. As Harbalk continues the task of remaking the 49ers, what sort of personalities, in addition to personnel, might they project onto their future vision for the team?

Trent Baalke of late exemplifies flexibility, acquiring players by any means necessary, including free agency, draft, trades, and even signing players out of retirement. He proved quite flexible in manipulating the 2012 draft. He plans. He prepares. And he also stays ready to act should an opportunity present itself. Jim Harbaugh has also shown an openness to flexibility, especially on offense, not only in his game plans and play-calling (heck, he rebooted the 49er offense in mid-season last year), but in his use of personnel: defensive linemen play fullback; Delaney Walker played multiple positions; the 49ers line up in a multitude of formations. So, particularly with potential draftees in the later rounds, they may well look for a player who asserts "I'll play any position to help the team," with genuine sincerity.

Vince Lombardi once ranked the three most important things in life as God, family, and football. Jim Harbaugh might add "and more football." Given that he comes from a coaching clan, even a portion of his family life involves football. Harbaugh not only dreams, thinks, and imbibes football; it would surprise no one if he consumed pigskin for breakfast. Supposedly, he bonded with Colin Kaepernick over the duo's fraternal football zeal. Yes, Harbaugh would probably love a team filled with gridiron grunts (the football equivalent of gym rats) at every position. All else being equal between two prospective draft picks athletically, look for Harbaugh to press for the more football-centric choice, yes, even in the early rounds, which often yield future team leaders.

The Harbalk tandem often talks about filling a roster with internal competition at every position. Indeed, the head coach relishes using the term "compete," usually with that halfway-demented gleam in his eye, that gleam of which we fans heartily approve. We prefer to call such football fervor not "fanaticism," but "dedication." We want this guy as our head coach. Likewise, he will want highly competitive players everywhere he can get them. Again, every team covets these kinds of players, but for some organizations, the term "competition" becomes merely a clichéd mantra. Harbaugh really means it.

Of course team needs, a prospect's athletic ability, and value, can all trump character. But we've seen, with brother John Harbaugh's recent dust-up with his Super Bowl safeties, as with Jim's quick dispatch of Brandon Jacobs last year when the running back became disgruntled, that character does matter, both with coaches and players. Also, Harbalk often uses player visits as smokescreens and sometimes makes draft selections from seemingly out of the blue. Nonetheless, look for the pair, as per their own proclivities, to nudge the team toward players who, when ignited by inspired coaching, breath fire, thrive on football, and will willingly line up anywhere and everywhere.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


2 Comments

  • Mike Kenney
    Very perceptive piece. Lots of folks think coaching is x&o, but winning is more about culture than strategy. Harbaugh reportedly drove away from his personal workout with Kap without saying a thing. Kap thought he was miffed at his competitiveness. Obviously, he instead was sold. We can expect underperforming players and rookies to do better under his tutelage. Athletes worth having put a premium on winning over money. Coaches who allow for exceptions poison their own locker room. I see this perception very clearly in John and Jim. By the way, they both made it to the Super Bowl last year.
    Apr 9, 2013 at 3:14 AM
    0
    Response: Thanks for the perceptive insights. We sometimes get captured by stats, and underrate the importance of coaching.
  • Ladale
    I think this draft will emphasize speed, speed, and more speed. Guys to stretch the field for strong arm Kaepernick. No matter the position. Receiver, tight end, or running back.
    Apr 8, 2013 at 2:09 PM
    0
    Response: Kap would probably appreciate a speed speed more speed offensive draft. The defensive coaches might want some of that speed for their side of the ball, too.

Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News



49ers' third QB options for this season and beyond

By David Bonilla
Sep 19

Brock Purdy is now one injury away from starting. While the San Francisco 49ers have expressed a lot of confidence in the last overall pick in this year's draft, having the rookie lead a championship-caliber roster probably isn't ideal. Veteran Jimmy Garoppolo is the starter moving forward following the season-ending injury to Trey Lance, last year's No. 3 overall pick. Lance will undergo surgery today on the broken ankle suffered in the first quarter of Sunday's 27-7 win over the Seattle Seahawks. Purdy hasn't even been active in San Francisco's two games this season. However, he may suit up for Sunday's matchup against the Denver Broncos. Fullback Kyle Juszczyk



Who were PFF's highest- and lowest-graded 49ers players vs. Seahawks? Plus snap counts

By David Bonilla
Sep 19

The San Francisco 49ers improved to 1-1 after a 27-7 win against the Seattle Seahawks in Week 2. Today, Pro Football Focus released its grades from the game. Which Niners played well, and who has more work to do? Below are Pro Football Focus' five highest-graded 49ers players on offense against the Seahawks. Aaron Banks, LG, 77.7, 76 snaps Deebo Samuel, WR, 73.3, 59 snaps Trent Williams, LT, 73.3, 76 snaps Jeff Wilson Jr., RB, 72.5, 37 snaps Brandon Aiyuk, WR, 71.0, 67 snaps Below are the five highest-graded 49ers players on defense. Nick Bosa, DE, 89.6, 36 snaps Charles Omenihu, DE, 80.4, 28 snaps Talanoa Hufanga, SS, 79.9, 49 snaps Samson Ebukam, DE,



Silver: Some 49ers players and coaches believe team is better with Jimmy Garoppolo

By David Bonilla
Sep 19

The San Francisco 49ers avoided a catastrophe by bringing back quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo on a restructured one-year deal. Trey Lance's season ending in Week 2 is disappointing. The worst-case scenario for this season would have been not having a quarterback capable of stepping in and keeping the team competitive. Holding onto Garoppolo once seemed like an unnecessary luxury. Now, some feel the team is better suited to make a deep playoff run than they were with the second-year quarterback. Garoppolo knows the offense and what is expected of him. He's been a part of the locker room since 2017. According to one report, inside the building, some feel the team is better equipped to compete with Garoppolo at the helm of the offense. "[T]his is the part



Have Kyle Shanahan and John Lynch mismanaged the 49ers QB situation?

By Marc Adams
Sep 19

The San Francisco 49ers plan was set. Draft a young quarterback who would eventually replace Jimmy Garoppolo. The young draftee would be able to sit and learn under the veteran Garoppolo, and then take over in 2022. But things haven't exactly gone according to plan, and on Sunday, the plan imploded when Trey Lance broke his ankle—an injury that will cost him the remainder of the 2022 season. Much has been made about how well (or poorly) Kyle Shanahan and John Lynch have managed the 49ers quarterbacks. I've seen many fans and media blaming Shanahan for the current situation. Many have criticized the duo for how messy the QB situation has been since trading away two first-round round picks, and swapping another first-round pick, to draft a quarterback. Have


Featured

More by D.C. Owens

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone