Originally posted by sfgiantdave:
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Question.... would you trade Lincecum for Granderson straight up? Both are on final year of contract. Granderson makes 15M per year and Timmy 20M.
I seriously doubt that Timmy will be back after this season as I just dont see the Giants offering him a big long term deal similar to the one he turned down already. So, the question is.... would the Giants be better off with Granderson in LF and use the 5M to get a 5th starter of better off with Timmy?
Just for fun obviously. I dont know if NY would ever do that anyway,
I would say yes but I don't think the Yankees would do it
I'd say no. Granderson seems like he would only do well in hitter friendly parks. I LOVE the guy, don't get me wrong. But I wouldn't give up Timmy for him. I'd rather sign Swisher and keep Timmay