There are 74 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

who gets traded Kendal Hunter or LMJ

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Kendall Hunter right now is the second best RB on our roster until otherwise noted. He does it all. He isn't the workhorse every down but he is still a fine all around back that gets too few touches as is. I agree on LMJ as well that he is the only proven punt returner right now and we don't want KW the second now do we?

Please refer to this "player" as he who shall not be named, in future posts. Even his initials may cause spontaneous irrational violent behavior by sound minded 49er fans.
I don't see much value in trading LMJ. I think most teams would wait on him being cut. Hunter has greater value and would net more in a trade but I don't see one coming.
Originally posted by lamontb:
I don't see much value in trading LMJ. I think most teams would wait on him being cut. Hunter has greater value and would net more in a trade but I don't see one coming.

I would agree except for the fact the Cowboys traded a 6th for Rolanod Mcclain. You know, the retired former Raider LB. So, there are idiot franchises that may part ways with something for James. Not saying a lot, but at least a 6th, maybe a 4th if its the Cowboys
  • Chico
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,184
With lattimore and Hyde coming aboard there's not enough balls to spread around. Both KH and LMJ will get very few carries and have little trade value. I can see them both being cut and getting picked up by the Raiders/Cowboys.
Originally posted by CWin4949:
Originally posted by phatbutskinny:
Neither ya bishes. LMJ is the only NFL experienced ST returner.

By his performance that ain't sayin much...

true but a mediocre returner with experience is less risk than someone who has never done it in an NFL game. We shall see in training camp anyway if someone can step up and take over
Neither player has any trade value that makes sense. Hunter will probably play out his contract then who knows what, and LMJ will probably either play out his contract and leave in FA or he'll get cut at some point. Been watching game rewind the last few days and LMJ's ball security was even worse than I remembered (and I've been highly critical of him for it). He had at about half a dozen fumbles that didn't make it to the stat sheet as technically fumbles (muffs, fumbles right after his knee hit the ground, etc). The guy fumbled or muffed the ball on almost 20% of his touches last season. He just has no place on an NFL roster unless he can fix his fumbling problem, and I've never seen any player have as much of an issue as he does.
Originally posted by NeeJ49er:
Neither ....both will be Niners this season ...like it or not, LMJ will return kicks and get a few snaps here and there, hopefully Jim draws up a few plays for him to take advantage of his skill sets ...same for Hunter, McDonald and Stevie ...we need to spread the ball around and incorporate all of our weapons into the scheme of things , with this many weapons on offense, measures need to be taken so none of our playmakers rot on the bench

I wish they both could be niners too but I just think were so loaded at that position that it would behoove us to get more depth at say cb?? I just don't see our leapords changing their spots anytime soon.. Meaning I don't think roman will overnight create plays designed for them and Kap won't magically start floating bubble screens to lmj. They already Have enough new weapons.who knows tho because currently Kendal IS the number 2 back( and a good one at that), and LMJ is our returner so I guess I can't see either being traded until a better player is in place. With that said I could see us holding a team with a injured starter for randsome mid season once we have a better returner or number 2 back with enough reps to be confident.
[ Edited by matthewabbit on Jul 3, 2014 at 11:15 AM ]
Wuh?
who is gonna trade for a back-up RB these days? they are a dime a dozen. Hunter and LMJ have far more value to the Niners than any other team.
Originally posted by boast:
who is gonna trade for a back-up RB these days? they are a dime a dozen. Hunter and LMJ have far more value to the Niners than any other team.

Agree. We're in win-now mode and shouldn't think about trading any players that can help us this year. If they leave next year, so be it. I want that 6th ring.
Def not Kendall Hunter.
If LMJ is our best option as a punt returner this coaching staff is getting overpaid. I would rather rush 11 everytime and just take chances on where the ball ends up. LMJ scares me everytime hes looks up for the ball. Sorry. Probably off topic
LaKendall Jamester!
Kendall Hunter is the only proven running back behind Gore, so why is he even being mentioned? The only scenario I see that happening, is if Hyde and or Lattimore both come out of the gates turning heads, then maybe we can put KH on the trade block like AD was last season. LMJ is the only one that is on the chopping block IMO, but someone mentioned Hyde and Lattimore can both be disappointments just as likely as becoming stars... It is unknown..
Originally posted by NeeJ49er:
Originally posted by CWin4949:
Originally posted by phatbutskinny:
Neither ya bishes. LMJ is the only NFL experienced ST returner.

By his performance that ain't sayin much...
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
how about VD


nah ...soon as his contract squabbles are in the rear view mirror, Vernon will go back to being one of the team leaders and a consistent redzone weapon for our attack

LOL - He is soft and is all about his money.. He can go to the Browns or Redskins or something