Originally posted by fryet:Here is my personal comparison between Reid and Goldson:
Covering Receivers: Equal - Goldson was also good in this area imo
Run Support - Goldson
Tackling - Goldson
No Penalties: Reid
It is hard to quantify improved communication, but it does seem like the 49ers pass defense is better, even with limited pass rush. If this keeps up, the 49ers may start to play 8 in the box, trusting their secondary to hold up on the back-end. Goldson is also more of an enforcer than Reid, but with the new rules, that seems to be more of a liability than an asset.
I would give coverage and tackling to Reid.
Goldson goes for the big hit, we've seen him whiff many times. His coverage was never that great, decent.
Reid wraps up very well. His coverage has been pretty decent as well. So far no big wtf? Coverage breakdowns.
Of course, this is only several games into the season.
Reid is very impressive. Wouldn't guess he is a rookie,