Originally posted by BigBug415:Aldon is 10/10.
If other players are getting knocked for not seeing the field you can't give Aldon a 10. He's missed almost an entire season
There are 230 users in the forums
Originally posted by BigBug415:Aldon is 10/10.
Originally posted by sspiker:Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:Don't see how you could give Hyde and Marcus Martin a higher grade than Ward, who plays more snaps than both of the two combined at a much more difficult position. He's a safety playing the slot position. That is crazy good.
I also don't see how you could give Marcus Cooper a 1. He's at least a 5/10, even if we cut him. That was our bad.
Also would probably rate Davis above Iupati. He plays a tougher position and has been way more consistent.
I like the rest though.
I don't see Ward as being a playmaker yet. He's a solid tackler, but opposing QBs go right after him in the slot. Maybe my expectations are too high, but you can see the great job that Cox and even Culliver to a lesser extent are doing (and the job Brock did last year). I haven't seen the same out of Ward.
Gave Cooper a 1 because he didn't contribute to our team. Obviously Baalke knows how to find quality CBs late in the draft; that's not what this exercise was for.
I thought about swapping Davis/Iupati but Davis had a horrid first year.
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:I give Balke a C- 70%. In 2010 he coulda had A Davis and Dez Bryant instead of Iupati. In 2011 I give Balke his props A+ 98% because he did good with Aldon,kaep,Cully,kendall
Originally posted by theninermaniac:2012 class is cringe worthy. Worst draft class in NFL history.
Originally posted by Niners816:I agree for the most part with your 2010-12 grades. I still thinks it early for assigning grades to last two draft, unless they are no longer on the team. I still think tank is gonna be a huge contributor from the '13 draft, it as you said it hard to assign a good grade with no time on the field.
Originally posted by BigBug415:
Aldon is 10/10.
Originally posted by swayze:
Just a note on Cam Johnson for the 2012 draft class, we did recoup the pick when we sent him to Indianapolis--I think that could warrant more than a 1/10
Originally posted by sspiker:
Notable UDFAs:
2010:
Tramaine Brock: 10/10
Michael Wilhoite: 10/10
2011:
Ian Williams: 10/10
2012:
Tony Jerrod-Eddie: 10/10