Originally posted by IMnotsoHO:
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Originally posted by IMnotsoHO:
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Sigh.
I thinks its funny how when I point something out and all of the sudden I'm saying that Reid sucks. Reid misses some tackles he should make. Its a fact. He also hits like a truck and makes a number of really good tackles. Two things can be equally true.
If it was just 1 or 2 tackles vs Houston then i would never have said anything, but I've seen it all year. I'm not saying he is not or can't be a very good tackler. I'm saying he's missing some tackles he should make. This is simply a small criticism of a player whom I think can be better than the All-Pro player he's replacing.
I dunno how I can make that any more clear. I'm done responding to this issue BTW. I see what I see. You don't see it? Good for you.
Hi Marv49,
Please don't take my post so personal. First of all, I never mentioned you in my post. Secondly, I never even implied that anyone in this thread thinks "Reid sucks." What I did point out is that I think some in this thread are overly critical and inconsistent when evaluating Reids missed tackles. I think I did a reasonable job stating my position and giving in game examples.
You do a good job every week with the recap, but your not the only one with a DVR and an opinion. This is the internet, get use to people disagreeing with you.
I got no prob with people disagreeing with me. I spent 3 months this summer on a Seattle Seahawk board.
You are free to have your opinion and I'm free to disagree with it. Works both ways.
Lets be honest, posting in a rivals board where you expect to be challenged if not insulted, is a lot different than having to defend your position in what is essentially your personal blog. People read your thread because its perceived as creditable. If your observations are not seen as mostly accurate, so goes the credibility. I recognize the sensitive nature of the situation, even if you don't. Again, no need to be snippy.
LOL.
Who's being snippy?
I disagree with you. Its as simple as that. If I'm not credible because I see Reid missing tackles, then so be it. I see what I see and these are my thoughts after rewatching the game. Me not agreeing with your analysis doesn't mean I have an issue when people disagree. It means I had that opinion for a reason and I'm sticking by what I saw initially to post in the first place.
"Sensitive Nature"? I don't even know what you are talking about. I post what I see and I admit when I'm wrong (which is alot). Just ask people about my defense of Alex Smith and having written off Frank Gore several years in a row now. The thing is tho that when I truly believe something, I'm gonna defend it.
Reid looks like he's going to be a very good player. I already like him FAR more than I ever liked Goldson (whom I was never a big fan of). Reid is getting better and better in every game and is getting more and more aggressive as his confidense builds. All of that can be true as well as my concern that he too often misses tackles. I've seen him do it in almost every game so far this season. He'll over extend and reach and the player will pull away and break the arm tackle. That doesn't mean that this can't be corrected or that it will hinder him in the future. It's what I see NOW. You don't see it? Great. That's your opinion. It is what it is.
Too often when I make a comment on this site people see the negative in my comment and completely ignore the positive in the same paragraph. Reid has a chance to be a good one....but he DOES need to improve his tackling. That's my opinion and I stand by it.
[ Edited by Marvin49 on Oct 8, 2013 at 4:37 PM ]