Originally posted by Mr.Mcgibblets:
There's nothing wrong with our receivers. We may not have a spectacular bunch of guys after Boldin, but they are decent. QB just has to find the open man and give him a chance by throwing a halfway decent pass. Oh, how things have suddenly changed around here.
I find this a really strange and supercilious post. I know the comments to which you are referring though the reason for doing so seems obliquely perverse. Allow me to puncture some of the cloud for you and maybe stop yet another QB argument which seems to forment in a number of posts at the moment:
1) This WR group is compeltely different to that in the first half of last season where we had Crabtree, Manningham, Moss and williams. The first three were routinely open. We have a different core this time where we are relying on Boldin, Moore, Williams and Patton.
Boldin does not have Moss' ability to get open and is currently recognised as our main receiving threat, hence he is double covered and rarely open. The Defenses are not worried about any other receiver. Moore was a ST player at Miaimi and rarely saw the field in a receiving capacity. Williams is not an NFL calibre WR. Patton is a rookie still learning the game.
2) Why on earth would you want to drag past history up? There seems to be a huge element of schadenfreude amongst some posters in this thread who are taking a perverse joy in the teams struggles. I support whoever is on the field for us but I will point out where I think we can improve. What does that say about your psyche that you would rather drag up the past and "punish" people who you disagreed with in some thinly veiled attempt at "I told you so" rather than getting behind the team? I think you should maybe have a period of reflection on what you really want or hope to gain from these comments and what possible benefit it is to anyone going forward, including yourself.
Now that aside, I think TheFunkychicken is actually right in his approach and here is why:
Moore has been invisible to me, and he barely played in the pre-season games. He was described as a lock by the coaching staff having been primarily a previous ST player only at Miami. Williams just does not have an ability to get open and he should have caught at least one pass from Kap last night for a 3rd down - it was a hard pass but it hit him in the hands.
Now Baldwin at least is a mismatch problem with his size and so he should be activated. Him and Patton should be on the filed as often as possible now behind Boldin. If we are going to struggle on offense with veterans like Moore and Williams making no contribution then we'd be better struggling with Patton and Baldwin and letting them gain experience and develop.
Collie has a proven histroy of production. Hawkins made plays and it was noticeable. I would rather have Collie to help out our receivers and Kap though would prefer both. We kept the wrong people at the cut.