Steve's rep was that of a prolific passer with great running skills.He is remembered for total domination in games. If he was some how remembered for great clutch performances, and had a rep for winning big in play off games, Id say he was over rated, but to say he is over rated because he failed in a few play off games is silly.
You could say Joe Montana was over rated, as Line backer, see line backing was not really what Joe was known for, by the way Steve Young, way over rated in his rep as great pole vaulter, and stir fry cook!
If you look at a guys weakest point, and discount his finest attributes, then you can say he's over rated, what a couple of ignorant ass hats these two "analyst's" are!
[ Edited by GolittaCamper on Jul 9, 2013 at 10:02 AM ]