Holmgren or Shanahan?

I'm curious to see who the fans would prefer out of these two.
I don't see why anyone would want Shanahan. He had two good years with Elway but sucked donkey balls after that.
He couldn't do anything with RGIII and only made the playoffs once.
Holmgren succeeded with TWO different franchises and TWO different QB's. He should have won against Pittsburgh if the game wasn't
rigged by the officials. He's a QB guru and an offensive genius.

Holmgren, hands down!

Why not both? Shanny HC Holmsy OC.

I've always liked Holmgren, but as far as coaching is concerned, Shanahan is a close second IMO.

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Why not both? Shanny HC Holmsy OC.

Might as well have Chip as the quarterback coach as well. Nobody else seems to be knocking on his door.

why another Walrus thread? he's not even on the radar.

...it might be like Godzilla vs Ghidora........with Rodan and Godzilla versus 3 headed ghidora....where ghidora is Baalke...

Options C neither

If Shanahan bring Kyle with him he would be my pick. If not I would get Holgrem.

Shanahan if it were my choice. He's not quite as old, and isn't quite as um, "portly" as Holmgren.

I worry if Holmgren's body can stand up to the coaching grind.

Both poor options but Shanahan is clearly the better option

Originally posted by Niners418:
Both poor options but Shanahan is clearly the better option

From Niners616 and this should be posted to refute any misconceptions about Shanny:

1999 - 330ypg 213pass 117rush 56/44ratio
2000 - 410ypg 265pass 145rush 54/46
2001 - 301ypg 184pass 117rush 53/47
2002 - 381ypg 239pass 142rush 57/43
2003 - 350ypg 186pass 164rush 48/52
2004 - 396ypg 250pass 146rush 50/50
2005 - 360ypg 202pass 158rush 47/53
2006 - 309ypg 175pass 134rush 50/50
2007 - 346ypg 224pass 122rush 56/44
2008 - 396ypg 279pass 117rush 62/38
2010 - 337ypg 246pass 91rush 65/35
2011 - 337ypg 236pass 101rush 61/39
2012 - 383ypg 214pass 169rush 48/52
2013 - 370ypg 234pass 136rush 59/41

This is 9 top 10 offenses of which 6 are top 5 without the benefit of a HOF type QB.

Holmgren

Feel like people are living in the past. I don't want either. Who do I want well both guys are no longer avaliable so maybe they should throw a ton of cash at Myer or Saban

I think it would be okay if these old school coaches are willing to change and try new things. I think Shannahans old school wsys caught up to him in Washington.

have the two of them duke it out in the octagon. give the job to whoever win.