Originally posted by kronik:
Are you comparing a 15 year vet to someone who has only played 1.5 years of games?
I'll guarantee one thing. Kaep will have much more production than Manning in the next 10 years. Manning will retired within next 2-3 years.
No, clearly i am comparing playoff statistics of two quarterbacks. Before you came along the argument was Payton's ability to get it done without a coach, and Kap's ability with a coach. I do agree Kap is good because of Harbaugh, but i also believe that Payton is good because of his team, not just himself.
This may just be me but Payton is an excellent seasonal QB, come playoffs he is average.
In my opinion, getting it done means a superbowl win. Payton has gone to the playoffs 12-13 times and has won the superbowl 1 time. I'm pointing out that given the chances Payton had, I'm confident Kap would have won more than 1 with Harbaugh.
[ Edited by Quest4six on Mar 12, 2014 at 5:49 PM ]