Being able to develop QBs is a fine quality no doubt but it shouldn't be only criteria or even the main criteria for who we should hire as a head coach. I mean we're looking for a head coach not a QB coach or an OC. There is a lot more to job than developing a QB.
And it's not to say guys like Mornhinweg might not be capable candidates but we should be seriously be looking at them based on if they can command the respect of the players, their ability to build a staff and bring in quality people on both sides of the ball, and their overall knowledge of football not just their ability to develop a QB.
I still favor Harbaugh as my number one guy because I think he can do everything that I mentioned above but I don't think Billick/Lewis combo is a terrible fallback option.
I think if those three things came to be we'd be looking pretty damn good.
Brian Billick is a good HC with a ring to show for it. He has a positive win to loss ratio and his team made the playoffs 4 times including a super bowl win. Along with that 6 of his coordinators became head coaches and 4 of them are still head coaches. That shows that he is able to put a very good staff together and talented coaches are eager to work on his staff.
Marvin Lewis was the DC in charge of that great Ravens defense that won the SB. His defenses with the Bengals we're quite good also leading the league in turnovers in atleast one season that I remember.
Carson Palmer is still a franchise QB. Having Chad and TO as your primary receivers isn't as good as it looks on paper and it's not a big surprise that Palmer had his best game of the season last week when both of them were out of the game (against a very good defense that had a lot to lose).
Bringing in Palmer also allows you to focus on other areas in the draft. Luck is almost certain to be gone by the time we draft (Even if it's #2) and after him things aren't as exciting. You can wait and find a guy to develop a little later in the draft and instead pull in a defensive stud like Peterson or whoever.
With all that said Hasrbaugh is still my top choice and I believe he's the 49ers top choice regardless of whot he GM is. The question is are we going to be his top choice. If he has NFL ambitions you would beleive that the 49ers would be a tough option to pass. The team is local to where he already is so he wouldn't even have to relocate. The team is loaded with talent and has a high draft pick to fill the one glaring hole, QB.
We'll have to see how it all plays out over the next week or so.
Originally posted by thedude: How long to you think Lewis would stick around as a DC before getting another HC gig? Seems like it might be a great interim fix, but our inability to hold onto coordinators has burned us before.
maybe thats why we stopped trying to get legit co-ordinators, cus we know thy'll leave after the year haha
This site is dedicated to the 49ers and their fans. It is in no way affiliated with the NFL or any of its teams. All teams and players mentioned on this site are registered trademarks of the NFL. The use of any team names, words, trademarks, logos or photos have been used for descriptive purposes only. The content and information from other sites is the property of their respective owners. Player and team photos used with permission from USA TODAY Sports Images.