Alex Smith 2005-2008 : poor - average QB
Alex Smith 2009- beyond : average to above average 2nd tier cusp QB
bottom line, I think Colin or Tolzien would do fine with Harbaugh and the weapons, but rewarding Alex with the keys again and added weapons, Smith gets the benefit of the doubt that he can ONLY IMPROVE in the 2nd year of the offense that he hasnt had.
not to mention his production has gotten better every year the last few years, and thats what you want from that position. just dont ask skip bayless's opinion
[ Edited by 49ersnum1 on Mar 19, 2012 at 1:20 PM ]