There are 117 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Making Troy Smith Video....

Hey guys....just looking for some feedback.

In the past, I've made these three vids...

49ers Draft 2010

Crabtree 2009

Nate Davis preseason 2009

I am currently working on Crabtree 2010 and just decided to start a Troy Smith 2010. I dunno if he's going to continue to play well or flame out, but I figured I'd start the process as I capture and edit all my own video and that takes some time. I edit week to week during the season. That way I have it finished very soon after the season is over.

Anyway, my question is this....If I make a Troy Smith Highlight Vid, do I include all the great plays he made that were called back on penalty? I'm leaning toward yes because of the Crabtree and second Davis TDs were outstanding.

PS...If you watch the above vids and don't like the music, keep it to yourself. Impossible to make everyone happy.
I think you should wait a couple more games.

It would be cool to see a highlight video with some Wu Tang though.
[ Edited by binary2nd on Nov 15, 2010 at 11:48 AM ]
  • boast
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 74,597
wait for more games and don't include the penalty plays.
You should post the ones that were taken away, he still made the throws.
I loved your Crabtree video. One of my favs.

But yeah, I think it's cool to include the TD to VD simply because that WASN'T a hold and the catch VD made needs to be recognized. s**t was insane.
Originally posted by binary2nd:
I think you should wait a couple more games.

It would be cool to see a highlight video with some Wu Tang though.

LOL...I'm more of a rock guy. Sorry. To each his own.

I won't publish the vid till the season over and only if he continues to play well, but it takes alot of time to do this if I do all the games at once. Its much easier if I do it week to week, a few plays at a time.
Originally posted by Leathaface:
I loved your Crabtree video. One of my favs.

But yeah, I think it's cool to include the TD to VD simply because that WASN'T a hold and the catch VD made needs to be recognized. s**t was insane.

Ya, and the scramble by Troy to find Crabtree on the Crabtrees called back TD was impressive as well.

I was never going to include the first TD to VD because the fault was Troys that the clock expired.
Originally posted by boast:
wait for more games and don't include the penalty plays.

lol good luck finding more then 7
include the penalty plays that weren't troy's fault
Originally posted by phatbutskinny:
include the penalty plays that weren't troy's fault

Thats what I'm leaning towards.
Yes, include ALL throws because this video is for entertainment purposes. Most of the time, viewers can see the penalty sign show up near the score anyway.
Originally posted by LionHeartofGold:
Yes, include ALL throws because this video is for entertainment purposes. Most of the time, viewers can see the penalty sign show up near the score anyway.

Ya, thats kinda what I'm thinking. The point is to show what he can do, not what he can do if nobody else screws up...lol. ;-)
If an Alex Smith NFL highlight video can be made from 6 or so plays, this one should be easy for you.

All we can do is joke now, fellas.
Originally posted by Joecool:
If an Alex Smith NFL highlight video can be made from 6 or so plays, this one should be easy for you.

All we can do is joke now, fellas.

god, i get depressed just thinking about how much time we wasted with him
  • Wodwo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 8,104
Originally posted by WestCoast:
Originally posted by Joecool:
If an Alex Smith NFL highlight video can be made from 6 or so plays, this one should be easy for you.

All we can do is joke now, fellas.

god, i get depressed just thinking about how much time we wasted with him

At least we're not the Redskins?

They held onto Jason Campbell for 52 starts before getting rid of him. We've given Alex Smith 47 starts.

Redskins gave up draft picks for McNabb. We got Troy for peanuts.

Silver lining?

Well, I tried...