Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Also, clearly you didn't see his break down of that picture. Kaep didn't stare Crabs down at all. Please pay attention to the breakdowns before you criticize Kaep.
Who's criticizing CK? I think it's more of a coaching issue personally...but I admit I can't tease it out (could be both but most likely a coaching issue b/c the scheme is flaring outlets for him).
BTW: How did we do on that low % play at the end of the game?
Uh, you? lol.
Dude, go READ the breakdown OF that play you completely muffed on
I saw the play...the gif, the breakdown, and have it DVR'd and I drew my own analysis.
Now, tell me what your analysis is and what exactly is your point. You think this was a great decision by CK to go to Crabtree and was well executed (including the look-off)? If that is your stance, that's hard to argue b/c it worked but you're not going to convince me that was the higher % play or that only one option would have been successful on that play. And of course, you're completely missing the overall point here...and that is tunnel vision/coaching to ONLY see the sideline and intermediate-deeper passing routes that mass, MASS majority of the time instead of taking what the defense gives you esp. when you have very viable check down options...be more balanced. You get that right?
Again, I'm NOT saying the outlet routes wouldn't have worked, on that specific play. Kap has disregarded check downs before and has missed them. And wasn't that play 3rd down? So that backs up why I believe that decision to throw to Crabs 1 on 1 was FINE. A check down you get tackled short and punt. Where have I tried to convince you it is a higher % play than the outlet routes? I said it was more of an,"in the middle" type of %. The closer you throw the ball to the LOS, the higher the %. You also understand the situation, what down we're in, and where the marker is, is important too right? Fact is, Crabtree's route was not impossible to complete.
As for the last play of the game, why such deep routes? That definitely is on Roman as well. Kaep has tremendous confidence in Crabs. To me, (probably not to you), it was a GOOD decision, but not the SAFEST know what I mean? 1 on 1 with Crabs, yeah, he's gonna take that anytime he can get it. The throw and the call sucked worse.
[ Edited by defenderDX on Jan 29, 2014 at 3:22 PM ]