Originally posted by Rascal:Originally posted by jreff22:Originally posted by trizzil:Originally posted by jreff22:Against backups.
Throwing BJ up against real starters would be bad. Colt at least has real game time experience against D's like Pitt and Balt.
Seattle threw Wilson up against great D's his rookie season. look what he did..
That is a rare occurance. We will not get wins from BJ if we forced him on the field right now. He was a late rounder for a reason and will need to be polished.
So, McCoy will get us wins ? I doubt that very much. The truth is if you can play you can play. I never buy into this rookie argument. Loads of rookies QBs play in their first year. In fact, if you look at the Skins, Mike Shanahan would rather play Kurt Cousins over a veteran in Grossman after RG3 went down. Hey, Rex Grossman had played in a Super Bowl before you know ? LOL. So, there you go.
Yes Colt would get more wins compared to BJ. He won games in Cleveland and won't be rattled by s**t that would get to a rookie. And the truth is even if you can play you still have a lot to learn. We aren't talking about a highly drafted rookie getting serious reps, he's a 7th rounder getting the scraps. I trust a guy who played against 2 of the best D's twice a year instead of a rookie who was out the majority of his last college season and hasn't taken a real NFL snap.