Sort of interesting who they have on their lists--over rated list has only one player rated among the elites--Montana.
R.W. McQuarters -- http://www.nfl.com/player/r.w.mcquarters/2502053/profile
Two years with the 9ers...no stats but one Int?
Dexter Carter -- 1,000 yards over seven seasons? Who rated this guy on any list?
Kevan Barlow -- Five years...hardly a career to measure among the greats.
William Floyd -- Clicked on their link and found stats for Paul Kruger...hmm...I rate this site as an F+.
Joe Montana -- If not the best QB of all time, he is in the conversation unless you just hate the guy for non-football reasons.
Putting Montana with this group is an insult in and of itself. They were good players but nowhere near elite. Not even 9er diehards would rate them that highly.
On the other hand, the players they list as underrated is largely a list of players who suffer by comparison or injury:
John Taylor -- JRice cast a shadow over him...but knowledgeable fans know his worth.
Garrison Hearst -- Injury kept him from being one of the greats. 12 year career, 2 years out, 4 years of 1,000+ yards.
Frank Gore -- Who is underrating this guy?
Bryant Young -- Played a less glorified role, but underrated by who?
Tom Rathman -- Perhaps underrated when compared to Roger? But he was known to be a solid all-around player.
Just a dumb set of lists by any measure.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Jul 13, 2013 at 9:19 AM ]