Originally posted by sincalfaithful:
Originally posted by Crown:
Originally posted by Jcool:
But also have this:
Coach Mike Sanford @SanfordStanford
That was a fumble. His knee or elbow never hit the turf.
very possible but...it wasnt called that way.
could have easily been delay of game on ASU as well for laying on the ball.
true it was hard to tell if he gave himself up or not
Honestly, it was b******t the way it ended.
But it would be a mistake to assume Wisconsin wins the game, we will never know if Wisconsin actually makes that FG to win.
Secondly, it really is a QB mistake. IMO he was in a panic when he set the ball down and at the time I thought it was a fumble because I didn't think he ever touched the ground. IMO the ASU players had a clear reason to think it was a fumble, whether it was one or not because the QB was really weird with his kneel down. I've never seen a QB kneel down like that. Once the ASU player was told it was not a fumble he got up. IMO its the QB's fault for creating all that confusion.
Edit: I don't know the exact rules, but IMO the reasonable way would have been a Refs timeout to review the play with the clock stopped at 10 or so seconds, after review Wisc has time to spike ball and kick FG (if it wasn't a fumble).
[ Edited by SunDevilNiner79 on Sep 16, 2013 at 9:15 AM ]