Originally posted by gold49digger:
This is all Romans fault. His faulty play calling is making us doubt Harbaugh.
Seattle fans are probably laughing at us right now..
Who chose to keep Roman around?
There are 235 users in the forums
Originally posted by gold49digger:
This is all Romans fault. His faulty play calling is making us doubt Harbaugh.
Seattle fans are probably laughing at us right now..
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Truth? You mean your opinion.
The TRUTH is that we'll never know. But the best inidcator of the future is to look at the past and JH has won everywhere he went.
Did he win a SuperBowl as a player?
Did he win a National Championship as a NCAA coach?
Did he win a SuperBowl as a HC?
Coming in 2nd place year after year counts for sweet jack all.
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by monsterzero789:
He has turned every program around at every stop he has been at
And loses every big game he has been in when it counts.
Is is also debatable who should be credited for our success. Like I said, would Harbaugh be able to take Cleveland this year and turn them around so quickly?
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:
The thing for me is, I think JH helps this 49ers team More Psychologically then he does x's and o's. Having said that, basically the same 49er team went 8-8 and 6-10 under Dinglebary and yet Harbaugh was a Good Enough coach to win 36 games in 3 years with a SB appearance also. Is there even a reason this should be debated?? I'd give Harbaugh a 3 year $25million extension and let him have a say in FAs and drafts too. Not all the say but some say.
Originally posted by captveg:Baalke. Jim has some great strengths, but he also has some weakness re: applying the talent on the roster depth. I can see someone like Gruden exploiting the tools on offense in a more traditional West Coast style more successfully, that's for sure.
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
The same question was asked in 2011 when he signed with us. And we went 13-3.
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
The same question was asked in 2011 when he signed with us. And we went 13-3.
Because Baalke built the damn team.
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
So anyone could of led that 2011 squad to the NFCC?
I don't think so. It takes a great coach like JH to take a crappy organization and turn them around in one season. Baalke could draft great players until the cows come home but they are useless without a good coach.
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
So anyone could of led that 2011 squad to the NFCC?
I don't think so. It takes a great coach like JH to take a crappy organization and turn them around in one season. Baalke could draft great players until the cows come home but they are useless without a good coach.
What about signings? Those don't count? Whitner. Goodwin. Akers. Rogers.
And by your logic explain to me how Barry Switzer won the SB in his 2nd year in Dallas? Was it due to his great coaching or the All-Star team he inherited?
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
lol Switzer inherited a SUPER BOWL TEAM.
Harbaugh inherited a hot mess... You can't see the difference between the 1994 cowboys and the 2010 49ers?
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
lol Switzer inherited a SUPER BOWL TEAM.
Harbaugh inherited a hot mess... You can't see the difference between the 1994 cowboys and the 2010 49ers?
Baalke didn't inherit that same mess?
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Harbaugh inherited a hot mess... You can't see the difference between the 1994 cowboys and the 2010 49ers?
Originally posted by WINiner:
Has to be Baalke, because even if he has Baalke removed from the situation Harbaugh's still likely a short term coach. Baalke is a good GM and far more likely to be the long term Niner. The personalities and reality make this decision for us.
In a perfect world give me Harbaugh 11 times out of 10. In the real world though, I think the team would benefit more in the long run from keeping Baalke and putting your trust in Tomsula. That could be a combo for the next decade, where I just can't see Harbaugh a long term Niner. His personality is just too abrasive.