There are 96 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Who would you say is worth keeping (on staff) besides Rathman?

Originally posted by Norcal9erfan:
Originally posted by PTulini:
Our TE coach

I'm pretty sure he is now our QB coach since the OC move. He's the guy that was sitting next to Troy Smith on the bench when Singletary was in his face this Sunday. I've heard nothing bad about him, only good things. He gameplans the redzone offense and I believe we did really well in that area.

I'm referring to TE Coach Pete Hoener.
for consecutive years in seattle and now this year in SF, solari's O-Lines have been some of the worst in the league-he goes

mike johnson/jason michael- we havent had a qb perform well for years - they go

jerry sullivan - who was our last 1000 yd WR? - he goes

screw it- we need a whole new offensive staff

defensively...i'm not entirely sold on the notion that we need a complete overhaul here

take into account that our offense never was able to consistently sustain drives and maintain control of the ball and the amount of time that our defense was on the field for extended lengths due to the inept offense

as it stands we are 14th in the NFL in total defense (331yds/gm) 24th(pass) 7th(rush)

if our offense played with any consistency over the course of the season we very well could have a top10 maybe top5 D

special teams - wasnt nearly as bad as it was last year, but wasnt what i felt it should've been - schettenheimer goes
Originally posted by TheGoldDiggerrrr:
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
Tomsula's unit has done a good job. our LBs have been good. cant think of any other units that have excelled tho. clean house!

I think the line improve as the season went along. Which is amazing considering we started 2 rookies. One will be a hall of fame. The other is 20 years old and doesn't bend with his knees enough!!! Alex getting striped of the ball in the final min of that game!!!

raw talent is good but he hasnt done anything with chilo,. he still stinks. other than baas, iupati and staley i dont trust the others, the rookie will be a great RT once he gets his footwork right. chilo is a lost cause and they dont see that.
Originally posted by 49erfeeeever808:
Tomsula
Rathman
Hoener


bout it.

Maybe Manusky...
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 5,321
NO ONE SHOULD BE SPARED IN THE PURGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This question is almost impossible to answer by fans... it's hard to evaluate position coaches unless you see them coaching on a daily basis. For example, Rathman has Frank Gore and Westbrook. Their talent may make him look great, but who knows how good of a coach he really is... none of us really do.
Originally posted by sacniner:
This question is almost impossible to answer by fans... it's hard to evaluate position coaches unless you see them coaching on a daily basis. For example, Rathman has Frank Gore and Westbrook. Their talent may make him look great, but who knows how good of a coach he really is... none of us really do.

I say Rathman stays if we go back to a West Coast Offense.
  • SaksV
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 893
FIRE

Joel Patten (Director of College Scouting)
Mike Johnson (Offensive Coordinator)
Jason Michael (Quarterbacks)
Jerry Sullivan (Wide Receivers)
Wendell Davis (Wide Receivers)
Mike Solari (Offensive Line)
Greg Manusky (Defensive Coordinator)
Al Harris (Pass Rush)
Jason Tarver (Outside Linebackers)
Vance Joseph (Secondary)

RETAIN

Tom Rathman (Running Backs)
Ray Brown (Offensive Line Assistant)
Vantz Singletary (Inside Linebackers)
Kurt Schottenheimer (Special Teams)
Dave Kipp (Special Teams Assistant)
Duane Carlisle (Strength & Conditioning)
Mark Uyeyama (Strength & Conditioning)

[ Edited by SaksV on Dec 27, 2010 at 14:48:54 ]
Originally posted by Nes49:
NO ONE SHOULD BE SPARED IN THE PURGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



i feel your disgust with this team, but we're not as awful as our record/past performances indicates
Originally posted by Nes49:
NO ONE SHOULD BE SPARED IN THE PURGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This.
Rathman would be the only retained assistant in my mind.

Manusky has had a down year, Solari hasn't shown he isn't expendable, and no one else stands out to me as "must keep"


If there's anyway we can snag Kubiak for OC, I'd probably die from elation
Originally posted by longtime49erfan:
Originally posted by 49erfeeeever808:
Tomsula
Rathman
Hoener


bout it.

Maybe Manusky...

Gag....
  • GEEK
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 17,139
Tom Rathman, Mike Solari/Ray Brown, Jerry Sullivan (sr. off. asst role only, not WR), Jim Tomsula, Jason Tarver.

The rest can go.
Originally posted by susweel:
I will let the new HC worry about this because I know nothing about the abilities of assistant coaches.

This
Originally posted by Nes49:
NO ONE SHOULD BE SPARED IN THE PURGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

everybody is a target