FS1's Craig Carton recently floated a bold—and highly improbable—trade scenario involving the San Francisco 49ers and New York Giants. He suggested the Giants trade three first-round picks, including a swap of first-rounders this year, in exchange for quarterback Brock Purdy.
"Here's a trade nobody says no too - The @Giants trade 3 first-round picks(includes a pick swap this year) with the @49ers for Brock Purdy. The Niners then sign @AaronRodgers12 to be their starting QB for the 2025 season - ur welcome no need to pat me on the back just happy to help," Carton shared on social media platform X.
Wait … what? 👀#49ers pic.twitter.com/562A4BawcG
— 49ers Webzone (@49erswebzone) March 22, 2025
The Giants currently own the third overall pick, while the 49ers select at No. 11. While the proposal garnered attention, it quickly drew criticism from both fanbases.
From the Giants' perspective, such a deal would mean mortgaging their future for a quarterback they would need to sign to a massive extension—likely in the $50-60 million per year range.
Meanwhile, the 49ers would be giving up their 25-year-old quarterback for 41-year-old Aaron Rodgers, whose future in the NFL remains uncertain. There's also no guarantee Rodgers would sign with San Francisco, especially after the team parted ways with several key players this offseason.
Fan reactions
Giants fans overwhelmingly rejected the idea, questioning Purdy's long-term value and balking at the steep price tag.
49ers fans, on the other hand, had no interest in reviving Rodgers-to-San Francisco speculation. Many would rather stick with Purdy than entertain such a dramatic shift at the most important position on the team.
I pray for the day Rodgers retires so the "Rodgers to SF" theory can die the death it deserves.
— Mr. Controversy himself (@TommyHouse101) March 22, 2025
We had ONE shot to get him. We picked Smith instead. It happened. Move on.
I'll say no wtf? The guy is fucking old and washed get over him already damn
— gunnerrr (@gunnerrr0) March 22, 2025
I don't want Arron Rodgers in San Fran plain and simple
— Chad Long (@westcoach76) March 22, 2025
Purdy is worth 3 first but not a new contract? Make it make sense
— Cap (@clay_mcdermott) March 22, 2025
Not even being discussed. Neither team would do this.
— Casey Durbin (@thenewplanman) March 22, 2025
Rodgers is washed and Purdy is the future
— MRG (@alwaysmikeg) March 22, 2025
Absolutely NOT…… that dude needs to retire.
— Alma Springer (@Topaz5757) March 22, 2025
Why put in a guy who doesn't know the offense, while getting rid of a guy who has 3 years in it 😂😂. On top of that 2 nfc championship and a superbowl 😂😂
— money p (@sjmialokz) March 22, 2025
Why this trade makes little sense
It's also notable that the 49ers are in the middle of a roster overhaul, aiming to clear cap space and prepare for Purdy's upcoming contract extension. They also have long-term deals for tight end George Kittle and linebacker Fred Warner potentially on the horizon.
Additionally, NFL insider Ian Rapoport reported earlier this month that the 49ers are focused on getting younger this offseason. Adding a 41-year-old quarterback would directly contradict that approach.
While Carton's proposal sparked debate, the chances of this deal actually happening are extremely slim.