Originally posted by jrg:It'd be 50/50..don't be a homer. Both are unbelievable.
One thing I always hear w/ Molina is "watch a full season of Cardinals games and you'll understand"
Like they said..there isn't stats on the little things he does. The small advantages he gives.
lol 50/50? Give me a break. Molina is 31 years old. Its not bias, its common sense. Posey is the better player, and hes 26. Molina wasnt even an above average offensive catcher until his 8th year in the big leagues.
I lived in KC, so I know how loyal midwestern fans are with their hometown players. I get it. Nobody is saying Molina isnt a great overall catcher, but if given the choice, no GM is going to pick Molina over a 26 year old MVP.
Like i said before, Molina's best offensive season was comparable to Posey's rookie season. Posey is on pace to DOUBLE Molina's career WAR.