I think the best controversy ever was Alex Smith vs. Tim Rattay/Shaun Hill/JT O' Sullivan/Nate Davis/Troy Smith/Colin Kaepernick.
Alex Smith is the greatest transitional Quarterback in history and he needs to be in the hall of fame for most QB Controversy victories.
Hes 5-1 all time in QB Controversies, and if he goes to New York and beats Sanchez, he will be the greatest QB slayer of QB Controversies in NFL history hands down. Someone get this man a trophy.
[ Edited by Kronos2560 on Jan 15, 2013 at 8:22 PM ]