Originally posted by dtcomposer:blah blah blah same tired arguments. Smith was not an average QB last season. Last season he was a good QB. People keep acting like he was some middle of the road player, when in reality he was one of the top 10-12 QB's in the league last season. He did that with BY FAR the worst supporting cast offensively, and with the most conservative playcalling.
I am not saying that he is going to be great, but to act like you know what kind of a QB he is going to be is just idiotic. Nobody knows, and it could go either way. So stop making ridiculous statements about how good he is going to be. You don't know.
Amen there are some pretty ridiculous statements being tossed out here. No one knows what his ceiling is for better or worse. By the way, if you have to say you are not bashing Smith, then you probably are...