Originally posted by Shorteous:
My question is whether or not this offense was used with Alex? Did the coaching staff change the offense to best suite Kap and if so I think we can assume that it will grow with Kap's maturity. Can we fault the OC for adapting to the best fit with kap while we always complain about coaches not changing to fit the personal?
It was. The main difference is Alex routinely threw quick slants on the AR routes and found secondary targets in 2011 but that is how Harbaugh got what he got out of Smith. Smith's strengths we're always on short to intermediate routes down the middle of the field or in the flat out wide. He told Smith to go the primary target, roll and look for 1 more target and if they aren't there to take a sack, get back to LOS, or throw it away. Efficiency was and still is the name of the game, we traded Smith's veteran look on the game for Kaep's rocket arm and scrambling ability.
Best game to demonstrate Alex's use in our offense was the second half rally against Philly in 2011. First TD to Morgan was on a slant, he was the called target the entire play, the LB had to honor the TE for a split second and even then was still close to make a play if not for the quick release, Morgan made guys miss and scored. Second TD to Vernon it is hard to tell if VD was the primary cause Smith actually looks left but you can see the middle DB move that way and Smith immediately goes back to Vernon who was right the middle of 3 eagles and turned and scored.
http://www.49ers.com/video/videos/Highlights-49ers-Beat--Eagles-24-23/a5271187-3699-442a-a505-c4cc590b9acf
Smith was far more mature in his QB play than Kaep is right now. He had a bit more leeway than Colin and he was mature and comfortable enough to freelance if he had too. Harbaugh was very happy to dink and dunk his way down the field using traditional plays like the slants with Smith, with Colin we see a lot more crossing routes and out routes.
With Kaep, he isn't as comfortable in the pocket as Smith yet, consequently not as happy to take a sack. If that primary read isn't open yet Colin almost aways just looks to run, if he trusts the receiver and the play he'll throw it up anyway (see the crazy throws to Boldin that work OR the plays like that throw to VD that intercepted).
While I agree with the other posters that say our offense falls apart if we are missing 1 piece it isn't even that because as plays like that interception against GB demonstrate....Our offense actually hinges on full out effort by the decoys. If decoys don't go 110% on their routes than the play is doomed to fail even if it is called correctly.
[ Edited by sfout on Jan 11, 2014 at 9:34 AM ]