There are 66 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

I think we cut the wrong QB !

Originally posted by modninerfan:
Originally posted by Ceadderman:
Originally posted by fister30:
I can't hope for injury for Alex Smith. The QB situation in SF is terrifying. Hopefully the rest of the team can carry the lame duck that plays under center.

So if we're successful with Smith under Center, then it's in spite of Smith? Is that what you're saying?

If this is the case, just go root for another team.

You'll never be happy so long as Smith is the Starter. And that's truly sad.

~Ceadder

these are the same type of fans that would have rooted for Montana to beat the 49ers when he was a Chief. Just like back in the day, these guys have already made up there mind... no matter what Alex does, it will never be enough to satisfy this type of Fan.

Let's be fair now, I rooted for Montana to beat us. Only because I wanted him to show us that he was still a damn good QB and to shut the haters (that said he sucks) down. Look at what Montana did with a team of nobodies. It was Montana, Marcus Allen and a bunch of nobodies Offensively. But I never rooted against Steve either. In that game I rooted for both QBs'.

Fixed. No need to get personal. You can dislike haters that's fine but no need to get warned over a personal attack on the haters

~Ceadder
just lock this thread, all its going to do is get people banned for talking s**t
Originally posted by FILTHpigskin:
Originally posted by 4949:
Originally posted by FILTHpigskin:
Originally posted by 4949:
Originally posted by FILTHpigskin:


LOL... looks like someone else doesn't know what a franchise QB is. Terrell Owens made Jeff Garcia what he was, and that was a slightly above average player at his position. You don't think that, with the weapons we currently have on offense, Smith could lead this team to the playoffs?

If Terrell Owens made Jeff Garcia why is it that TO put up his best numbers with Garcia as his QB and not McNabb or Romo?


Best numbers? His highest average per reception was 16.7 with Dallas in 2007. His highest yards per game was 109 with the Eagles in 2005. Terrell Owens was pretty consistent no matter who his QB was:

http://www.nfl.com/players/terrellowens/careerstats?id=OWE755129

I really hope you are kidding, You judge WRs by highest yards per game when they only reached 763 yards that season and think thats better then a year when they broke 1400 yards?

You mention he had higher yards per game one season with the eagles and higher yards per catch one year with the Cowboys but if you want to use stats that the rest of the world use to judge a WR check RECEPTIONS, YARDS, and TOUCHDOWNS. His highest in the areas that count was with the niners.


Yeah, my point was that Owens was consistent no matter who was throwing the ball. I just hope you're not trying to say that Jeff Garcia was better than McNabb or Romo.

I have to agree that TO made every QB look good, even Rattay.

Lots of TOs TD's while on the Niners were all YAC, TO breaking tackles and running circles around defenders
Originally posted by JeuSF49:
Well this looks like another Thomas Clayton/Marcus Maxwell story.
Clayton was suposed to be the next Emmit Smith/Walter Payton/Barry Sanders, and Maxwell was predesined to become the next Jerry Rice.

I honestly belive that Nate has more upside an more of a shot becoming a legitimate player in the NFL than the two mentioned earlyer.

Who?
All of you Nate Davis fanatics need to get your heads out of your asses now and wake up. He's just not NFL ready.

What we should learn from this.... preseason truly is meaningless. They are purely for practice and warming up for the regular season.
Originally posted by blm7754:
All of you Nate Davis fanatics need to get your heads out of your asses now and wake up. He's just not NFL ready.

What we should learn from this.... preseason truly is meaningless. They are purely for practice and warming up for the regular season.

And that's why he's going into the 49ers 6-year QB development program.
Originally posted by DesiDez:
Originally posted by blm7754:
All of you Nate Davis fanatics need to get your heads out of your asses now and wake up. He's just not NFL ready.

What we should learn from this.... preseason truly is meaningless. They are purely for practice and warming up for the regular season.

And that's why he's going into the 49ers 6-year QB development program.

And why not? The program hasn't worked so far...



Originally posted by cNiner:
It shows how Sing is not there at all, if you have no faith in your Back up qb aka Carr why keep him ? we should have cut him and moved on with troy Smith insted of getting rid of Nat lots of potanital Davis ! Sing got to question this decision

Cut the guy who has starting experience, knows our playbook, and has been in camp with the team all summer. In favor of a guy that will have to hurry up and learn the system, and has no chemistry with his receivers. That's genius.
Originally posted by NinerGM:
REALLY?

Okay EEEEEENough already.

Christ we're talking about the THIRD STRING QB!!!!!

I swear you would have thought we traded Vernon Davis and Patrick Willis to the Cardinald for Matt Lienart and a 7th round pick.

Again say it with me .....

THIRD STRING.

Updated: 4th String