Originally posted by SteveYoung:You dont think Gruden could win a SB with this team in two years? I do.
The gap between Gruden and Switzer is huge. Gruden would be a great signing.
There are 217 users in the forums
Originally posted by SteveYoung:You dont think Gruden could win a SB with this team in two years? I do.
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
You think any good coach in 2011 could come in, with no off season, with Alex at QB, and take a perennial loser team to overtime in the NFCC? I think it takes a great coach to do something like that.
Jim was probably the only guy that could do that and that is why he was AP 2011 COTY
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by pwillis52beasty:
LOL is this guy serious? Harbaugh wouldn't have had any more success than Singeltary? Dude the 2010 and 2011 team weren't much different. We got 6-10 under Singeltary and 13-3 the following year under Harbaugh. You have some blind hate against Harbaugh for whatever reason..
We would have won the division with Jim because the only thing we needed fixed was the QB. Baalke had the talent here in 2010 and Scott in 2009. Our problem was the QB position. Jim would have won the division both years because he could fix the position we needed fixed!
Originally posted by pwillis52beasty:
That is true, but we also improved in pretty much every other area as well.
Originally posted by NinerGM:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:
Lets look at the tape
Baalke--- takes over talented roster, but was also scout before GM (lead scout maybe?) Has added significant talent. Has worked with Paraag to master the cap. Hasn't overpaid anyone. His major whiffs have been on offensive players, and it has been said that Harbaugh has a lot of input as far as drafting offensive players. Has put together an elite defensive coaching staff. finds gems in UDFA--- such as Brock and Ian williams
which brings us too
Harbaugh (and the offensive staff he brought with him from stanford)---- Has his own offensive system, which worked for awhile but now is not so lethal, given that we have an all-pro line, all-pro TE, all-pro FB, and pretty good WRs... and our QB can run like hell... he is a fine leader of men but his in-game management is laughable--- the play calling is not fluid, the time outs are embarressing and our challenge percentages were some of the worst in the league... we run when the league is begging us to pass... our route concepts have been described as 'remedial'...
Our roster is loaded, and our defense in 2011 was historic. I contend that any good coach would have been successful in this situation, we just needed to stop hiring people like Singletary, and that all changed when we hired Baalke. Baalke has constructed the team. The defense has played at a championship level. And when its all on the line the past two years, we can't score when we have to, and in the playoffs, you gotta score. This is an offensive problem. First and goal from the 5 and no ring? Doesn't sound like a Baalke problem to me
I don't dislike Harbaugh, but you people who would rather keep the coach are CRAZY!!!!
You think any good coach in 2011 could come in, with no off season, with Alex at QB, and take a perennial loser team to overtime in the NFCC? I think it takes a great coach to do something like that.
Like Andy Reid? Look what Reid did and give him THIS team with THIS defense and even more talent (deep) on offense?
Come on folks, it's muuuuuch harder to put a great organization together (because you need more than one person) than to hire a coach smart enough to recruit the right coaches with the right amount of creativity to generate a less predictable offense and most important, how to scheme around (to a certain extent) injury.
Originally posted by pd24:
What has Baalke done to warrant a firing? Say we do make the decision to let Baalke go, how would be viewed around the NFL for letting one of the best GM's go just because?
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Originally posted by pd24:
What has Baalke done to warrant a firing? Say we do make the decision to let Baalke go, how would be viewed around the NFL for letting one of the best GM's go just because?
He hasn't done anything wrong. Neither has JH.
This is a hypothetical debate, if you had to chose, which one would it be.
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
I don't think Reid was in overtime in the AFCC. Cheifs were a wild card team IIRC and got bounced in the divisional round. And there was no lockout this year either. So its not the same comparison. Plus Reid has been a coach in the NFL for years. He is at his peak while JH is growing.
That being said, Reid is not just "any good coach." I think Reid is a great coach and will end up in the HOF. Its a good thing that Harbaugh can be compared to Reid really.